Home Blog Page 4288

Shekhar Gupta’s ThePrint gives space to Chhattisgarh CM Bhupesh Baghel to spread falsehoods over Coronavirus pandemic

Shekhar Gupta’s online publication, ThePrint, on Wednesday, April 21, 2021, published an interview with Chhattisgarh CM Bhupesh Baghel.

Shekhar Gupta’s tweet

In the interview, Baghel claimed, “During the first wave, we had sealed the borders early so we managed to contain the spread. But as far as the second wave is concerned, the Centre did not issue an alert to the states. They knew about it but they did not issue any alerts.”

However, according to a report dated January 7, 2021, published in ThePrint itself, the Central Government asked four states – Maharashtra, Kerala, West Bengal, and Chhattisgarh to maintain a “strict vigil” and take steps in order to curb a COVID-19 surge in their respective states.

ThePrint article from January 2021

According to the report, in January, Union Health Secretary Rajesh Bhushan wrote to these states including Chhattisgarh in order to draw their attention “to the low and declining testing rates in the states, stating that any laxity at this crucial junction may squander the results of our collective actions in containing the transmission.”

“It is important to ensure that there is no complacency in the collective efforts in containment and management of COVID-19,” the health secretary told states including Chhattisgarh in January.

In his interview with ThePrint, Baghel blames the migrant workers coming in from the politically-allied neighboring Maharashtra for the recent spike in Chhattisgarh’s COVID-19 cases. It is of note that both Maharashtra and Chhattisgarh were cautioned and asked to maintain “a strict vigil” in order to curb COVID-19 back in January itself.

“The second issue about the second wave is that from the district of Rajnandgaon, Maharashtra starts through Nagpur. We have a migratory population there and people keep going and coming. Several families have temporary homes in Nagpur and they work there and people keep coming and going back,” he said, without receiving any sort of journalistic pushback.

No stranger to gaslighting

The Chhattisgarh Government is no stranger to gaslighting or passing the buck when it comes to dealing with the pandemic. The Bhupesh Baghel-led government has also engaged in pushing vaccine hesitancy narratives, which have been completely disproven in hindsight.

In February 2021, Chhattisgarh Health Minister TS Singh Deo said he does not support the use of Covaxin, one of the two vaccines which were approved for emergency use then, in Chhattisgarh. Chief Minister Baghel, too, had cast aspersions on the safety of the Covaxin and indulged in fear-mongering. Just yesterday, an ICMR study declared Covaxin to be effective even against COVID-19 variants.

It is imperative to note that when Chhattisgarh was gripped in the second wave of coronavirus infection, Baghel was busy in Assam, campaigning for Congress and predicting his party’s victory. As of now, there are over 5.88 lakh total coronavirus cases in Chhattisgarh, of which 1.22 lakh are active cases. The state has announced a complete lockdown in all 28 districts from Tuesday.

Unfortunately, the journalists at ThePrint did not seek clarification for any of the above issues from Bhupesh Baghel himself in the course of their interview. Hopefully, in their next interview maybe CM Baghel will finally be challenged with some actually tough and critical questions.

NDTV journalist Gargi Rawat Ansari shows how she is willing to sacrifice human lives so propaganda continues to reign supreme

Earlier today, amidst the second wave of the Coronavirus pandemic, Vedanta-owned Sterlite Copper has offered to restart production at its two oxygen plants in the now shut copper smelter at Thoothukudi in Tamil Nadu. Vedanta said that the plant contains two oxygen plants with a combined production capacity of 1,050 tonnes of oxygen daily.

Interestingly, while the Oxygen requirement of India has gone up 7 times, from 700 tonnes per day to 5,000 tonnes per day, the Tamil Nadu government has opposed the plea of the Vedanta-owned Sterlite Copper plant. The central government has reportedly supported the proposal by Sterlite to open their oxygen plants so the increased demand in India can be met amidst the raging pandemic.

Vedanta, in the Supreme Court, was being represented by senior advocate Harish Salve. He submitted before the Supreme Court that If Vedanta was allowed to re-open in Tamil Nadu, the oxygen produced could help the country. The Solicitor General of India, Tushar Mehta, said that the country is in dire need of oxygen and that the court should allow Vedanta at least just to re-open their Oxygen manufacturing unit.

Opposing this, the state government said that Vedanta was closed due to environmental concerns and that there is a “trust deficit” between the company and the people of Tamil Nadu.

While it is interesting that the Tamil Nadu state government seems to be far more concerned about the environmental concerns, real or imagined, if Vedanta opens again, it does not seem to bothered about how many people the additional 1000 tonnes of oxygen could help.

