In a video that has now gone viral online, the anchor of a show on Pakistan news channel, Newsone, can be heard making a vile anti-Hindu comment while trying to hold India responsible for the landmine blast in South Balochistan on May 1 that has left 6 Pakistani soldiers and a Major dead.
While trying to take potshots at India, the anchor said, “Hindu Bania aab aukat se bahar nikalna lag gaya hai“. It loosely translates as “Hindu Bania is going out of hands.” The video was aired in Pakistan on 9th May 2020.
At around 3 minute into the video, the news anchor, while holding India responsible for the instability in Pakistan, says that Pakistani Army’s restrain should not be considered its weakness. “Till when will we stay quiet because now the Hindu Bania has crossed all limits,” he says.
Further, in the video, Pakistani academician Qamar Cheema, who also appears on debates on Indian news channels, while lamenting on lack of propaganda mechanism in Pakistan said, “We in Pakistan don’t have English media. India’s English media does the propaganda, what are we left doing in Pakistan? There are hardly 2-3 (English) newspapers, how will the world know? The world does not know Urdu. We are anyway weak in English, we don’t have English channels and now if India negotiates with Taliban..”
Showering praises on Prime Minister Imran Khan’s way of handling his Twitter account, Qamar Cheema further said, “I believe the miracles Imran Khan’s Twitter handle has done are second to none. No other Prime Minister of Pakistan has ever tweeted on India’s aggression in Pakistan the way Imran Khan does. Khan sahab’s tweets become headlines in international media. But we must discover new avenues.”
The news programme was based on the recent attack in Balochistan, carried out by the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) that has been fighting for Independence from Pakistan State. A spokesperson of the armed group said that the military has been carrying out operations in Tigran and other areas of Turbat in Balochistan and has primarily targeted women and children. The landmine attack was a part of the plan to avenge the harassment meted out to the civilians.
However, despite the fact that the responsibility for the attack was taken by the BLA, the Pakistani News channel seemed hell-bent on framing India’s role in the attack by citing a statement made by Retired Major Gaurav Arya on Republic TV.
Hinduphobia in Pakistan
This is not the first time that such a bigoted, anti-Hindu statement has been made by someone in the media or politics. On ‘Kashmir Solidarity Day’ which is observed in Pakistan and by Kashmiri separatists, Pakistani leader spewed venom against the Hindus by putting up a poster declaring that Hindus can be taught a lesson only by violence, not dialogue. The poster read, “Hindu baat sen nahin, last see maanta hai.” Earlier in March, a Pakistani propaganda media outlet spread fake news that a Muslim girl was being raped by Hindus in Delhi’s Jafrabad.
On Monday, Congress leader and Leader of Congress party in Lok Sabha – Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury took to Twitter to issue some warnings to China and praise the Indian forces. However, he soon deleted the tweet.
The Congress leader, slamming China, warned the communist nation about how Indian forces can ‘defang the venomous snakes’ like China and stated that the entire world was watching the sinister designs of China while calling them “Yellow expansionist”.
Chowdhury also urged the Modi government to accord to diplomatic recognition to Taiwan “without much delay” .
It is notable here that Taiwan has donated 10 lakh face masks to India as the country fights the novel coronavirus outbreak. The Island nation is claimed by China as its territory which opposes its international recognition.
However, Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury’s bluster against China did not last long. He soon deleted his tweet, leaving twitter users to wonder what might have been the reason. The racial slur also received wide criticism by many.
???So many problems with this from the leader of @INCIndia in Lok Sabha 1- Sounds infantile 2- ad hominem name calling 3- "yellow expansionist"?! Sounds racist. Adhir not knowing that isn't an excuse 4- Ask @ShashiTharoor to draft it. This is embarrassing 5-Taiwan? WTAF? pic.twitter.com/hJQIq0I6Ku
The Gandhi-scion, not once but twice, was caught meeting Chinese officials, raising suspicion among the policymakers regarding the intent of his secretive meeting with the Chinese.
