Home Blog Page 3049

England: One arrested for racist comments against Indian cricket fans in the Edgbaston Test

On the fourth day of the Edgbaston Test (July 4), a group of English fans misbehaved against Indian spectators sitting in the stands. On 8th July 2022, Birmingham police arrested one person from the English fan group who misbehaved. Birmingham police informed this through a tweet. The arrested person is being interrogated.

Team India recently played the Edgbaston Test against England, in which India lost by 7 wickets. On the fourth day of the match (July 4), the Indian spectators sitting in the stands were mistreated by some English fans. They were abused and called Pakistani. A group of English fans had made bad comments about Indian fans, the complaints of which were reported through Twitter. The Edgbaston authorities and the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) then took cognizance of the matter and launched an investigation.

In a tweet that brought this matter to light, it was described how Indian fans were subjected to racial abuse. The Twitter user wrote in a series of tweets, “Racist behaviour at Edgbaston towards Indian fans in block 22 Eric Hollies. People calling us Curry C**ts and paki bas****s. We reported it to the stewards and showed them the culprits at least 10 times but no response and all we were told is to sit in our seats. We were also fearful for our safety as women and children but had no assistance when we left. This is unacceptable in today’s society.”

Birmingham police tweeted, “A 32-year-old man has been arrested for a racially aggravated public order offence after reports of racist, abusive behaviour at the test match in Birmingham on Monday. He remains in custody for questioning.”

According to a report by the Times of India, West Midlands Police spokesperson said, “We have launched a criminal investigation into reports of racist, abusive behaviour at the Test match in Birmingham. We are liaising with Edgbaston officials to understand what has happened and would encourage anyone who heard any racist language or gestures or has video footage that could help, to get in touch.”

The officer further said, “We are aware of the images circulating in the social media showing an alleged offender. We are making inquiries to identify the person and would urge him to come forward and speak to us.”

The second Twenty20 International between India and England will be played at Edgbaston on Saturday. As part of a series of precautions, Warwickshire County Cricket Club has chosen to place “undercover football crowd-style spotters” in the stadium to listen for and report abusive conduct.

Marketing agency distances itself from its employee Joy Das over his Hinduphobic tweets; promises to take action for hurting sentiments

Social media has proven to be a powerful tool for people to express their views and ideas. Beyond its obvious advantages of facilitating online socialisation, keeping years-old friendships and relations alive, and helping businesses expand to uncharted territories, social media has empowered people with an agency to speak or write on matters that hitherto no other platform ever provided.

Its utilities and advantages notwithstanding, social media portals, like any other communication platforms, have also had their fair share of disadvantages and downsides. The most glaring among them is attracting all sorts of abusers, trollers, manipulators, propagandists and instigators, who believe insulting and provoking people online somehow adds meaning to their wretched existence.

Recently, Mohammed Zubair of Alt News harnessed this dangerous aspect of social media by dog-whistling against Nupur Sharma, touching off an ugly chain of events leading to the death of at least three people in the name of ‘blasphemy’, besides the attendant chaos and disorder that came in its wake.

Egged on by the Alt News co-founder’s inflammatory rhetorics, thousands of Islamists hit the streets, threatening to behead Nupur Sharma for her audacity to comment on Prophet Muhammad. As the matter gained international attention, Zubair and Alt News hopped on the gravy train, seeking donations in the name of carrying out ‘responsible journalism’.

And the faithful dutifully lined up to plunk down money to Alt News—apparently, for setting the country on fire—as Islamists across the nation went on a rampage, indulging in wanton violence, vandalism and issuing ‘sar tan se Juda’ threats to Nupur and those who supported her.

One of the patrons of propaganda outlet Alt News is an internet troll named Joy Das, who has time and again worn it as a badge of honour to bankroll an organisation that works as a mouthpiece for Islamists when it is not conducting slanted ‘fact checks’ or when its co-founders are not busy making derogatory posts against Hindu Gods and Goddesses or whipping up a communal frenzy against those who restate what has been mentioned in authentic and reliable Islamic Hadiths.

Joy Das, who has made no bones about his aversion for the non-left or for anyone who disagrees with his political inclinations, and laboured his way up the ladder of the ‘liberal’ coterie, has a history of making derogatory posts on Hindu Gods, Hindu places of worship and Hinduism in general. For years, social media users dismissed the Hinduphobia exhibited by Das as a desperate attempt by a wannabe trying to firmly embed himself in the ‘liberal’ orbit.

However, after ‘liberals’ subjected ordinary yet assertive Indians to doxxing attacks, online ostracism, and brought an action against them by tagging their employers and demanding action against people whose views did not converge with theirs, Hindus on social media realised the need to bring people like Das, no matter how worthless cog they are in the giant ‘liberal’ wheel, to a reckoning for their behaviour that they have brushed off for so long.

