Saturday, September 19, 2020
Home Media Media and the art of manufacturing narrative

Media and the art of manufacturing narrative

At an event of Upword, a new initiative that I am a part of, I was moderating the panel and therefore, kept my impulse to participate in the lively discussion largely in check. Later, however, I was asked by more than one member of the audience to write in greater detail about the theme of the discussion, “Media and the art of manufacturing narrative: Storytelling in the service of political correctness”. There is much to be said about the media and how and why they get things wrong all the time but I will try and address the fundamentals in this article.

Nassem Nicholas Taleb coined a term for the compulsive habit of intellectuals to offer half-baked theories regarding events around them and successfully providing the public with a much-needed explanation for ‘news’, which is essentially organized hearsay. He calls it the ‘narrative fallacy’ and demolishes the practitioners of the art with his incisive commentary in “The Black Swan”.

Taleb draws liberally from the works of one of the most illuminated minds of the 20th century, Daniel Kahneman. The exchange, though, is not one-sided and Kahneman acknowledges Taleb’s contribution to the ‘understanding’ of the hollowness of our explanatory models of the world in his “Thinking, Fast and Slow”. Both of them explain in their own ways, the illusion of explanation and how we hugely overrate this thing called understanding.

To get a sense of how narratives operate, the stock market is a fitting analogy. When you sell your stock, you sell it because you believe it is the best time to sell it. However, on the other side, there is someone buying it believing exactly the opposite. Both the buyer and the seller have their skins in the game and thus no one can accuse either of being careless. Both are acting in their best self-interest. Both are fooled by the coherence of their respective narrative. The truth is that only time can tell what decision is the best and more often than not, it proves seasoned traders wrong. Stock-trading is glorified gambling and people who claim to be good at it are lying, to themselves and to others. This is pretty much established beyond the shadow of a doubt, even though an entire global industry thrives on the illusion of expertise.

- Advertisement -

The power of a narrative is in its coherence and its coherence is a function of the power it wields, which is dependent on how many people believe in it. Take the case of a morally ambiguous issue like Abortion. Is it appropriate to kill an unwanted foetus just because it is inconvenient for the woman bearing it? Or is it more appropriate to force the woman to have the baby and live with the burden for the rest of her life? The questions yield no easy answers for an individual but for a society, the choice is governed by the assumptions that the majority of people subscribe to. The rest just have to fall in line.

Monopolistic religions promote one narrative, one explanation of the origins of the universe and its working principle. Anything contrary to their narrative is considered worthy of punishment. Conversion becomes an unavoidable part of their strategy as it helps them acquire more followers to strengthen the power of their narrative. In the same spirit, Marxism offers one explanation for the whole of human history. DD Kosambi, the polymath Marxist, interpreted the Bhagwadgita as a conflict between classes, so complete was his surrender to his chosen narrative. Similarly, people who are paranoid are so convinced of the reality of their phobias that you cannot talk them out of it without risking your own sanity. India, on the other hand, never had problems with multiple narratives, which reflects in the age-old pluralism of this land. I suppose all ‘pagan’ cultures knew a thing or two about myths and their superiority to ‘facts’.

The Indian sense of history is quite distinct from this chronological reconstruction of the past that we know as historiography. What we call fact-based history, created by tying together the flimsy evidence available to us from the past and then attributing motives based on the lens employed in studying the evidence is an enterprise no less speculative than inserting interesting, and sometimes fantastic, stories to convey a deeper point about the human nature. By allowing for multiple accounts to thrive and not obsessing over THE ONE TRUE account, the Indian tradition has wisely avoided the trap of history being used as a tool for manipulation of identities. Many people have been taught to think of myth as a dirty word but I believe that it is really beautiful. For example, the history presented in Mahabharata is interspersed with myths like Krishna lifting the Govardhan hill on his little finger, unless someone insists that he really lifted a hill. The point of the myth is to impart a spiritual lesson that fact-based history is incapable of.

But what really makes some belief systems insist on one version of events? These are systems where power flows top-down. Any flow of information in the other direction is a threat to the order imposed by the Caliph, Pope, Church, President or the Supreme Leader. There is one explanation for everything and that explanation comes from the top. Where this command and control mechanism is absent, there is seeming chaos, for there are as many explanations of events as there are perspectives. Moreover, in societies that avoid the trap of endorsing the one true version of history, the menace of political correctness is automatically kept in check.

Media organizations take pride in their hierarchical structures, which are very much like the church and boast of the expertise of the people they employ. Because of this inflated belief in their expertise, they get things wrong all the time, as Thomas Sowell has documented in his “Intellectuals and Society”. Kahneman calls this the illusion of validity, the near-infallible pattern of humans to commit cognitive errors due to an exaggerated belief in their own understanding. As Kahneman notes in an academic tone, most people are wrong most of the time but the experts are wrong more often than those who don’t carry the baggage of expertise.

In the spirit of the multiplicity of perspectives, we don’t claim to have the password to the objective truth. At Upword, we present the perspectives of the common people of India, whose feeble voices need an amplifier, to counter the one-dimensional narrative of the State, the Church, the Wall-Street or the Politburo.

Here is our first video.

[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=js936p_cvTE]

We are not building any grand narrative. We are not countering any lies. We are not speaking for the left or the right. We are not building any bridges nor are we burning them. We are just amplifying the voice of those who lack access to the PR machinery of totalitarian ideologies. We speak for the plants, animals, forests, rivers, temples, deities and devotees of Bharat. We speak for you. We speak for ourselves.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Ashish Dharhttp://www.pragyata.com
Ashish Dhar, a Mechanical Engineer and an entrepreneur, lives in New Delhi. He is the co-founder of Pragyata, an e-learning portal dedicated to Indic knowledge systems.