The first meeting had taken place in 2017, when Rahul Gandhi had a meeting with Chinese Ambassador to India Luo Zhaohui, especially at a time when India and China were in the middle of a stand-off at Doklam. At first, the Congress party had denied such meetings and had termed news reports suggesting that the Gandhi-scion had indeed met Chinese officials as ‘fake news’.
However, Congress party had to face massive embarrassment after it was caught that the Chinese embassy had issued an official statement confirming the meeting between the Congress vice president and the Chinese envoy.
This meeting was especially suspicious, because the Congress party and Rahul Gandhi, at that time were vehemently attacking the Indian government over their stand in the ongoing military standoff with China.
Again in 2018, Rahul Gandhi had himself revealed regarding the secret meeting with a couple of Chinese ministers during his trip to Kailash Mansarovar in September 2018. The meeting was kept secret initially but later Rahul Gandhi had revealed the details of the meeting accidentally leading to people to speculate even more as to why both the Congress party and China were trying to hide the meeting.
Rahul Gandhi, the then president of India’s main opposition party secretly meeting the government officials of China and taking steps to keep the meetings secret had raised quite a few eyebrows back then.
Adhir Chowdhury and his controversial statements
The Congress leader is known for his often controversial statements. Last year, he had stoked another controversy by stating inside the parliament that how can the state of Jammu and Kashmir be an internal matter if it is being monitored by the UN since 1948.
Home Minister Amit Shah had shut him up by saying that when he talks about Jammu and Kashmir, he talks about the state in its entirety.
Congress distances itself
After Adhir Choudhury’s tweet created criticism and speculations, the Congress party has distanced itself. Congress’ Rajya Sabha MP Anand Sharma has tweeted that Adhir’s tweet is his personal opinion and do not reflect the party’s stand. Sharma has added that the Congress recognises and values the special strategic partnership between India and China.
Take a look at this interesting graph that suggests how we could be living at the cusp of one of the biggest transition time that we are seeing in over many centuries:
How the world history has seen major turning points over centuries
With the coronavirus pandemic sending almost the entire world in a lockdown, the realisation that these times are ‘not normal’ has become pronounced, but if we look at the trends, it seems that this radical transitional phase was waiting to take place around this time.
The study of time cycles is non-linear and it needs intuition as much as empirical faculties. Financial analysts see the world from the lens of 2008 global financial crisis while political analysts benchmark their ideas to 1990s. It is intuitively difficult to comprehend the large-scale death and despair during 1929-1942 or the indigenous wisdom that existed before 1770s in Asia and Europe.
However, gradually it is becoming clear that we are now in a phase that will see a new world order emerge after the coronavirus crisis is over, or at least subsides.
We have seen how the most powerful politicians, businesses and policies of the last century are biting the dust across the globe. In the past five years, we are seeing how global trade, economics of John Maynard Keynes, crude oil prices, and WTO are crumbling. It seems the old order is giving way to a new world order, albeit through a painful transition process.
Let us look briefly at the history before we try to gaze into the future.
Culture gives way to modernity
There is a belief that the modern world started around 1770s with the American revolution and the industrial revolution. With it came the faith that the human intellect and labour can help us achieve just about everything. The belief served us well till about the turn of this decade.
It also led to widespread conviction that mechanization and modern rationality is somewhat superior to the lived human experience, or as I call it culture. Naturally people started to gradually sacrifice unique human sensibilities at the altar of industrialisation.
For example, we lost certain indigenous wisdom which could enable us to predict the timing and extent of rainfall in an area, the optimum nutrition required for a plant or usage of cow dung as organic manure, coolant, binder and disinfectant, etc.
The focus on labour and intellect in the industrial era led to withering away of core faculties that helped human beings survive for thousands of years. Politicians soon devised strategies to control the labour and the mind, which led to a decline in communitarian values and resilience, and led to mass migration to cities.
The Great Depression and the World War II led to loss of lives and livelihood. The wealthy world gave the starving world food and a red book.