Specimen of Joy Das’ Hinduphobic tweets

Recently, a Twitter user who goes by the handle @CrimeMasterV2 highlighted the chronic religious bigotry exhibited by Joy Das on Twitter, where he routinely mocks Hindus and their cherished beliefs because it burnishes his ‘liberal’ credentials and does not evoke ‘sar tan se juda’ chants like quoting from authentic and reliable Islamic Hadiths does.

In a string of tweets, the Twitter user highlighted how Joy Das (@Joydas), an inveterate disparager, has been denigrating Hinduism and its pantheon of gods through his perversely vile tweets aimed at insulting Hindus. From Lord Ram to Lord Ganesha to Lord Hanuman, Joy Das has felt no compunction in being disrespectful of deities revered by millions of Hindus around the world.

Though some of the objectionable posts have been removed by Joy Das, primarily after suffering a backlash online, there still exist plenty of tweets where the internet troll masquerading as an ‘intellectual’ insulted Hindus and their religion.

In May 2022, amidst the debate over the discovery of a Shivling inside the wuzukhana of Gyanvapi mosque, Joy Das shared a three-decade-old video from San Francisco to imply that Hindus have a tendency to turn any and everything into their deities. It was not lost on anyone that Das’ post was directed at the Hindu assertion of the discovery of a Shivling at the Gyanvapi site.

Source: Twitter

Joy Das has also been a vocal proponent of Muslim encroachment on public spaces for religious purposes. In December 2021, he drew a false equivalence between Muslims occupying open spaces and public roads to offer namaz with the celebrations of Hindu festivals. He said Muslims use only 26 hours a year of open spaces while Hindus use over 1000 hours a year for their festivals. What he conveniently misses out on highlighting is that Muslims also celebrate festivals such as Muharram, Eid-Milad-Un-Nabi and other occasions when thousands throng the streets in various cities and towns, occupying roads and public spaces. Beyond everything else, Das here tries to rationalise the occupation of public property by a specific community just because they need “26 hours” of open spaces a year. 

Source: Twitter

While ‘liberals’ keep insisting that terrorism has no religion despite the overwhelming majority of the caught or eliminated terrorists being Islamists, one of their footsies, Joy Das, does not mind accusing Hindus of being traitors and working for Pakistan’s ISI.

Joy Das
Source: Twitter

In yet another tweet, Joy Das had cast aspersions on the former CJI who was a member of the bench that had granted the site in Ayodhya to the Hindus for building a Ram Temple. Insinuating that the judgment was a result of a quid pro quo arrangement, he criticised the verdict saying that the Ex-CJI was awarded a Rajya Sabha post.

Joy Das
Source: Twitter

Back in 2018, a controversy broke out as liberal luminaries partook in condemning the use of Hanuman posters on cabs and linked it with aggression and hostility against other communities. Long, convoluted and devious articles were written, which enjoyed international coverage, on how Hindutva proponents have found a new expression for their bigotry in Hanuman posters. Joydas was one of the members of the ‘liberal’ firmament that furthered this Hinduphobic narrative on Twitter.

Joy Das
Source: Twitter

Joy Das’ employer condemns his Hinduphobic tweets; promises to take action against employees who had hurt religious sentiments

Besides spewing hatred against Hindus on Twitter and targeting one of the most successful business magnates in India, Joy apparently also has a day job. He works at the Mumbai office of LIQVD Asia, a Digital Marketing agency that describes itself as ‘the ideas company for a digital world’. He had recently attended LIQVD Asia’s birthday bash in Mumbai after the organisation completed its nine years.

Joy Das
Joy Das (L) with a LIQVD Asia executive at its birthday bash held in Mumbai in March 2022 (Image Source: exchange4media.com)

In addition to his Hinduphobia, Das has repeatedly attacked Ambanis on social media. He weaved a conspiracy theory to play down the bomb scare outside Mukesh Ambani’s residence and inexplicably linked it to farmers’ protest. He also has body-shamed Mukesh Ambani’s son and made vulgar jokes about Neeta Ambani.

Source: Twitter

However, it is worth noting that Das’ organisation LIQVD Asia proudly flaunts its association with an organisation named DigiBoxx, a cloud-based file-sharing application company that has partnered with Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Jio. But that hasn’t stopped Das from insulting the Ambanis and spinning wild conspiracy theories against them.

OpIndia contacted LIQVD Asia about their stand on the Hinduphobic posts made by Joy Das, one of their senior-most employees. In a detailed response, the company condemned his derogatory posts and distanced itself from his anti-Hindu tweets.