While the state of Tamil Nadu indulged in politics in this respect, NDTV journalists also chimed in to make comments against Harish Salve, who was representing Vedanta in the Supreme Court.

Gargi Rawat Ansari, who is married to Yusuf Ahmad Ansari, the great-grandson of former Congress President Mukhtar Ahmad Ansari, took to Twitter to say, “How nice of Harish Salve to slip in an appeal to open Vedanta unit in Tuticorin that was closed due to environmental concerns and violations. Very smooth. Don’t let a crisis go to waste”.

Essentially, Gargi Rawat Ansari was essentially saying that the loss of lives due to a shortage of oxygen is acceptable as long as the environment, to whatever extent.

Interestingly, it was Ansari herself who was outraging about the lack of oxygen in various cities of India.

On the 20th of April, Gargi Rawat Ansari took to Twitter to outrage, rightfully so, about the lack of oxygen in Delhi and other parts of the country.

Even on the 16th of April, Gargi Rawat Ansari was talking about the shortage of oxygen and medicines.

Interestingly, after spending days outraging about the lack of oxygen and medicines, Gargi Rawat Ansari has now taken to Twitter to oppose a plant opening that can actually produce 1000 tonnes extra of oxygen that can cap the increased demand.

The cognitive dissonance with Gargi Rawat seems to be so strong, that within a span of 3 minutes, she managed to outrage against the support for Vedanta that has offered to produce additional oxygen and also outrage about the deaths due to COVID-19 happening in the country.

Screenshot of tweets by Gargi Rawat Ansari

It is pertinent to note that the Vedanta-owned Sterlite Copper plant in Thoothukudi was shut down by Tamil Nadu in May 2018 following the violent protests staged by the locals and activists, who alleged that the plant posed serious health hazards. 

Though the plant later got clearance by the National Green Tribunal, the state government approached the Supreme Court seeking a stay on the National Green Tribunals order. The apex court stayed the order of the NGT and allowed Sterlite Copper to approach the Madras High Court, which upheld the government order. The case is now in the Supreme Court with Sterlite Copper challenging the Madras High Court verdict. The company’s plea to access the plant for just maintenance purposes has also not been entertained by the court so far.

The closure of the Sterlite Copper plant had such widespread ramifications that it made the country an importer of copper cathodes from being one of the top five exporters.

The left propaganda against the Tuticorin plant seems to be far more important than human lives amidst the pandemic for the usual suspects from NDTV and beyond even though the Green Tribunal has given the plant clearance. However, it seems like if the actual shortage of oxygen is solved in India and human lives are saved, the left cabal would have paltry little to create their propaganda on. Given the Left’s propensity to build political castles on the dead bodies of Indian citizens, one has to agree with Gargi there.. ‘Don’t let a crisis go to waste’.

Cipla issues caution against Remdesivir scammers: Preying on the vulnerable and how you can save yourself

Pharmaceutical company Cipla has issued a cautionary notice against the scammers regarding Remdesivir. In the notice, the company asked the public to beware of the unscrupulous persons as they have set up bank accounts fraudulently in the name of Cipla Ltd. The notice suggests that such scammers are enticing the public to transfer funds in these accounts towards the alleged supply of medicines upon remittance.

Cipla further added that such persons are not connected with or authorised by the company. “Authorities have been alerted and are investigating the matter. We urge consumers to source Cipla products only through our authorised stockists and channel partners,” it added.

Social media posts revealed people panic-paid frauds for injections

When we searched on social media to find out if there were people cheated by scammers on the pretext of arranging Remdesivir injections, we found a few tweets that suggested such scams have been happening more frequently than anyone would have thought.

Sourabh Tiwari mentioned on Twitter that he called a number from Mumbai for Remdesivir. The person on the other side claimed to arrange the injection in two hours. He asked Tiwari to transfer money to his account. On suspicion when Tiwari checked the details, the number was not from Mumbai but West Bengal and the account number was a private bank account.

Another user Pooja Mehta put out her ordeal how she was cheated of Rs.28,000/- by one Abhishek Kumar. He claimed to be an employee of Zydus Pharmaceuticals and took Rs.28,000/- from her on the pretext of arranging Tocilizumab.

Pooja also shared conversation between her and Abhishek where she alleged that he had “lied through his teeth until the last minute.”

Another user had replied to union minister Ravi Shankar Prasad where he alleged that he had paid one Ajay Agarwal for the Remidesivir injection and now he is not picking up his calls.

Another user Jyoti had alleged she paid someone Rs.15,000 for the injection but now his number was switched off.

Another user Nachiketa shared a similar story where he called up a number that he got on social media but it was saved as “Remdesivir fraud” on Truecaller.