Modernity gives way to modern slavery
The book, which pegged all of world’s problems to inequality, had a rather simple solution. It asked all disempowered people to unite and organize through one mammoth political organisation. As it is, the hungry people can do anything for food.
When you turn half of the world into industrial labourers and poor people uprooted from their land, they will fall for a promise of a better world no matter how impracticable it is. The philosophy of Leftism gained popular support and in no time became the guiding light of governments, politics, power brokers, academia, politics, economics, and historical narratives.
In poor countries like India, the ruling British distributed leftist books freely to the most hardened freedom fighters jailed in Andaman Cellular Jail as a means to absolve them from the sins of waging war against the Queen and to “educate” them.
In an ironic way, people were queuing up to surrender their personal and intellectual freedom to realise dreams of a revolution. This revolution was not limited just to bringing about radial political changes, but almost in every aspect of life.
Control by Leftists becomes entrenched
Mind control was just not enough. Leftists needed power, brute power, to effect large scale and rapid “development’’ for poor nations. For example, governments needed to be centralised so that they can give licences to only a favoured few, land holding needed to be reorganized to help “connected” business men to set up coal mines, oil wells, hazardous chemical factories and nuclear power plants, etc.
The biggest strength of the leftist system was that it could organically permeate into the prevailing status quo and ultimately influence their outcomes. Status-quo-ism as espoused through United Nations, NATO, ILO, WHO, etc. without addressing existing repression and imbalance, is a dangerous statecraft. Also, the leftist system favoured deterministic and empirical analysis over human values, sharing, compassion, cultural and indigenous sciences.
Even though communism as an authoritative political system collapsed and couldn’t survive beyond North Korea and China, the leftist ideas got entrenched almost everywhere, including in the USA, the supposed capitalist heaven.
Are we looking at Left losing its monopoly?
With the world now set to enter a new era, can we say that we are going to see a new world order where the Leftists are not going to have the same amount of control and power as they came to enjoy following the earlier cycles of change?
Leftists used to belittle anything traditional, conservative, cultural, indigenous, or spiritual. But of late, we have seen communities and nations realising that this blind disowning of their roots, of their culture, of their old ways, was nowhere as scientific and modern as it was made out to be.
The mere realisation that the millennia old tradition of “namaste” is safer than modern handshake during the pandemic is just a small example. Even before the pandemic, the world had seen rise of so-called right-wing political parties in various parts of the world.
People, including and especially at the lowest rung of economic hierarchy – who were supposed to be the main audience and foot soldiers to keep the bastion of Left strong – are realising that they have turned too much away from their core values of sharing, sustainable living and culture. Often, they see the elite “woke” class preaching and attacking the ideas they believe in. the class conflict has turned on its head of late.
I personally believe that the time is just right where finally the monopoly of the left can be overthrown, not necessarily though a bloody revolution that the left believes in, but due to the fact that we indeed are at the cusp of a civilisational change.
The non-left has to grab this opportunity. We have to delve into our own culture, tradition, indigenous, or spiritual wisdom to complement our 20th century intellectual faculties. If we do that, we might just make the new world order that is less fake and less exploitative.
The capitulation of this exploitative system started in 2016-2017, as one can see in the graph at the beginning of this article, and we will see a decisive turn in 2020-2021. The foundation of a new world is being laid now.
The Mamata Banerjee-led West Bengal government has reportedly abandoned the stranded tourists stuck in Uttarakhand as the state government has been unresponsive despite repeated requests have been made by them.
Reportedly, hundreds of tourists from West Bengal are stranded in Haridwar since the beginning of the lockdown and the Mamata Banerjee-led government has not bothered to make any arrangements to allow them to return to the state, the Uttarakhand government said.
Uttarakhand: Around 700 tourists from West Bengal are stranded in Haridwar since the #CoronavirusLockdown had begun. They say, "we are not facing any problem here, but we want to return to our homes. We request Mamata didi to make arrangements for us to return home." (11.5) pic.twitter.com/zWfjAs6ZYK
Speaking to ANI, the tourists have stated that though they are not facing any problems in Uttarakhand, but they have been stranded there since the beginning of the lockdown in March and are anxious to return home. They have requested CM Mamata Banerjee to make arrangements for their safe return to home.
