Saturday, April 4, 2020
Home Opinions Ram Guha and Harsh Mander reach the same destination of bigotry, they just take...

Ram Guha and Harsh Mander reach the same destination of bigotry, they just take two different paths

Also Read

Nirwa Mehtahttps://medium.com/@nirwamehta
Politically incorrect. Author, Flawed But Fabulous.

‘Historian’ Ram Guha, whose sycophancy towards The Family is not hidden, has today written a response to an opinion written by ‘activist’ Harsh Mander. Harsh Mander’s article, ‘Sonia, Sadly’, writes about ‘political marginalisation of Muslims’ where he implicitly propagates ‘two nation theory’ advocated by Jinnah.

In his article, Mander talks how Muslims in India feel afraid and threatened. That they are forced to live in fear of hate violence. He goes on to blame Sonia Gandhi because he feels even Congress ‘alienated’ Muslims. He feels that many people think Muslims are a political liability, especially when a ‘Dalit leader’ had urged Muslims to join them in their rallies, keeping their ‘skullcaps and burkas’ at bay. He feels that this will voluntarily get Muslims to stay away from politics. He quotes an unnamed Congress MP who puts the onus on Hindus to decide whether they want India to become a Hindu Rashtra or remain secular. He says the BJP has created a ‘toxic majoritarian’ where Muslims are not ‘just irrelevant’ but are also ‘political bogeyman’, whose ‘visible support will frighten voters’.

To counter it, Guha has today written an article which he pretends is the other side of what Mander said. Guha starts off which politely disagreeing with Mander’s views saying how they have usually agreed on same things in the past. Guha likens wearing burka or skullcap to Hindus ‘flaunting saffron robes and trishuls at rallies’. As if comparing voluntarily and proudly wearing one’s religious identity to that of the centuries-old symbol of oppression like a burka wasn’t enough, Guha points out that while burka isn’t a ‘weapon’, in a symbolic sense it is akin to a ‘Trishul’. While there is no denying that some extreme elements use Trishul and sword as means of violence, calling it a weapon is like linking every burka-clad woman to the terrorist who wears a burka while escaping and accidentally blows himself off.

- article continues after ad - - article resumes -

Guha states that objecting wearing burka and skullcaps in public places is not asking Muslims to voluntarily back off, but it symbolises ‘liberation’. He then says how no Muslim should be denied the right to voice his criticism of Hindu leaders as feared by Mander. And he ‘detests’ Hindutva majoritarianism as much as Mander and since Hindus are the majority in India, their ‘communalism’ is far more ‘dangerous’ than ‘Muslim communalism’. Essentially, Muslims, who are the second largest majority in India, can continue doing their communalism, because it’s not ‘as dangerous’, according to Guha. He says how ‘liberals’ should promote individual interest against that of the community and hence they must take on both, Hindu and Muslim communalists. When Mandar says Muslims in India should be free to choose their leaders and campaign for those they support, Guha paints a picture where this is dangerous as Muslims should also be critical of Hindus who are ‘misled’ by Pravin Togadia and Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

It is interesting how the two have managed to paint the picture such that they are able to retain their ‘intellectual’ credentials while they camouflage their bigotry under the veil of liberalism. They water down a symbol of oppression like the Burqa and demonise a religious symbol like the Trishul. He puts the onus of any sort of communal violence on Hindus exonerating completely the Muslims and without so much as a mention of Islamic terrorism. He peddles the exact same communal and sectarian rationale that the Congress’ communal violence bill was based on, basically saying, that any communal violence is the Hindu’s fault and only Muslims can ever be declared the victims of it.

Essentially, while Mander tries to paint the Muslims as a big chunk of victims, Guha has repackaged that same argument to say Hindus are evil, instead of painting the Muslims as victims.

In the end, Mander and Guha reach the exact same destination of Hindu hatred and communal bigotry, they just pretend to take different paths to it.

- Support OpIndia -
Support OpIndia by making a monetary contribution

Trending now

Nirwa Mehtahttps://medium.com/@nirwamehta
Politically incorrect. Author, Flawed But Fabulous.

Latest News

Latest updates and important links about COVID-19 coronavirus

Live statistics and tracking of news related to COVID-19 coronavirus with focus on India.

IIT Roorkee and AIIMS Rishikesh develop closed-loop portable ventilator named as ‘Praan-Vayu’ for COVID-19 patients

The ‘Praan-Vayu’ Ventilator is based on controlled operation of the prime mover that delivers enough air to the patient.

Madhya Pradesh: Police register FIR against fruit vendor after a video of him contaminating the fruits with his saliva goes viral

The police registered the FIR against the fruit vendor on the basis of a complaint lodged by a youth named Bodhraj Tipta

Tablighi Jamaat members kept in Madhu resort in Agra throw tantrums, refuse to eat prescribed healthy food, demand spicy beef biryani

Tablighi Jamaat members are turning out to be quite a headache for the authorities and medical staffs

Karnataka: Muslim mob pelts stones at police officials after being stopped from offering mass namaz defying coronavirus lockdown

Muslim mob in Hubbali attacked police personnel with stone pelting when the cops tried to stop them from offering namaz en masse

No pills, Sharing unwashed utensils, washroom and water for Wuzu: How Tablighi Jamaat’s lifestyle made them super-spreaders

Man who had stayed at Delhi centre of Tablighi Jamaat said that poor community practices were reasons they emerged as 'super-spreader'

Recently Popular

“May Allah send a virus that kills 50 crores Indians”: Bengal Maulvi roared from the stage, video goes viral

May Allah send such a terrible virus to India that ten to twenty to fifty crore people die in India, the Maulvi said to an applauding crowd

Tablighi Jamaat members kept in Ghaziabad hospital roam naked in the ward, make lewd gestures toward female staff

The Chief Medical Officer of the District MMG Hospital in Ghaziabad has written a letter to the Ghaziabad police informing about criminal behaviour of the Jamaatis

Did you know that the Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund has always had the President of Congress party in its managing committee

After PM Modi launched PM CARES Fund, a lot has been discussed about similarities and differences between PM CARES Fund and PMNRF

Nasik police arrest Muslim man after video of him wiping his face with currency note and saying “Coronavirus is Allah’s punishment to you” went...

The man was seen saying that the coronavirus has no treatment because it is sent by ‘Allah’, while licking the notes

In video message, PM Modi asks citizens for 9 minutes on 5th April at 9 PM: Here is what he wants us to do

Prime Minister Modi in a video message announced that on 5th April, the nation has to come together to show their grit and collective strength.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Each morning, get an email to keep updated with all the news, opinions and analysis published by OpIndia.

Connect with us

217,359FansLike
271,158FollowersFollow
211,000SubscribersSubscribe
Advertisements