Tuesday, January 19, 2021
Home Fact-Check How Scroll and Firstpost falsely blamed Modi for acts of an NGO

How Scroll and Firstpost falsely blamed Modi for acts of an NGO

Last night, an “opinion” piece, by the blog called Scroll.in was making waves mild ripples on Twitter. It talked about plans to rename to areas of Delhi, and how this plan by “Modi’s Government” revealed an “Imperial Mindset”. Midway during the Social Media outrage, the blog chose to change the title of the story within a few hours of posting it:

xBut they forgot to edit the content, which said the Modi government is planning “to rename Lutyens’ New Delhi as the “Imperial City of Delhi” and the walled city that many call the Old Delhi as the “Imperial City of Shahjahanabad”

It quoted this Firstpost report dated 6th April 2015 & at the same time said “no confirmation of the news reports has come as yet“. Scroll then went on to give some half-assed pseudo-intellectual logic to defame the “Modi Government”, while mentioning in passing that this move may be aimed at attracting tourists & obtaining the UNESCO heritage city tag .

It even went on to say “Perhaps the idea here is to present the Modi government as the “new imperial” power, which will dislodge or “bleach out” the work of the previous governments and once and for all appropriate the imperial city of Delhi.

Coming to the Firstpost report, it said Modi Government (is) in a rush to “change everything“. Luckily Firstpost devoted some time to the reason behind this, i.e. securing the UNESCO heritage tag, but eventually couldn’t stop itself from taking pot-shots at Modi again. The author says this “mania for renaming” reminds him of “Stalinist-era revisionism“. The piece goes on to say “And now a proud Hindu nationalist comes along and wants to put “Imperial” back into Delhi.”

Firstpost on its part, quoted this The Hindu report. Amusingly, this report mentions clearly that this renaming was “a proposal from the Delhi government“. Then why have Scroll.in and Firstpost blamed Modi for all this? Why does Scroll.in say “no confirmation of this news”? Apparently, a simple Google search revealed much more than what Scroll.in “journalists” couldn’t confirm.

One of the earliest news reports on renaming parts of Delhi, came way back in July 2013. It said that the dossier, containing the proposed division of the city into ‘Imperial Cities of Delhi’, among other things, was submitted to the Delhi Government by INTACH (Indian National Trust for Art and Cultural Heritage). It said the dossier has been given to Delhi Tourism, the Nodal Agency. It would then be scrutinized by the government, Archaeological Survey of India and then by world heritage apex committee and this verified dossier will then be submitted by the end of January, 2015. INTACH is a Non-Profit NGO.

The above is corroborated by this news report from September 2013 which says “the dossier has been prepared on these by INTACH”. It further says “Pitched as “Imperial Cities of Delhi”, the dossier highlights the contrasting lifestyles, cultures and architecture of two differing time periods in Delhi.

Another report from The Hindu from April 2014, quotes an INTACH official as saying “In the dossier, we have highlighted the fact that New Delhi and Shahjahanabad are two imperial cities.”

All three of the above stories are from pre-Modi era. And all three of them conclusively say one thing: An NGO floated the idea of dividing Delhi into two “Imperial cities”, and it was done only to get a UNESCO Heritage tag, to increase tourism in Delhi. The change in names, was to be carried by Delhi Development Authority, only to ensure no that the plan to get the UNESCO heritage tag, goes without a hitch. If at all any politics is to be played on this, one could “blame” the AAP Government or the UPA Government, but any unbiased reader would observe, there is no Politics here.

There are more recent news reports, like this in Indian Express and this on a Travel News site,  from February 2015 which clearly say the Central Government has approved the Delhi State Government’s proposal, with the idea of having the “Imperial Cities”. The clincher though is this Government of India Press release from February 2015 itself, which says:

The State Government of Delhi has proposed UNESCO to include ‘Delhi’s Imperial Capital Cities’ among the World Heritage Cities. The nomination dossier of ‘Delhi’s Imperial Capital Cities’ had been forwarded to UNESCO in 2014 for the purpose of its inscription in the World Heritage List

Looking at all the above facts, some questions emerge:

1. Why did Firstpost decide to blame Modi for this proposal? In fact the report from The Hindu, which they themselves relied on, says it was a Delhi Government proposal.

2. Why did Scroll.in, which relied on this Firstpost report, say that “no confirmation of the news reports has come as yet”? As you can see, a simple Google search threw up at least 6 different links from 6 different sites and sources clearly stating the facts. Are the so called “journalists” at Scroll.in so ill-equipped that they cannot even search the net for information?

In fact, this point was raised by an astute twitter user, to which a journalist from Business Standard called Mihir Sharma replied, saying it was a “good practice“:

If Mihir Sharma considers hiding behind the burqa of “unconfirmed reports” and “unnamed sources” as a “good practice” then we can judge what quality of “journalism” he approves of. And in a hilarious twist, Business Standard, the very publication Mihir Sharma works for, published a story on this issue which said:

The Delhi government has done its groundwork well. The Indian National Trust for Art and Cultural Heritage (Intach), which has prepared the Unesco nomination dossiers on behalf of the state government, has proposed the “Imperial Cities of Delhi” comprising two components – the walled city of Shahjahanabad, or Old Delhi, and the area of New Delhi designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens – for inclusion in the list of World Inhabited Historic Towns

Thus Business Standard directly contradicts the very Scroll.in article (based on unnamed sources) which Mihir Sharma was vehemently defending. It also shows Mihir Sharma’s deep ignorance of what his own site publishes.