According to Uttarakhand Cabinet minister and government spokesperson Madan Kaushik, there are nearly 700 people from West Bengal who are stuck in the holy city Haridwar amidst coronavirus lockdown. The minister said that the first communication with the West Bengal government to send back the tourists was made when the lockdown was initially imposed, back in March.
“We are requesting the West Bengal government, again and again, to take their people back because these tourists are in a state of panic and they want to go home. But no response has been received yet from there,” minister Kaushik said.
The minister added that even though the Uttarakhand government has made arrangements for their stay, food and medical facilities, the stranded people from Bengal wanted to return. A senior official said to Indian Express that a lot of stranded tourists were from Bengal.
UP and Haryana have already taken their tourists
Earlier, a large number of tourists of Uttar Pradesh and Haryana returned to their state after respective state governments arranged bus facilities for them. However, the West Bengal government is yet to make arrangements for the stranded tourists.
However, a senior government official from West Bengal refuted the Uttarkhand minister’s statements and said they are in touch with all the states where tourists from Bengal are stranded. West Bengal officials have stated that they are in the process of making arrangements for the return of the tourists.
Home Minister writes to Mamata Banerjee regarding the migrant crisis
The controversy surrounding Mamata Banerjee-led government come a day after Union Home Minister Amit Shah had written to West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee expressing disappointment over West Bengal government’s reluctance to extend support to help migrant workers reach home.
In the letter to Mamata Banerjee, Amit Shah has stated that the Centre is not getting the required support from the state government to handle the migrant workers.
According to the reports, the Home Minister has said that the Central government is operating Shramik special trains to facilitate the return of migrant labourers to their native places, but Mamata Banerjee-led state government is not co-operating. Home Minister Shah has also demanded an answer on the Mamata government’s inaction over the migrants’ distress in Bengal.
Former Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh has tested negative for Chinese coronavirus and is likely to be discharged from hospital on Tuesday. As reported by Times of India, his fever is under control and he was tested for COVID-19 as a measure of abundant precaution. He is stable now and ready to be discharged.
While Dr Singh was initially kept in the cardiac ICU, but he was later shifted to a private room where a team of doctors monitored his vitals. Dr Singh is diabetic and a heart patient and has undergone two bypass surgeries.
Dr Manmohan Singh admitted to AIIMS
On Sunday late evening, Dr Manmohan Singh was admitted to Delhi’s AIIMS after he got fever and complained of chest pain. Dr Singh had redeveloped a febrile reaction to a new medication. He was kept under observation to rule out any other causes of the fever.
Dr Manmohan Singh is 87. He has served two consecutive terms (2004-2014) as India’s Prime Minister. He is one of the senior-most leaders of the Congress party. Prior to becoming the PM, Dr Singh was the finance minister in the PV Narasimha Rao government from 1991 to 1996. Prior to that, he served as the Chief Economic Advisor (1972-76) and as the Governor of the Reserve Bank from 1982 to 1985. He was also the head of the Planning Commission from 1985 to 1987.
Although the Delhi Government has claimed a total of 73 Coronavirus deaths in the State, yet an ITO Kabristan dedicated to deceased Coronavirus patients has witnessed 96 burials so far, reported AajTak.
In a video uploaded by the news channel, health officials could be seen burying the body of a deceased in accordance with Coronavirus protocols. Covered in PPE overalls, the health workers ensured compliance with all safety measures while performing the last rites of the deceased. A JCB machine was even employed to dig the pit for the burial.
According to the ground reporter Milan Sharma, cemetery records state that the said burial marked the 96th case of burial of a Coronavirus patient at the ITO Kabristan that is spread over 5 bighas or 1-acre land and dedicated to performing the last rites of such infected people. As such, there is a mismatch between the Delhi Government data and the actual number of deaths caused in the State due to the Chinese virus. It must be reiterated that the ITO cemetery is just one of the several burial grounds in the State.