“We have found that many Twitter users have condemned the offensive comments made by Mr Joy Das. Considering the whole matter seriously, we would like to categorically say that there is no direct or indirect relation of the company with the said case. LIQVD ASIA holds full faith, respect and pride towards the culture and civilization of India,” the organisation said in an email response.

Distancing itself from Joy Das’ Hinduphobic comments, his company said, “We would like to clarify that the statements referenced by Joy Das may be his personal views, which have been tweeted from his personal Twitter account. His personal Twitter account is his personal space for expression. The views expressed herein shall not be construed to be related to the views/beliefs of the Company.”

The company has also assured that it will take strict action against its employees who are found hurting the religious sentiments of people, even though it has not revealed yet what action it plans to take against Joy Das, whose derogatory posts deriding Hindu Gods have long gone viral on Twitter.

LIQVD Asia also took to Twitter to respond to the raging controversy. On being highlighted how one of its employees is brazenly exhibiting Hinduphobic tendencies, the official Twitter of the company tweeted, “As a responsible Indian company, we fully respect India’s faith, identity, culture, civilization and tradition. LIQVD Asia always condemns the statements/comments that provoke public sentiments.”

In the past, Joy Das’ ideological brethren have run motivated campaigns attacking Hindus in the middle east for something as innocuous as backing the Citizenship Amendment Act, a bill passed by the central government to fast track granting of citizenship status to persecuted minorities from Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh, which has led to job losses.

It will be worth noting what punitive action LIQVD Asia initiates against Joy Das for his patently Hinduphobic posts and for hurting the religious sentiments of Hindus with his tweets mocking and insulting Hindu Gods or if the assurance by the company is only a lip-service aimed at temporarily assuaging the feelings of Hindus until the issue becomes cold and forgotten.

History sheeter Salman Chishti has no remorse after calling for the beheading of Nupur Sharma, has been smiling and reciting ‘shayari’ in police custody: Reports

Salman Chishti, the Khadim of the Ajmer Dargah, was arrested by the Ajmer Police after he publicly gave death threats to Nupur Sharma. Salman Chishti has since shown no remorse while in police custody. The history-sheeter has reportedly been smiling, reciting “shayaris,” and chanting religious slogans while in police custody, reports Aaj Tak.

The police have reportedly said that Chishti has not been cooperating with the investigation. He has been reciting poems and Islamic chants during interrogation.

According to the report, when the Ajmer police reached his house to arrest him, even then Chishti displayed no signs of repentance, instead, he smiled and chanted Islamic slogans while he was being taken away by the police.

The police said that Chishti, who is a history-sheeter with over 13 cases against him, had resorted to similar antics during his past three arrests. He had also tried to injure himself by smashing his head against the wall while in custody.

Sharing the report by Aaj Tak, BJP leader Rajyavardhan Rathore expressed his displeasure with the Congress lead government in Rajasthan for its appeasement politics. He highlighted how the criminals in the state have been emboldened due to the callousness of the Ashok Gehlot government.

Chishti smiles, flashes victory sign after arrest

Notably, earlier, a video had surfaced wherein arrested Ajmer Dargah Khadim Salman Chishti was seen smiling and displaying a victory symbol while he was being sent to police custody for two days after being produced in front of a magistrate.

Commenting on this, BJP national spokesperson Shehzad Poonawalla had also remarked, “After Rajasthan Police tutoring Salman Chisti now you can see him smiling in police presence. Clearly, he feels Gehlot government is with him. He knows that because Karauli main accused has not been caught..he knows vote bank matters”. 

Meanwhile, Chishti reportedly deleted all his phone data before his arrest. Salman Chishti also runs his own YouTube channel, which he made private after the controversy over his video threatening former Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) spokesperson Nupur Sharma grew. The police have now sent his phone to the forensic department to recover the data. Efforts are now being made to recover the content from his YouTube channel.

Rajasthan police caught coaching arrested Salman Chishti who wanted to kill Nupur Sharma

It may be recalled that the Ajmer police were recently caught on camera coaching the arrested accused Salman Chishti to say that he was drunk while issuing threats to Nupur Sharma so that it will be ‘easier to save him’.

In the video that went viral on Wednesday, while arresting Chishti from his house, someone from Ajmer police said “What exactly you were high on while recording the video?” Salman Chishti is heard saying that he does not drink. At this moment a police officer near him said, “Say that you were drunk so that it will be easier to save you.”

After the video went viral, on July 7, Ajmer’s Deputy Superintendent of Police (DSP) Sandeep Saraswat was reportedly removed from the post awaiting further orders (Line Hazir). 