Related Articles

Trending now

Netflix distorts ‘Kabuliwala’ to show Hindu girl offering Namaz in an attempt to secularise ‘Stories by Rabindranath Tagore’

A scene in 'Kabuliwala' in the 'Stories by Rabindranath Tagore' series by Anurag Basu on Netflix shows 'Mini' offering Namaz

Protests against Left minister in Kerala gold smuggling case ‘anti-Quran’, says Communist Party leader: Here is how he came to that strange conclusion

CPI(M) state secretary Kodiyeri Balakrishnan, in his weekly column has referred to the protest against the Kerala Communist govt and minister KT Jaleel as an "anti-Quran agitation"

HRCE Dept uses the ‘we are doing what Kings did’ argument, claims ‘secular’ state of Tamil Nadu entitled to control temples

HR&CE Dept has filed an affidavit at the Madras HC saying that though the state of Tamil Nadu is secular, it is entitled to control temples.

‘No right to question integrity of successors’: 26 former cops slam Julio Ribeiro for supporting people pushing ‘anti-India and communal narrative’

26 former police officers have written a letter slamming Julio Ribeiro for supporting people who push 'anti-India and communal narrative'.

In an ironical turn of events, BMC calls Kangana Ranaut’s plea an ‘abuse of law’ after hounding her for dissenting views

In an affidavit, BMC has also demanded that costs be imposed on Kangana Ranaut for making this plea and demanding Rs 2 crores damages

Delhi Police arrests journalist Rajeev Sharma for possessing classified defence documents, had written for Chinese mouthpiece GlobalTimes

Rajeev Sharma had written several columns for Chinese newspaper Global Times, the mouthpiece of Communist Party of China for the last several years.

Recently Popular

An eyewitness tells media that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party held on the eve of her death: Here are...

An eyewitness has told News Nation that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party which she attended on the eve of her death on June 8.

‘He opened his zip and tried to force his c**k inside my vagina,’ actress Payal Ghosh accuses filmmaker Anurag Kashyap of sexual harassment

Actress Payal Ghosh has claimed that she was sexually harassed by filmmaker Anurag Kashyap and called him a hypocrite.

Here is why #BabyPenguin is trending on Twitter, and why Aaditya Thackeray is called so by some

Yuva Sena registered complaint against twitter user for calling Aaditya Thackeray "Baby Penguin" and Uddhav Thackeray "Aurangzeb"

Nepal claims Indian cities Dehradun, Nainital under its ‘Greater Nepal’ campaign: Reports

The tension between Indian and its Himalayan neighbour Nepal is likely to mount again as Nepal continues to provoke India.

“You are supposed to be unprejudiced,” investor Rakesh Jhunjhunwala schools BJP-hater NDTV journalist Sreenivasan Jain

Without nothing left to say, Sreenivasan Jain laughed aloud and claimed, "I would love to think that I am unprejudiced."

Delhi Police arrests journalist Rajeev Sharma for possessing classified defence documents, had written for Chinese mouthpiece GlobalTimes

Rajeev Sharma had written several columns for Chinese newspaper Global Times, the mouthpiece of Communist Party of China for the last several years.

‘He opened his zip and tried to force his c**k inside my vagina,’ actress Payal Ghosh accuses filmmaker Anurag Kashyap of sexual harassment

Actress Payal Ghosh has claimed that she was sexually harassed by filmmaker Anurag Kashyap and called him a hypocrite.

Fact-finding report on Bengaluru riots: Survivors claim Hindus were selectively hunted and targeted during the pre-planned riots

These testimonies establish that Bengaluru riots were pre-planned and particularized to target the Hindu community

Rajeev Sharma was paid by China to convey crucial information on Army movement, Defence acquisitions and Dalai Lama: Delhi Police

Rakesh Sharma was in contact with several Chinese operatives, and were made payments through shell companies in Delhi

Justice Kirubakaran cautions against linguistic chauvinism, warns against ‘fringe elements’ wearing the mask of NGOs and human rights organisations

Justice Kirubakaran expressed concern over media reports showing links of educated and respected people of the country with the Naxal movement.

Bihar: Hindu group attacked by Mohammed Nirala, Sarfaraz and others as Vishwakarma idol procession passes through Muslim colony

Muslims attacked a Vishwakarma idol procession in Motihari in Bihar, assaulted people, damaged the idol

More anarchy in USA? Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg passes away, liberals threaten riots as Donald Trump could have third Supreme Court pick

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, breathed her last on the 18th of September 2020 at the age of 87 after prolonged illness.

Mumbai doctor slams Maharashtra government on its new circular governing the consumption of oxygen in private COVID-19 hospitals

Dr Amit Thadani said that 12 litre per minute of oxygen is not enough for COVID-19 patients in ICU as suggested by Maharashtra govt

Devendra Fadnavis exposes how ABP Majha abruptly ended his interview, shares video of parallel recording he had arranged anticipating foul-play by the channel

Devendra Fadnavis had alleged that his interview was cut short midway while he was explaining centre's help to Maharashtra on GST credit

Sushant Singh Rajput case: Muzaffarpur court orders eight Bollywood celebrities including Salman Khan and Karan Johar to appear before it on October 7

The court has acted on the complaint filed by lawyer Sudhir Ojha, three days after the death of Sushant Singh Rajput

Days before his arrest for having classified documents, Journalist Rajeev Sharma had spoken about the state of Indian media and ethics

Rajeev Sharma had spoken about the state of media in the country and the lack of ethics in reporting the real issues

Connect with us

243,917FansLike
453,474FollowersFollow
16,000SubscribersSubscribe