Ways to save yourself from scams

First of all, please do not pay anyone online for injections, especially before getting the medicine.

As mentioned by Cipla in its advisory, always go to an authorised distributor for the injection. Cipla has provided lists of authorised distributors for both Tocilizumab [PDF] and Remdesivir [PDF] that can be accessed from their website.

There are a lot of lists floating around on Social Media platforms that claim to be verified. Before trusting anyone of them, please call the number and try to find out if the distributor has some online presence. Double-check the information and pay only when you get the medicine in hand.

There have been cases where people arranged some medicines for a few people but later collected money and switched off the phone. It is a basic tactic of scammers first to gain trust and then run away with the money. It is strongly advised not to pay anyone in advance for the medicine without verifying the details.

Railway pointsman who saved child of a visually impaired woman donates half his prize money to the family

0

At a time when grim reports of the coronavirus pandemic have clasped the nation, the story of braveheart Mayur Shelke comes as a breath of fresh air. 

In a supremely courageous act, Poinstman Mayur Shelke, had recently risked his own life to save the life of the child who had fallen on the railway tracks of Vangani Station of Central Railway in Thane on April 17. The child was walking with his visually impaired mother when he suddenly fell on the tracks. The woman, unable to see her son, was helplessly calling for help while a train was fast approaching on the very same tracks.

For his act of bravery, the Ministry of Railways had awarded him Rs 50,000, half of which Shelke has now decided to donate to the visually impaired mother and her child.

He also urged the people wanting to meet him and award him for his selfless act to instead donate to the mother and child duo. 

“These are difficult times of Covid-19 pandemic and all those who wish to donate money, hand over cheques to me can offer the money to the mother and the child or any other needy in these times,” he said in an appeal on social media.

Shelke was welcomed with a round of applause and was felicitated by the railway staff at the Central Railway office for his bravery.

In a heart-wrenching incident that was captured by the CCTV footage of the railway platform, a visually-challenged woman was seen walking on the platform when her 6-year-old child walking beside her suddenly stumbled and fell onto the railway tracks below. 

Pointsman Shelke sprinted on the tracks, pushed the child back on the platform and pulled himself up in time, just as the high-speed Bengaluru-Mumbai Udayan Express train was seen approaching on the same track. 

The passerbys on the platform immediately rushed to the spot to check on them. Fortunately all went unhurt. 

The video soon went viral on social media and Railway Minister Piyush Goyal personally congratulated Shelke on the phone and said that the railway family was proud of him.

West Bengal: Mamata Banerjee holds massive rally in Dakshin Dinajpur, refers to PM, HM as “goons”

West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee held a major rally in Dakshin Dinajpur today, where she attacked Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, calling them “two goons of Delhi”.

“I am not a player, but I know how to play. I was the best player in the Lok Sabha earlier. We cannot surrender our Bengal to two goons of Delhi,” said Mamata. This massive rally also garnered some criticism online because of its potential role in facilitating the spread of COVID-19.

Critics were quick to juxtapose pictures from Mamata’s big rally at Dakshin Dinajpur today, with TMC leader Mahua Moitra’s tweet criticizing the BJP leadership for holding electoral rallies amidst the Coronavirus pandemic. “Indians watching helplessly as this Modi Made Disaster explodes”, wrote the TMC MP on Twitter.

TMC MP Derek O’Brien had on April 18 claimed that Mamata Banerjee will not campaign in Kolkata anymore and slashed time for rallies.

However, he had not clarified whether Mamata Banerjee will continue to hold massive rallies or not.

Today, West Bengal is voting in the 6th phase of the 2021 West Bengal Legislative Assembly Elections. There are two more phases of voting to go on April 26 and April 29. The results of the elections will be declared on May 2.

On Wednesday, West Bengal reported over 10,000 new coronavirus cases in the state. Total active cases stand at over 63,000

Pfizer and 10 other corporates donated $1 million each to Joe Biden’s inaugural committee, totalling $61.8 million: Reports

According to financial disclosure, U.S. President Joe Biden’s inaugural committee raised $61.8 million from contributions by corporations like Pfizer and Uber, labour unions and other wealthy individuals for his inauguration events, as per a Reuters report.

As per the filing submitted on Tuesday with the Federal Election Commission, the Democratic president’s inaugural committee took $1 million in contributions each from about 10 big companies which include Pfizer Inc- the maker of one of the COVID-19 vaccines in the United States, AT&T Services Inc, Bank of America Corp, Boeing Co, Uber Technologies Inc, Lockheed Martin Corp and Qualcomm Inc.

Around 12 individuals donated $500,000 each, according to the filing. The report, however, did not give details on how the money was utilized for the events as the traditional inaugural ceremony was given a miss due to the ongoing pandemic. However, the inauguration included televised performances by Lady Gaga and Garth Brooks.