Earlier, Dainik Bhaskar reported that while the Delhi Government had claimed only 68 Coronavirus deaths till May 2, cremations and burials conducted in accordance with Coronavirus protocols, exceeded a whopping 300. The Chairman of the Standing Committee of North MCD, Jayprakash JP accused the Delhi Government of playing politics over the issue and forging the data. Moreover, the actual number of deaths at hospitals in Delhi also contradicted the data provided by the Delhi Government.
Mumbai-based advocate Chandni Shah has filed a complaint with the cyber cell of Delhi against Delhi-based lawyer Rizwan Nizami for allegedly sharing a Photoshopped image of the Jain Bakeries and Confectionaries store in Chennai claiming that the store does not employ any Muslims and hence it is religious discrimination. On 8 May, Nizami had tweeted an image expressing anger that a Chennai-based bakery had said it does not employ Muslim bakers.
After the image went viral on social media platforms, police arrested Prasanth, the owner of the bakery, and booked him under various sections of the IPC. The shop owner has been booked under sections 153 (provocation to cause riot), 153A, 505 (inciting commission of an offence against another community) and 295A (insult a class of people) IPC.
As per Advocate Shah, the original advertisement of the bakery did not have the ‘No Muslim Staff’ on it but the image was circulated by the bakery to those who questioned who were employed in the kitchen.
No, this photoshopped image was circulated by the bakery but not as an advertisement. It was given out on whatsapp in answer to the queries whether spl community ppl are working there ? But this man here, posted the image on twitter portraying that the bakery is discriminating.
— Adv. Chandni Shah (@adv_chandnishah) May 11, 2020
As per Advocate Chandni Shah, the original advertisement did not have the ‘No Muslim Staff’ text.
Image courtesy @adv_chandnishah on Twitter
The incident comes close on heels of multiple incidents where Muslims have deliberately indulged in spitting on food. Many videos exposing Muslim vegetable and fruit-sellers spitting on their produce, presumably to spread coronavirus had gone viral recently.
Just a few days back, an equally appalling incident has come to light from a bakery in Maharashtra’s Amravati. The viral video is from a bakery in the Amravati district of Maharashtra where an individual, Abdul Nazim Sheikh Mahmood (29), was seen slicing the loaves of bread and spitting on them.
Earlier in March, a video of a certain Sheru Miyan, licking the fruits which he displays in a cart for sale went viral on social media. In the video, the fruit vendor in Raisen, Madhya Pradesh, is seen arranging a variety of fruits on his cart, which he parks in the middle of a marketplace.
Such viral videos have left everyone wary of the community.
Halal is mainstream
It may be noted that nowadays many food products are label as Halal certified, which means not only that the products are manufactured according to Islamic practices, but many times it also means that only Muslims are employed in the entire production and packaging chain of such Halal certified products. For example, the guidelines for preparing Halal certified meat make it abundantly clear that only Muslim employees are allowed to participate in the entire process at every stage from slaughtering to packaging, and if any non-Muslim is involved in the process, the product becomes Haram, or not allowed as per Islam.
Wobbled by the double whammy of global outrage against China for its incriminating role in concealing the Wuhan coronavirus outbreak initially and the growing recognition of Taiwan for its transcendent handling of coronavirus crisis, bellicose Chinese diplomats across the world have resorted to trumpeting the hackneyed refrain of ‘One-China principle’ in a bid to influence the international discourse concerning Taiwan’s participation in the World Health Organisation.
Replicating this obsession over the ‘One-China principle’, the Spokesperson of the Chinese Embassy in India, Ji Rong, today posted a series of tweets urging the Indian media organisations to take a “correct stance” on Taiwan’s participation in the World Health Organisation’s activities.
