Home Editor's picks Shashi Tharoor alleges the Triple Talaq bill violates the constitution. Here is how he is wrong

Shashi Tharoor alleges the Triple Talaq bill violates the constitution. Here is how he is wrong

The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Bill, 2018 popularly known as the Triple Talaq Bill, was introduced in the Lok Sabha on Monday amid opposition from several parties. Congress MP Shashi Tharoor opposed the Bill saying that it was targeting a certain religion and therefore is unconstitutional under Article 15 and 16.

“An attempt at creating a class-specific legislation on the grounds of religion. Instead of focusing on the larger issue of mistreatment and desertion of wives and dependents, which affects all communities, this bill is couched in terms of a specific religion. Therefore it is a violation Article 15 and 16 of the Constitution,” he said. “The bill has no procedural safeguards to prevent its misuse. It is therefore manifestly arbitrary, and therefore is a violation of Articles 14 (Equality before law) and 21 (Protection of life and personal liberty) of the Constitution,” he further added.

“And finally, the Parliament does not have the legislative competence to enact any law which is inconsistent with Part III of the Constitution in light of Article 13(2). So I do believe that the bill is a misconceived bill that should not be brought to the House. I do not believe that Parliament has the competence to enact such a bill,” he said.

- Advertisement - - article resumes -

Law Minister Ravishankar Prasad argued in the favour of the Bill that “despite the Supreme Court’s order making Triple Talaq [instant divorce] illegal, there is rampant use of instant triple talaq against women. We have discussed and thought about the issue and decided to bring the bill. There is a penal provision in the bill but we have improved it.”

Tharoor has termed the Bill a ‘class legislation” and hence a violation of Article 14. Article 14 prohibits improper discrimination by conferring particular privileges or imposing liabilities on an arbitrarily selected class of persons. However, the provision permits reasonable classification for the purpose of achieving specific ends. The Supreme Court has in a number of cases laid down the criteria to determine whether a piece of legislation is class legislation or not. The test says that-

  1. The classification must be based on intelligible differentia which distinguishes persons or things that are grouped together from others left out of the group.
  2. The differentia must have rational relation with the object to be achieved by the legislation.

Here in the case of the Triple Talaq Bill, the Supreme Court set aside the practice of Triple Talaq declaring it unconstitutional. It also directed the Government to consider an appropriate legislation with reference to Talaq-e-Biddat or Tripple Talaq.

The Bill was drafted following the directions of the Supreme Court to address the social evil of Triple Talaq which ruined the lives of women Muslim women for years. Here the class concerned is an already existing class i.e. the Muslim community and the object to be achieved is the abolition of the evil practice of Triple Talaq prevalent in the community. So the legislation is not at all creating a new class, it is only addressing a problem pertaining to an already existing class. Therefore Tharoor’s argument of calling the Bill as a class legislation does not hold water.

So far as the question of the Bill being violative of Articles 15 or 16 is concerned, for the reason of being discriminatory on the ground of religion, it is definitely not so. In a case where a problem pertains to a certain community, the legislation seeking to address the problem will inevitably apply to the community. An example of such a legislation can be the Bengal Sati Regulation 1829 which addressed the social evil of Sati (immolation of a Hindu widow on the funeral pyre of her husband) and made it illegal. While Article 15 prevents gender discrimination, it also empowers the legislature to make special provision for women and children. The Triple Talaq Bill being an effort in the direction of the empowerment of Muslim women has the support of this provision. Article 16 on the other hand, does not come into the picture at all as it refers to equality of opportunity in matters of public employment.

Tharoor has also said that there was no need of criminalising an act which is already null and void by virtue of the judgment of the court. As was mentioned in the Preamble to the Triple Talaq Ordinance 2018, that despite the Supreme Court declaring the practice of Triple Talaq as unconstitutional, the cases of Triple Talaq are still continuing unabated. In such a situation, it becomes necessary to instill the fear of law in the hearts of offenders because of whom the Muslim women continue to suffer. There were reports on how Muslim women are still being humiliated at the hands of their husbands who continue to use triple talaq as a weapon of subjugation against them even after the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Bill 2017 was introduced.

Tharoor, who is an accused in his wife Sunanda Pushkar’s murder case, seems to be more worried about the rights of the men who practice Triple Talaq than the women whose life as well as dignity is compromised because of such practices.

Help Us Reach Every Indian, Please Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Advertisement

Big Story

80 doctors at the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital in Kolkata have resigned demanding an apology from the Chief Minister for her remarks.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

Read OpIndia.com's response to the defamation notice served by Swati Chaturvedi

That you have lost readership and your peers doubt you, is not our problem: Read our response to Swati Chaturvedi’s defamation notice

Recently, OpIndia.com got a legal notice from abusive media troll Swati Chaturvedi. At the onset, we would like to reiterate that such intimidatory tactics won't work with OpIndia.

Rahul Gandhi finally arrives in Parliament, but stays true to form and goofs up while taking oath as MP

A Lok Sabha official stopped Rahul Gandhi and told him that he has to sign the register after taking oath

Pakistani Twitter erupts in self-deprecating humour as their cricket team stares at imminent defeat

India registered its 7th consecutive win against Pakistan in Cricket World Cup tournaments.
NDTV's takes journalism to new heights by asking Rahul Gandhi how did he like his samosa

Rahul Gandhi got conned by his own men: Report says ‘Big Data’ head Praveen Chakravarty billed Congress 24 crores and is now absconding

A day prior to election results, Rahul Gandhi had reportedly even contacted UPA allies and offered to accommodate them in the cabinet.

Even as 700 doctors resign, TMC leader Abu Taher Khan Chaudhury accused of threatening doctors with rape and murder

There are videos circulating on social media which purportedly show the Trinamool MP from Murshidabad, Abu Taher Khan threatening the doctors at the institution. The politician, however, has denied all allegations.

Here is what you missed when the India-Pakistan match was on

News you may have missed due to the India-Pakistan match yesterday

LokSatta and Karan Thapar scolded by Press Council of India for peddling fake news against the RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat

While Thapar maintained that his mistake of wrongly attributing quotes to Dr Mohan Bhagwat was bonafide, the PCI has taken a tough stand against Thapar.
India won by 89 runs in their WC match against Pakistan

India refuses to be mediocre and docile, if that is ‘cold hearted’ for this Guardian writer, so be it

Some people, who have clearly run out of issues to find faults, have come up with a brilliant demonstration of what Hindi Twitter knows as 'Naraaz Fufa'.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

170,587FansLike
149,474FollowersFollow
69,781SubscribersSubscribe
Help Us Reach Every Indian, Please Share This Post