Nicaragua orders dismissal of Missionaries of Charity founded by Mother Teresa, says ‘NGO failed to comply with State laws’

In a major crackdown against the catholic church, the Nicaragua government in the Central America has decided to expel the Association run by the Missionaries of Charity (MoC) for failing to comply with the state laws. The government stating the specific reason said that the association had failed to comply with Law 977 which deals with money laundering, financing of terrorism and financing of proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

According to the reports, the Nicaraguan government President Daniel Ortega has also decided to shut down 100 similar NGOs including several Catholic organizations operating in the country. The measure was first ordered by the Nicaraguan Interior Ministry and was approved by the National Assembly on July 7.

Since St. Mother Teresa visited the nation of Nicaragua during Daniel Ortega’s first term in office, the Missionaries of Charity have been active there. The Immaculate Heart of Mary Home in Granada, which takes in abandoned children and abuse victims, is run by nuns. They run a nursing home in Managua, the nation’s capital, where the elderly may get amenities including food and clothing. The MC also runs childcare for children from low-income families and provides remedial education to at-risk youth.

The government ordering the association’s dismissal stated that it did not have an operating permit from the Ministry of Education to provide remedial education for students. “Also, they are not accredited by the Ministry for the Family to function as a nursery-center for childhood development, home for girls, and home for the elderly, and their financial statements reported to the Ministry of the Interior don’t agree with other documents presented for review”, the government was quoted.

The decision to expel more than similar NGOs including the Kolkata-based Missionaries of Charity comes amid the massive war of words between the Catholic Church and the Ortega’s government who is ruling over the entire Central America for the past 15 years. Relations have been fragile since 2018 when Nicaraguan authorities cracked down on marches against a series of disputed social security reforms. Despite attempts to mediate the crisis, bishops were eventually barred from participating in the dialogue, and relations deteriorated further following the contentious 2021 elections, which confirmed President Ortega against the other presidential candidate.

Reports mention that among the Catholic organizations that the Nicaraguan government has ordered to dissolve are the Diriomito Children’s Care Home Association, the My Childhood Mothers Foundation, the Catholic Foundation for Human Development Assistance for Nicaraguans, and the Spirituality Foundation for Children of Nicaragua.

It is important to note that the Missionaries of Charity Association has also been booked in several cases in India. In December 2021, the Gujarat Government filed an FIR against the organization founded by Mother Teresa for luring young girls to convert to Christianity. Also, one of the ex-nun had confirmed that MoC isolated the nuns and sisters and institutionally brainwashed them.

Reportedly, the Union Ministry of Home Affairs had rejected the renewal of the FCRA licence of the organisations after it failed to submit documents about the donations it had received from the overseas. Reportedly, the Christian evangelist organisation had been receiving large amounts of money from a company based in tax haven Panama. Of the total ₹75 crores received as donations from foreign donors, more than 17% came from this mysterious company with links to companies named in Pandora papers. Later the license was restored after the organisation submitted relevant documents.

Uttar Pradesh: Warrant issued against Alt News co-founder Mohammed Zubair in Lakhimpur Kheri. Here is what we know so far about the FIR and proceedings initiated now

A day after the Supreme Court granted interim bail to Alt News co-founder Mohammed Zubair in a case filed in the Sitapur district of Uttar Pradesh, an arrest warrant has been issued against him in Lakhimpur Kheri district of the State.

The warrant is issued based on a complaint filed by Sudarshan news journalist Ashish Kumar Katiyar who had originally filed the complaint through the court on September 18 last year. Based on that complaint, the police have now initiated proceedings to take Zubair into their custody.

In his complaint, Katiyar had stated that the Alt News co-founder played a malicious role in uniting Muslims, across the world, against India and peddling communal discord even during the Coronavirus pandemic.

Screengrab of the FIR copy against Mohammed Zubair

He informed that the cops initially refused to lodge a complaint, thereby forcing him to knock on the door of the court. Later, an FIR was registered against Mohammed Zubair at the Mohammadi police station on the directive of the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM).

Charges were pressed against the accused under Indian Penal Code (IPC) Section 153A (promoting enmity between different groups).

Screengrab of the FIR copy against Mohammed Zubair

While talking to Opindia, Katiyar said, “The case is pending for the past 10 months. After Delhi and Sitapur police, now the Lakhimpur police have initiated proceedings against Zubair.”

He also informed that the Alt News co-founder will soon be brought to Lakhimpur Kheri. Opindia also reached out to the Station House Officer (SHO) of the Mohammdi police station.

“We have submitted warrant B at the Sitapur jail. The matter is being investigated as per the rules,” he informed. It must be mentioned that warrant ‘B’ is issued when the police wants to seek custody of an accused, who is booked in a different jail or a district.