Under One-China principle, China’s Central Government has made proper arrangement for the Taiwan region’s participation in global health affairs, which ensures the region can deal with local or global public health emergencies in a timely and effective manner. (2/4)
“China’s position on Taiwan region’s participation in WHO activities, including WHA is clear and consistent. It must be handled according to the One-China principle, ” Rong tweeted while trotting out banal claims that under ‘One-China principle’ the Chinese government has made proper arrangement for Taiwan region’s participation in the global health affairs that has ensured the region to deal with local and global emergencies in a timely and efficacious manner.
Amidst the raging coronavirus pandemic, Taiwan’s model to curb the spread of the virus and its friendly overtures with nations seeking its help to combat the scourge of COVID-19 is winning plaudits from across the globe. By contrast, China’s belligerent and opaque stance on coronavirus has attracted criticism from many countries who have now turned into coronavirus hotspots after the virus reportedly first emerged from the central Chinese town of Wuhan. Nations staggering under the pandemic are lauding Taiwan for its exceptional handling of the crisis and for being forthcoming in sharing their experiences with them.
To this end, many countries have advocated Taiwan’s inclusion in the upcoming World Health Assembly (WHA), the decision-making body of the World Health Organization (WHO). However, this has not sat well with the Chinese diplomats, who are trying all the diplomatic means at their disposal to dissuade governments and the local media from voicing support for Taiwan.
Consequently, the Spokesman of the Chinese Embassy in India, Rong alleged that the Democratic Progressive Party of Taiwan is using the issue of coronavirus to engage in political manipulation hyping-up the issue to extract advantage and seek “independence”, rather than caring about the health and welfare of the people in Taiwan.
We urge relevant Indian media take a correct stance on this issue & adhere to the One-China principle, a widely accepted universal consensus of the international community including the Indian government. (4/4)
Also, Rong urged the Indian Media to take a “correct stance” in adherence to “One-China principle”, which the Chinese diplomat claimed was a widely held consensus, including that by the Indian government.
Backlash against China building amongst coronavirus-hit nations
As the global backlash builds against China for its initial mishandling of the coronavirus crisis and its opacity about the pandemic, Taiwan is increasingly asserting its independence to undermine Beijing’s efforts to isolate the self-ruled democratic island that it claims as its own. With its remarkable success in taming the coronavirus so far, Taiwan is advocating itself as a model of democracy to try to undercut China’s propaganda campaign aimed to tout the supremacy of its autocratic governance.
Countries across the world who are reeling under the coronavirus crisis have recognised, appreciated and sought help from Taiwan to blunt the spread of contagion. The greater global recognition to Taiwan has given China the willies. It is now aggressively and combatively using its enormous heft to denounce countries recognising Taiwan and warning them of economic and diplomatic fallout should they continue to flout its “one-China” principle.
China’s rant against Indian newspapers
This is not the first time that Chinese diplomats have delivered a homily against Indian media organisations. Recently, the Chinese embassy in India censured an Indian newspaper ‘The Hindu’ for publishing an opinion piece penned by Taiwan’s health minister Chen Shih-Chung. In the article, Chen propounded Taiwan’s exemplary strategy in curbing the sinister spread of the contagion in the country.
Chen’s exhortations to include Taiwan into WHO was enough to raise the hackles of the Chinese Embassy in India counsellor Ji Rong who issued a strong-worded statement denouncing the Indian media outlet for disregarding China’s sovereignty and territorial integrity by providing a platform to Taiwan’s health minister. Refuting the article that advocated “Taiwan’s participation in WHO”, the embassy asked the media organisation to adhere to the one-China principle and not provide a platform for “Taiwan independence” forces.
Before this, the Chinese embassy in India had slammed another Indian Newspaper The Times of India for interviewing Taiwan’s foreign minister. The interview of Taiwan’s foreign minister by an Indian daily was termed as defiance of its “internationally recognised one-China principle”. Restating China’s long-standing position on Taiwan’s participation in WHO, the Chinese Embassy in India Counselor Ji Rong exhorted the media organisation to recognise the gravity of the problem and refrain from providing a platform to “Taiwan independence” forces.