Lets come to the actual Idea of renaming some parts of Delhi to help in boosting tourism. It may sound like a stupid, farcical idea, but if it does help in getting a UNESCO tag, and help tourism in Delhi, then we are all for it. Irrespective of whether it sounds “Imperial” or “Colonial” or Modi-fied.

(Thanks to Rahul Roushan for tipping us off on this)

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Gauravhttp://bwoyblunder.co.in/
co-founder, OpIndia.com

 

Related Articles

Trending now

From Times of Islamabad to The Hindu: 5 media outlets which ’knew about the Balakot airstrike before it happened’ according to ‘liberal’ logic

The Mumbai Police leaked the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami on the internet in order to embarrass the Republic TV Editor.

Director of ‘Tandav’ issues ‘unconditional apology’ for hurting Hindu sentiments after UP Police registers an FIR: Details

Ali Abbas Zafar, the director of the recently released controversial web series Tandav, has issued an "unconditional apology".

‘Consensual affair’ between minors and adults not a valid defense, says SC: Here’s why it is significant in view of growing Grooming Jihad cases

The Supreme Court on the 13th of January delivered a very significant judgment in a case involving the kidnapping of a minor.

As India starts world’s largest COVID vaccination drive, media organisations resort to spreading lies and fear

Several media organisations have published headlines that alluded the ward boy who died of heart attack in Moradabad, had lost his life because of COVID-19 vaccine

‘Gaadi se layenge farzi comedian ko’: UP Police reaches Madhya Pradesh to take custody of Munawar Faruqui

UP Police has sought custody of 'comedian' Munawar Faruqui in a 2020 case pertaining to allegations of insulting Hindu gods and goddesses.

Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms and censorship: The case against it and the ironic case for it

Content creators don’t stay away from picking on other communities because they fear lawsuits or court cases. They stay away because they fear raw street power.

Recently Popular

British-Pakistani singer Zayn Malik says he loves India and fans can’t keep calm

Recently, Zayn Malik was heard singing Mohammad Rafi's Chaudavi Ka Chand in the track Tightrope.

‘Madam Chief Minister’ poster row: Bhim Sena threatens to cut off Richa Chadha’s tongue, actress apologises for poster

The poster of 'Madam Chief Minister' showed Richa Chadha holding a broom. Many have called it an offensive stereotyping of the Dalit community.

‘Not a single NPA in the three decades of its existence,’ Adani Group rubbishes Subramanian Swamy’s allegations

On Friday, BJP MP Subramanian Swamy had put out allegations on Twitter against Adani accusing him of non-payment of loans worth Rs 4.5 lakhs, which has allegedly turned into an NPA.

What the Nidhi-Harvard story reveals about our world: Get off your high horse, you are not that special, anyway

Liberal journalist, Nidhi Razdan, thought she had received an offer from Harvard University to become an Associate Professor of journalism.

Congress admits Mumbai police leaked Arnab Goswami chats: Here are all the wild conspiracy theories they generated

Prithviraj Chavan has admitted that it was the Mumbai Police which leaked the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami.

Pakistan claims India staged Pulwama attack after Mumbai Police leaks chat to embarrass Arnab, Republic hits back: Details

Pakistan has now issued a statement on the nonsensical controversy surrounding the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami
- Advertisement -

 

Mamata Banerjee declares war against Suvendu Adhikari, will contest 2021 polls from Nandigram, latter says ‘challenge accepted’

Mamata Banerjee declared that she would be contesting the upcoming Assembly polls from Nandigram in Purba Medinipur.

From Times of Islamabad to The Hindu: 5 media outlets which ’knew about the Balakot airstrike before it happened’ according to ‘liberal’ logic

The Mumbai Police leaked the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami on the internet in order to embarrass the Republic TV Editor.

California pauses the use of a huge batch of Moderna COVID-19 vaccine: Read why

Prior to this, a doctor in Boston had developed a severe allergic reaction after receiving Moderna COVID-19 vaccine

‘Took his penis out and asked me to feel it’: Actress Sherlyn Chopra accuses Sajid Khan of sexual harassment

Sherlyn Chopra has come forward and alleged that Sajid Khan took his penis out of his pants when she went to meet him in 2006

Director of ‘Tandav’ issues ‘unconditional apology’ for hurting Hindu sentiments after UP Police registers an FIR: Details

Ali Abbas Zafar, the director of the recently released controversial web series Tandav, has issued an "unconditional apology".

‘Consensual affair’ between minors and adults not a valid defense, says SC: Here’s why it is significant in view of growing Grooming Jihad cases

The Supreme Court on the 13th of January delivered a very significant judgment in a case involving the kidnapping of a minor.

BBC ‘Death in Bollywood’ documentary: Jiah Khan’s sister narrates how Sajid Khan harassed the actor, says ‘he asked her to take off her top’

BBC recently come out with a documentary series titled 'Death in Bollywood' that traced the mysterious death of late actress Jiah Khan

As India starts world’s largest COVID vaccination drive, media organisations resort to spreading lies and fear

Several media organisations have published headlines that alluded the ward boy who died of heart attack in Moradabad, had lost his life because of COVID-19 vaccine

India Today CFO and Distribution Head being grilled by ED again in the fake TRP case: Read details

India Today CFO was earlier summoned by the ED for questioning in the TRP case on January 8.

‘Gaadi se layenge farzi comedian ko’: UP Police reaches Madhya Pradesh to take custody of Munawar Faruqui

UP Police has sought custody of 'comedian' Munawar Faruqui in a 2020 case pertaining to allegations of insulting Hindu gods and goddesses.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
22,800SubscribersSubscribe