The case against Mohammed Zubair in Sitapur

On June 1, Khairabad Police of Sitapur district in Uttar Pradesh filed an FIR against Alt News co-founder Mohammed Zubair for using derogatory language against Mahant Bajrang Muni Udasin, Yati Narsinghanand and Swami Anand Swaroop. 

The FIR was registered based on the complaint of Bhagwan Sharan, district head of Rashtriya Hindu Sher Sena, under sections 295(A) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

The Sitapur court in Uttar Pradesh rejected the bail plea of Alt News co-founder and propagandist Mohammed Zubair on July 7, 2022. Judge Abhinav Srivastava denied the bail on the grounds that the accused may influence witnesses or commit similar new crimes.

Later, Zubair obtained interim bail from the Supreme Court of India. However, he will continue to remain in judicial custody in Delhi.

Jamtara, Jharkhand: State-run schools pressurised to remain shut on Friday as 70% children are Muslims, over 100 schools adopt change. Read details

On July 8, Friday, the Hindi daily Jagran reported that due to the unprecedented increase in the Muslim population in the Jamtara district in Jharkhand, many government schools have changed their weekly offs from Sunday to Friday after the community exerted pressure. The decision has been taken after the members of the Muslim community residing in those areas compelled the school authorities to do so. As per the report, gradually, more than 100 state-run schools in Jamtara have started observing Friday (Jumma) as a weekly holiday in schools on religious grounds. 

According to the report, neither these institutions are Urdu-medium schools nor have they received any departmental directives to implement the change. However, due to pressure from the parents of Muslim students, who make up more than 70% of the student population at these government schools, the administration has unilaterally decided that Fridays would now serve as students’ weekly holiday instead of Sundays.

Interestingly, as per the official data available with the state education department, out of the 1084 state-run schools on Jamtara, only 15 are Urdu medium schools, where teachers conveniently skip school on Fridays for Jumma prayers. But now, more than 100 state-run schools in Jamtara have officially designated Fridays rather than Sundays as a weekly holiday for all the students as well as the teachers.

A teacher of one of these state-run schools told Jagran, on conditions of anonymity, that initially, just a small number of students’ parents had requested the school administration to observe Friday as the weekly off day. The authorities, however, promptly convened a meeting to discuss this and issued arbitrary directives to observe the modification in the weekly off. This arbitrary instruction began to gradually become the new norm in these state-run institutions, and it has now persisted for a number of years, said the teacher.

Another teacher who has been teaching at a state-run middle school since 2001, told Jagran that 70 per cent of the students in his school are Muslims. He added that one day, all of a sudden, he learnt that Fridays would henceforth be the weekly holiday for the school rather than Sundays. However, until today, they have not received any official intimation regarding the same, said the teacher.

Because Sundays are still the departmental weekly off days they have to mark themselves absent in the school register but they must still report to school on such days since schools have arbitrarily marked Sundays as working days, rued the teacher.

The report further stated that along with marking Fridays instead of Sundays as weekly holidays for school students many government schools in Jamtara, Jharkhand has declared themselves Urdu-medium schools since 70 per cent of the children coming there are Muslims.

Muslim community in Garhwa, Jharkhand gets school prayer changed, stop students from folding hands 

Notably, on July 5 OpIndia reported how in Jharkhand’s Garhwa, some members of the Muslim community got a school prayer, that has been offered for years, changed. They said that since the Muslim community forms 75% of the population, the prayer should be ‘as per them’. The school administration also succumbed to the pressure and changed the prayer.

Not only this, but the Muslim community also objected to folding hands during the prayer and got the same to stop. Hindus fold their hands while offering prayer, greeting in ‘namaste’ and bow down their head as a mark of respect. The school administration said that for the past few months the people from the Muslim community have been coming and creating a ruckus demanding a change of prayer.

Amarnath Yatra temporarily suspended after cloudburst, landslide hit pilgrim base camps, 16 reported dead, over 15,000 stranded pilgrims shifted

At least 16 people died and around 30-40 have been reported missing after a massive cloudburst occurred near the holy Amarnath Cave amid the ongoing Amarnath Yatra. The Indian Army helicopters have undertaken rescue operations to evacuate the pilgrims who are residing and are trapped at various base camps.

According to the reports, the cloudburst occurred at around 5:30 am on Saturday forcing the heavy water to hit the base camps located near the holy cave. Following the tragedy, the Amarnath Yatra which began on June 30, has been suspended and a decision on its resumption will only be taken after rescue operations get over.

Jammu and Kashmir Governor Manoj Sinha expressed anguish over the incident and said on July 8 that he was closely monitoring the situation. “Deeply pained by the unfortunate incident of cloudburst at Shri Amarnathji holy cave, in which precious lives have been lost. I send my heartfelt condolences to bereaved families. Rescue operation by NDRF, SDRF, BSF, Army, JKP & Shrine board admin is in progress”, he said.