Mili Gazette, a media outlet specifically for Muslims, has come out resolutely in the defence of the discriminatory Islamic practice of Halal certification. It claimed that the hashtag ‘Boycott Halal Products’ which has been trending on microblogging site Twitter is “a sugar coated way of persecuting Indian Muslims and exhibiting bigotry”. They labelled the opposition to Halal as ‘Islamophobia’. They claimed that no one should be bothered by the discriminatory practice of Halal and insinuated that the only reason anyone could possibly have any objection to Halal products is due to Islamophobia.
All most 99% companies seeking halal certificate must be getting it without changing anything in their process. A halal certificate on a non-meat product should not bother anyone one bit. And for meat products, why are Right wing Hindus even bothered?
Mili Gazette stated further, “Bigots claim: “We will not follow Sharia Rules. Why impose Halal on Non-muslims”. Imposing? Is anyone forcing ppl to buy halal “garam masala”? Moreover, where is there a sharia rule to make “garam masala”? It is just that no ingredient in it, is something forbidden in Islam. They added, “Bigots claim: Halal Certified product means kind of tax, are we living in Muslim country & paying Jizya? A tax? Certification is a one time fee, may be renewed at some intervals. But certainly not a “tax”. But here bigots want to parrot the word “jizya” and spread hate,” said the Islamic media portal.
Halal Certification is Discriminatory: Here is how
The implication here is that nobody is forcing anyone to buy Halal products and completely obfuscates the fact that Halal meat can only be prepared by Muslims and involves the chanting of Islamic prayers. Non-Muslims cannot participate in the production of Halal meat at any stage of the manufacturing of the product. Thus, when Muslims insist on only Halal food, they are also choosing who gets to make the product. Thus, effectively, it creates a monopoly for the community in the meat production industry and actively discriminates against individuals of other faiths in employment opportunities.
Thus, it is easy to understand why people of other communities might have a problem with that. It is not ‘Islamophobia’ to fight against discriminatory practices. Furthermore, Halal also mandates that animals must be slaughtered according to Islamic practices. Furthermore, the point that Mili Gazette purposefully obfuscates is that the trend is not directed against Muslims but the specific practice which discriminates against non-Muslims. To call it ‘Islamophobia’ only reveals the corrupted mindset of such individuals.
Mili Gazette also claims that there’s nothing wrong with Halal certification of non-meat products that charges a fee. But it is only natural that other communities will not be willing for businesses to cower before Islamic organisations in order to secure a certification the cost of which will be earned back from Muslim and non-Muslim customers alike. Therefore, whether it’s a one time fee or repetitive, non-Muslims should not be expected to subsidise the discriminatory religious practices of Muslims.
Mili Gazette Justifies Economic Boycott of Muslims
By justifying Halal, which is a discriminatory practice that discriminates against non-Muslims in employment, Mili Gazette is also justifying the economic boycott of the Muslim community since it is entirely up to people from other faiths to decide whether they wish to justify the discriminatory religious faith of the Muslim community. When Mili Gazette asks, “Why are right wing Hindus even bothered?,” they should not be bothered either if Hindus advocate the boycott of Halal products. Furthermore, if Muslim businesses can advocate for a practice and defend one that discriminates against people from other communities when it comes to employment, they cannot complain if non-Muslims refuse to hire Muslims in their business establishments.
Recently, the Chennai police had arrested an owner of a pure vegetarian Bakery for putting out cautionary information stating that it employed no Muslims to prepare food items. Reportedly, the owner of Jain Bakeries and Confectioneries in Chennai’s T Nagar had put out an advertisement on Whatsapp pointing out that all their orders are “made by Jains” and no Muslim staff were engaged for the purpose. Quite evidently, it was a blatant misuse of law by the Police as the owner had done absolutely nothing that is not practised by Muslims on a daily basis. Thus, it appears that the Mili Gazette and Chennai Police believe that it is permissible for the Muslim community to discriminate against non-Muslims but should non-Muslims decide to return the favour., then it is ‘Islamophobia’ and they must be arrested.
