Home Opinions How Indian 'liberals' supporting Article 370 are like the racists in 50s and 60s America

How Indian ‘liberals’ supporting Article 370 are like the racists in 50s and 60s America

Indian liberals, like that Alabama Governor, can “stand in the door” all they want, supporting Article 370 and crying for “states’ rights.” But history will not be kind to them.

Yesterday, the Government of India scrapped Article 370, making every Indian an equal citizen, from Kashmir to Kanyakumari. It sent Indian liberals into a tizzy.

All through the day, the government faced all sorts of absurd questions. How can a Constitutional change be made so quickly, they asked, completely forgetting that Article 35A was sneaked into the Constitution through a Presidential decree in 1954, like a thief in the night. Completely forgetting that Article 370 was supposed to be a temporary provision. There were the typical allegations of the government resorting to majoritarian rule. As if democracy is anything else. One liberal went so far as to suggest that this decision of the Govt of India, which makes everyone an equal citizen, is comparable to untouchability or the lynching of black people in the US back in the 50s and 60s!

And people wonder why it is so hard to take liberal “intellectuals” seriously.

- Ad - - article resumes -

I would have laughed away the ridiculous comparison, except that the person in question happened to be a much-decorated “Professor” of all kinds of made-up stuff. His words are usually taken seriously and often quoted in newspapers and on television.

So it really got me thinking about the history of racial injustice, segregation and how it was countered. That’s when you realize just how frightening and regressive the Indian liberal stance on Article 370 really is.

Untitled.png

This is a famous 1963 photograph of Alabama Governor George Wallace standing in protest at the door of the University of Alabama. His mission? To prevent black students from entering the all-white university.

But because of an order from a federal judge, the governor of the state can do nothing. He must allow black students at the university.

The governor insists that the federal government has no right to interfere at the state university and let black students in. He does so in the name of “states rights.”

Sound familiar?

How different is this from those who speak of the autonomy of Jammu and Kashmir and say that Indian citizens from all other states must stay out? How far are Indian liberals from “standing at the door” like Governor George Wallace, demanding that India must enforce segregation?

When you go further into details, you see that the arguments being bandied around by liberals in support of Article 370 are uncannily similar to those of racial segregationists in the United States.

You see, until around 1965, a bunch of American states used to enforce what were called “Jim Crow laws.” These laws mandated segregation between white people and black people in all public spaces. Separate schools, separate clubs, separate bathrooms and the like. And black people would have to sit in a separate section at the back of the bus.

Then, in the 1950s, a period of reformation began. In 1954, the US Supreme Court famously ruled (Brown v Board of Education) that states could no longer segregate schools by race.

What was the excuse of those who wanted to keep the schools segregated? States’ rights!

Then, in 1964, the Federal Government passed the Civil Rights Act which said no government could discriminate on the basis of race.

How did the racists fight back? You guessed it: States’ rights!

In 1965, the Federal Government passed the Voting Rights Act, which imposed special rules on states and districts with a reputation for preventing black people from voting by various means.

How did the racists fight back? You guessed it: States’ rights!

And today, how are liberals trying to stop the Govt of India from making everyone an equal citizen? States’ rights! The autonomy of J&K, they say.

In 1973, the US Supreme Court handed down another landmark judgement in the case of Roe v Wade, giving women everywhere the right to decide whether to have an abortion.

How did the opponents fight back against the liberation of women? They said it was interfering with states’ rights.

Today when the abolition of Article 370 has finally given equal property rights to Kashmiri women, how are liberals fighting back? They say it is against the autonomy of J&K!

Why was homosexuality still a crime in J&K despite the SC judgement last year? Because of Article 370. Now that gay people have rights in J&K, how are liberals trying to block them?

By using the excuse of states’ rights!

So that’s Indian liberalism for you. Supporting segregation by race. Against property rights for women. Supporting the criminalization of homosexuality. By using the same argument that racial segregationists used to employ in the US in the 1950s and 1960s.

Oh and before we forget: why did the Civil War happen in the United States? Because the Southern states wanted to keep slavery. They argued that the Federal Government abolishing slavery was against the autonomy of states.

So Indian liberals, like that Alabama Governor, can “stand in the door” all they want, supporting Article 370 and crying for “states’ rights.” But history will not be kind to them.

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Big Story

Strange rumours are coming out of Kashmir. Shah Faesal, supposedly, is Doval's stooge.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

Pakistan takes a cue from Congress yet again, asks ‘what happened to Rafale investigation’

In case Chaudhry missed out, the first Rafale jet is expected to be delivered next month.

NDTV’s Interim CEO Suparna Singh resigns with immediate effect

NDTV interim CEO Suparna Singh, whose appointment as CEO was not approved by I&B ministry, has stepped down
Hartosh Singh Bal resorts to factually incorrect details to target Amit Shah

Fact-Check: Unlike Chidambaram who tried to escape from law, Amit Shah resolutely faced trial and was acquitted

Hartosh Singh Bal equated P Chidambaram's disgraceful escape with Amit Shah's tenacity to face the law

Political Editor of The Hindu condones violence by Congress workers who beat up a man who shouted ‘Chidambaram Chor Hai’

Congress worker beats up a man for shouting 'Chidambaram Chor Hai', The Hindu Political Editor Nistula Hebbar shows excitement at the unruly behaviour.

P Chidambaram finally arrested by CBI after officers scale wall of his residence as the gates were locked

Chidambaram arrested from his residence after he addressed a press conference at Congress office

Former Pakistan army chief says Pakistan will use Kartarpur corridor to revive Khalistani terrorism in India

Gen Mirza Aslam Beg has said Pakistan army and the government should create trouble for India through Khalistan movement

Read about the P Chidambaram link in the new FIR filed against NDTV by the CBI

It appears that the INX Media case, the new FIR against NDTV and arrest of P Chidambaram are all interconnected.
Imran Khan has defended terrorists on Twitter

Imran ‘Taliban’ Khan goes on a bizarre defense of terrorists who may have infiltrated India disguised as Hindus

If harbouring, nourishing and sending terrorists to India was not enough, Pakistan has now shed all pretence and has been officially using terrorism as its state policy.

Is Shah Faesal Ajit Doval’s asset? Unlikely, Swati Chaturvedi may be unwittingly helping the central government

Strange rumours are coming out of Kashmir. Shah Faesal, supposedly, is Doval's stooge.
Rajiv Gandhi's tenure saw justice, freedom and institutions compromised at every level

No Sonia Gandhi, your husband did not stand for democracy or liberty

Rajiv Gandhi had infamously justified the Sikh massacre by saying, "When a big tree falls, the earth shakes."
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

181,299FansLike
172,747FollowersFollow
90,967SubscribersSubscribe
Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post