In the series of tweets further, he noted that he has briefed PM Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah about the situation and that the duo has assured all the possible help. “Our priority is to save the lives of people. Instructions have been issued to provide all necessary assistance to pilgrims. I am closely monitoring the situation”, he added. Accordingly, PM Modi and HMO Amit Shah also said that they are distressed about the situation.

“Anguished by the cloud burst near Shree Amarnath cave. Condolences to the bereaved families. Spoke to Manoj Sinha Ji and took stock of the situation. Rescue and relief operations are underway. All possible assistance is being provided to the affected”, PM Modi tweeted. Meanwhile, HMO Amit Shah has directed NDRF, CRPF, and BSF officers to join in the rescue operations.

Reports mention that the ITBP troops are conducting the rescue operations at the lower Amarnath cave sites while the Indian Army officers are using helicopters to evacuate the stranded pilgrims near the holy Amarnath cave. Heavy rainfall and landslide were reported on Friday evening however the situation worsened after the cloudburst occurred on Saturday at around 5:30 am.

The ITBP officials confirmed that most of the pilgrims who were stranded near the holy cave area due to flash floods have been shifted to Panjtarni and the route from the lower holy cave to Panjtarni has been expanded. “No pilgrim left on the track. About 15,000 people safely shifted”, the officers noted.

The rushing waters damaged 25 tents and three community kitchens where pilgrims are served food at the base camp outside the shrine in south Kashmir. The Union Territory administration and the Shri Amarnath Shrine Board (SASB) released four phone numbers to assist families of those affected by the cloudburst. The rescue operations are still underway.

Toronto Metropolitan University issues apology for platforming maker of Hinduphobic film ‘Kaali’, disassociates itself from Leena Manimekalai

The Toronto Metropolitan University (formally Ryerson University) has tendered an apology for having its name associated with the film Kaali and the Hinduphobic poster created by Kollywood filmmaker Leena Manimekalai to promote her film. The statement was released in regards to the university-sponsored event where the movie “Kaali” was screened and filmmaker Leena Manimekalai released her poster showing Hindu Goddess Kali smoking a cigarette.

In the letter of apology, the university said that the TMU department that hosted the event is committed to taking steps to address the issue and acknowledges the need to handle such complex topics more sensitively. The statement was issued in the context of the screening of the film ‘Kaali’.

The Hinduphobic movie by filmmaker Leena Manimekalai was to be shown at the “Under the tent” project at the Aga Khan Museum and was organized by Toronto metropolitan university’s Canada Excellence Research Chair in Migration and Integration or CERC Migration.

Toronto Metropolitan University, however, disassociated itself from filmmaker Leena Manimekalai. The University said that though it takes full responsibility as the host of the event where the Hinduphobic movie was screened and the ‘Kaali’ poster was displayed, it wanted to “make it clear that the student in question is not a TMU student and their poster was not reviewed or approved by TMU.”

Image credit: Twitter user @CoHNAOfficial

“The university would like to apologise for the oversight on our part and for any upset and disappointment this may have caused,” read the letter.

Aga Khan Museum tenders apology, stops screening of Hinduphobic film ‘Kaali’

Notably, on July 6, the University had also decided to stop the screening of the Hinduphobic movie ‘Kaali’. In reply to the query by Wion News, the University said that the film ‘Kaali’ would not be part of the further screening of the ‘Under The Tent’ event. It said, “We recognize the short film has caused sensitivities and have no further plans to screen it at this time.”

Toronto Metropolitan University had also added a statement on the event’s details page. In the statement, the CERC Migration department of the University said, “We regret that certain content in our Under the Tent presentation on Saturday, July 2 has caused offense and we are taking steps to address this. We are committed to equity, diversity and inclusion while at the same time respecting the diversity of beliefs and points of view in our society. We acknowledge the need to explore and examine complex topics sensitively.”

A day prior to this, Aga Khan Museum had also issued a statement and tendered an apology for hurting the religious sentiments of Hindu and other faith communities.

It is noteworthy that the High Commission of India in Ottawa had urged the Canadian authorities to withdraw the screening of an objectionable film named after Hindu Goddess Kaali. 

Following social media outrage, filmmaker says she has nothing to lose

After the film director, Leena Manimekalai issued a poster depicting Maa Kaali smoking, there was an outrage on social media against the film. In reply to the criticism, Leena had remarked, “I have nothing to lose. I want to be with a voice that speaks without fear of anything until it is. If the price is my life, I will give it.” She has not issued any statement after the screening stopped.