With the country facing an unprecedented crisis in the form of the raging coronavirus outbreak, citizens of all hues are largely complying with the government-mandated orders to depress the spread of the infection, including the Army personnel, who are amongst the country’s front-line defence against the novel coronavirus. However, some individuals, like AAP legislator, Rajendra Pal Gautam, attempted to stir up public opinion against the Indian Army by claiming that Indian Army jawans are insulted by their superiors with casteist slurs and remarks.
Condemning the incident, Gautam tagged PM Modi and Defence Minister Rajnath Singh in his tweet and implored them to take cognisance of the matter and initiate stringent action against the culprit to ensure such incidents are repeated in the future.
However, soon after AAP leader Rajendra Pal Gautam shared a video of an Army Jawan accusing his senior of using casteist slurs against him, the Indian Army issued a strong-worded clarification, condemning the circulation and curation of an outdated video to malign the country’s Armed Forces. It was said that circulating the video without verifying it with the Army was regrettable. The Indian Army said that it is proud of all the soldiers from the Indian society without any reference to caste, creed or religion.
Indian Army strongly condemns posting of such videos (2017), curated & circulated again by enemy agents. Uploading it without verifying with Army is regrettable. Army is proud of braves from whole Indian society without any reference to caste, creed or religion: Indian Army pic.twitter.com/2vLV7nmdYK
The Army stated that the video is three-years-old and is circulated by elements hostile to the Indian Army. The video that was shared by AAP legislator Gautam today was found with the time stamp of January 2018 on YouTube. In all likelihood, the video could be older, i.e from 2017, as claimed by the Indian Army. In the video, the Army jawan levels serious allegations against the discriminatory conduct of his superiors towards their juniors. However, the Army has refuted the allegations, asserting that videos are outed to vilify the Armed Forces.
After the Indian Army raised its objection over the propagandist video, AAP leader Rajendra Pal Gautam pulled down the video, claiming that a senior Army official called him up and informed him that the video shared by him was three years old. He also added that the Army official told him that the video was created by the disgruntled officer based on his personal enmity with his senior officers.
हालांकि आधिकारिक तौर पर इस वीडियो को लेकर अभी तक सूचित नही किया गया लेकिन उन आधिकारी की बात का भरोसा करते हुए अपने इस ट्वीट को हटा रहा हूं,लेकिन साथ ही साथ मैं यह भी कहना चाहता हूं कि आज भी हर रोज़ जातिगत भेदभाव की घटनाएं सामने आती रहती है और उन पर कोई ठोस कार्यवाही नहीं की जाती।
— Rajendra Pal Gautam (@AdvRajendraPal) May 11, 2020
Though the tweet was pulled down by AAP leader, in an attempt to save his face, Gautam continued claiming that caste discrimination is prevalent even today and that no concrete action is taken to nip the rampant discrimination in the bud.
In order to deflect the criticism received for sharing an outdated video of an Indian Army jawan, Gautam further cited incidents of Una, Jhajjar, Rohit Vemula, Payal Tadvi and several others incidents, along with the latest incident in AIIMS Delhi where a doctor had alleged caste discrimination to affirm that caste inequities are very much the part of the society.
…वह तुरंत देश से जातिवाद को खत्म करने की दिशा में काम करें और जहां भी जातिवाद और अस्पृश्यता की घटना हो उन घटनाओं पर मुकदमा दर्ज करके स्पीडी ट्रायल के जरिए ऐसे लोगों जल्द से जल्द सजा दी जाए, ताकि जातिगत भेदभाव की घटनाएं रुक सकें।
— Rajendra Pal Gautam (@AdvRajendraPal) May 11, 2020
Shifting the blame on the government for the stray incidents of caste discrimination in the country, Gautam claimed that he is a staunch nationalist and needs no lessons on nationalism from anybody. “We are staunch patriots, we know how to sacrifice our lives for the nation. We will not let the Army’s morale to fall. I request the Central government and the State governments should immediately work towards eradicating casteism prevalent in the country. The government should file cases against the offenders and expedite trails so that incidents of caste discrimination stop,” he said.