Elon Musk pulls out of the $44 billion deal, Twitter vows to take legal action: Here is why it happened

Tesla CEO Elon Musk has pulled out of the $44 billion Twitter deal, alleging that the social media giant breached provisions of the merger agreement.

As per reports, the lawyers of Elon Musk have claimed that Twitter failed to provide information about fake bots/spam accounts, which is integral to the company’s business performance.

“Twitter is in material breach of multiple provisions of that Agreement, appears to have made false and misleading representations upon which Mr. Musk relied when entering into the Merger Agreement,” they argued in a recent filing.

Musk also justified his decision, claiming that Twitter breached its agreement by firing 1/3rd of the talent acquisition team and several high-ranking executives.

Twitter vows legal action against Elon Musk

Reportedly, the contract signed between Musk and Twitter shareholders called for a $1 billion breakup fee, provided the Tesla CEO failed to honour the deal. This included reasons such as blockade of the deal by regulators or lack of acquisition financing.

However, the contract made it clear that if Musk terminated the deal on his own, then, the break-up fee would not be applicable. Aggrieved by the sudden development, Twitter Chairman Bret Taylor informed that the Board would pursue legal action against Elon Musk.

He tweeted, “The Twitter Board is committed to closing the transaction on the price and terms agreed upon with Mr. Musk and plans to pursue legal action to enforce the merger agreement. We are confident we will prevail in the Delaware Court of Chancery.”

According to Tulane Law School Associate Dean, Ann Lipton, the Tesla CEO has been making up excuses to get rid of the deal. She stated that the Twitter Board is in a strong position to fight it out in court.

The rationale behind Musk’s decision to abandon the Twitter deal

On May 13 this year, Tesla CEO Elon Musk announced that the 44 billion dollar Twitter deal had been temporarily put on hold, subject to the estimate that less than 5% of users on the micro-blogging platform were spam/fake accounts.

“Twitter deal temporarily on hold pending details supporting calculation that spam/fake accounts do indeed represent less than 5% of users,” Musk had tweeted. He had also shared the link of a Reuters report dated May 2, 2022.

As per the report, Twitter Inc. in a filing has noted that fewer than 5% of 229 million users, who were served ads, during the first quarter of 2022 were false/ spam accounts.

“Twitter said in the filing it faced several risks until the deal with Musk is closed, such as whether advertisers would continue to spend on Twitter and potential uncertainty regarding our future plans and strategy,” the report added.

Musk had earlier stated that one of his main priorities is to rid the micro-blogging platform of spam accounts. However, later Elon Musk tried to allay concerns about the deal by tweeting that he is “still committed to acquisition” of Twitter.

Pranay Pathole, a well-recognised fan of Musk, explained that Twitter’s count of spam accounts was not transparent. He said, “Transparency establishes trust.”

“It is definitely not < 5% fake/spam accounts on the platform. It doesn’t make sense to pay the same original price of $44bn if it turns out that the actual number of bot/fake accounts are higher than 20%. Elon had made a deal based out on their public filings,” he justified Musk’s decision.

Future of Twitter and immediate aftermath

On July 8, Twitter informed that it removes about 1 million spam accounts every day. It claimed that such accounts represented less than 5% of its total active user base in each quarter.

“To calculate how many accounts are malicious spam, Twitter said it reviews “thousands of accounts” sampled at random, using both public and private data such as IP addresses, phone numbers, geolocation and how the account behaves when it is active, to determine whether an account is real,” a report by Reuters read.

Meanwhile, Twitter share prices have suffered a major blow amidst the uncertainty over the ownership of the social media company. Analyst Daniel Ives remarked, “This is a disaster scenario for Twitter and its Board as now the company will battle Musk in an elongated court battle to recoup the deal and/or the breakup fee of $1 billion at a minimum.”

Madras HC says non-Hindus can enter temples if they have faith in the diety: Why the recent comments in the order are problematic

On the 4th of July, Madras High Court passed an order that could open Pandora’s box. In response to a PIL about not allowing the entry of non-Hindus during the Kumbabishegam festival of Arulmighu Adikesava Perumal Thirukovil at Thiruvattar, the Madras HC said that those non-Hindus who have faith in the deity cannot be prevented from entering the temple or offering prayers to the deity.

The petition was filed by one C Soman, in response to a Christian minister being invited for the Hindu festival.

The prayer in the petition said:

Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondents not to permit the Non-Hindus to enter the temple premises during Kumbabishegam festival in the Arulmighu Adikesava Perumal Thirukovil at Thiruvattar, Kanyakumari District and subsequent event scheduled on 06.07.2022.

The court, in its order said:

In our considered opinion, when a public festival like the Kumababishegam of a temple is performed, it will be impossible for the authorities to check the religious identity of every devotee for the purpose of permitting his entry into the temple. That apart, if a person belonging to another religion, has faith in a particular Hindu deity, that cannot be prevented nor can his entry into a temple be prohibited. It is common knowledge that the devotional songs of Dr K.J.Yesudas, a Christian by birth, rendered on various Hindu Gods are played without any demur in temples. In fact, in Nagore Dargah and Vailankanni Church, scores of Hindus worship.

There are certain operative parts of what the Madras HC said, taking a “broader perspective” on the issue and dismissing the PIL, saying it was “devoid of merits”.

  1. It would be impossible for the authorities to determine who is a Hindu and who is not.
  2. If a Christian has faith in a Hindu deity, then they can’t be stopped from entering the Temple.
  3. KJ Yesudas, a Christian by birth, has sung many devotional songs in Temples.

The Court in this judgement seems to have waded into territory that can open Pandora’s box. The Judiciary cannot determine the Hindu faith and what individual temples and festivals should or should not do. Such judgements can also have a cascading effect on the practices of several other temples in India.

For example, the Sree Padmanabhaswamy Temple allows only Hindus and those who declare their faith to be Hinduism to enter the temple and offer prayers. The Court, in its wisdom, did not want to take a ‘parochial view’ but a ‘broad perspective’, however, such pronouncements can then be used to demand that non-Hindus be allowed in several other temples where rules dictate that only Hindus can offer prayers.

The court further said that if a non-Hindu has faith in the Hindu deity, then he cannot be stopped from entering the Temple. A matter of faith cannot be determined by the court, certainly. In fact, when the court says that the administration will not be able to determine who is a Hindu and who is not, it has to consider that establishing the faith of a non-Hindu in a Hindu deity is far more difficult.

KJ Yesudas, who is a Christian by birth and has sung many devotional songs, also needed to approach the court to seek permission to enter the Sree Padmanabhaswamy temple. Even in this case, it was the Temple committee that had unanimously decided to let Yesudas enter the temple and offer prayers, not the judiciary. “Sree Padmanabhaswamy temple executive committee has decided to permit Yesudas to visit Padmanabhaswamy temple. Yesudas filed an undertaking that he has belief in the Hindu faith and is ready to follow the temple traditions,” V Ratheesan, a member of the temple’s executive committee, had said. “The decision was unanimous… all members who took part in the meeting agreed to accept the legendary singer’s request. Now, we will formally inform him about the temple committee’s decision… It is up to him to decide the date of the visit to the shrine,” Mr Ratheesan had said.

Ideally, the Court should have simply dismissed the case saying that it is a decision that the temple has to take independently, without the interference of the court, to determine if they wish to allow non-Hindus or not.

The Judiciary often looks at Hinduism from an Abrahamic view where principles of universal morals need to be applied, however, in Hinduism, every temple and every Sampradaya would have its own traditions and culture. In the case of Sabarimala, the outrage was precisely for this reason. Women, who did not even belong to the Sampradaya wanted to dictate what devotees should or should not do. They wanted to impose their modern moral construct on the devotees who only wanted to follow the tradition of the deity they had faith in. However, the Judiciary interfered and assumed to dictate the contours of the Hindu faith.

Justice Indu Malhotra, who had given a dissenting view in 2018, had said:

Justice Malhotra observed that religion can lay down a code of ethics, and also prescribe rituals, ceremonies etc. which are also regarded as an integral part of religion and hence are to be protected as a religious belief. She said, “The religious practice of restricting the entry of women between the ages of 10 to 50 years, is in pursuance of an ‘essential religious practice’ followed by the Respondents. The said restriction has been consistent, followed at the Sabarimala Temple for years.” 

She had further said:

“In a pluralistic society comprising of people with diverse faiths, beliefs and traditions, to entertain PILs challenging religious practices followed by any group, sect or denomination, could cause serious damage to the constitutional and secular fabric of this country.”

It is indeed true that if the courts start deciding what the contours of the Hindu faith are, it would hurt the secular fabric of the nation and infringe on the right of every Hindu to practise their faith freely. In this case, it is to be kept in mind that the Temple invited the non-Hindu for the festival and a devotee had approached the court. In my personal view, the court should have simply said that it will defer to the wisdom of the Temple and not interfere either way. However, to foist their own sensibilities and make comments accordingly, to define how a Temple’s conduct should be, is a dangerous path to tread. Hinduism is not a monolith and interference by the court only encourages temple practices to be ingringed upon. The comments, in this case, could have far-reaching ramifications and have a cascading effect on several other cases, where Hindu practises are wantonly challenged.