As compared to Donald Trump’s $106 million raised, Biden’s committee was way below the mark but exceeded the $53 million raised by Barack Obama for his first inauguration in 2009.

In accordance with the 20th Amendment of the United States Constitution, the Joint Congressional Committee on Inaugural Ceremonies (JCCIC) has been responsible for the planning and execution of the Inaugural Ceremonies of the President-elect and Vice President-elect of the United States at the Capitol since 1901. 

The procession, swearing-in ceremonies, inaugural address, signing ceremony are all done under the jurisdiction of the JCCIC. 

After Rakesh Tikait got vaccinated himself, BKU issues another threat to the Modi govt amid the Coronavirus pandemic: Read details

Despite the alarming surge of Covid-19 cases in Delhi, the so-called farmers, who have been protesting and even indulged in violence earlier, have refused to budge an inch from the protesting sites. The ‘farmers’ who have been disrupting the borders for months are now interrupting the transportation of medical oxygen supply critical to saving lives of Covid-19 infected patients.

After so-called farmers deciding to march from Punjab to Delhi yet again, Rakesh Tikait led Bhartiya Kisan Union has been issuing threats, warning the BJP government to not make any attempts to vacate the protesting site. In the latest threat issued by Gurnam Singh Charuni of the BKU, he has warned of serious consequences if the government tries to vacate the borders in the garb of the corona crisis.

Interestingly, this was the same statement that was issued by Icchadhari protestor Yogendra Yadav when he had earlier said that the Modi government was trying to end the protest under the pretext of the Coronavirus pandemic.

On April 17 too, Charuni had issued a warning threatening the party in power. His tweet read, “BJP should not be mistaken that they will be able to get the farmers to vacate the protest sites. If the Government takes such an action, the BJP will not be able to save its face.

A couple of days ago, while on a visit to Jammu, farmer leader Rakesh Tikait had asserted that the ‘farmers’ agitation was not Shaheen Bagh that can be ended in the name of coronavirus.

This is not where it ends for the alleged ‘farmers’. At a time when the nation has recorded over 3 lakh new coronavirus cases, the protesting farmers chose to throw an Iftar party at the Ghazipur border in the national capital flouting all Covid-19 norms including social distancing. 

The shocking videos of the party had emerged on social media where farmers leaders including Rakesh Tikait were seen dining in a large group at the protesting site.

Absolutely unaffected by the current crisis of the Covid-19 pandemic that has crippled the entire country,  Bhartiya Kisan Union has announced a march to Delhi on April 21 in order to protest against the Farm laws. This march comes at a time when Delhi is going through a surge in new coronavirus cases breaking all previous records, acute shortage of medical oxygen, hospital beds and testing facilities depleting rapidly. 

Rakesh Tikait gets himself vaccinated

Shooting off farmers’ shoulders, Tikait insisted that the ongoing pandemic cannot be a reason to put the ‘farmers’ protest on hold, after getting himself vaccinated

To add to it, he said the central government will be held responsible if farmers protesting at the borders of the national capitals are infected with the coronavirus.

Speaking with Republic Media Network, Tikait said, “Responsibility lies solely with the government if the farmers get infected with the virus. When the COVID-19 cases are rising across the country, who is responsible for it? Are farmers responsible for that too?”

He further added, “If there is a disease, then the government should ensure treatment for it and build hospitals for it. Politicians are collecting funds for other purposes. They are conducting rallies and contesting elections.”

Hindustan Times publishes a misleading article by Congress worker Praveen Chakravarty: Has India inoculated only 7% of its population?

It is often said that one should never let a crisis go to waste. With the COVID-19 pandemic and a gush of the second wave in India, the media and the opposition parties are almost having a field day, amidst the death and destruction the pandemic is leaving in its wake. With a sharp rise in the curve and over 2 lakh people testing positive in one day, the second wave is far worse than the first. At such a time, the media has been rather irresponsible in giving a platform to those who wish to play politics over the funeral pyres that have not even gone cold yet.

Hindustan Times today published an opinion piece by ‘Data analyst’ Praveen Chakravarty, who is a Congress party worker.

In the article published by the Hindustan Times, Chakravarty says the following:

Article by Praveen Chakravarty

Praveen Chakravarty, Congress’ data analytics person, says that India has inoculated 7% of its population and needs to focus on increasing that percentage to 75%.

Essentially, there seems nothing too wrong with this suggestion. There is nothing wrong in saying that India needs to scale up its vaccination process and must reach the 75% mark in the shortest time possible. However, according to Praveen Chakravarty himself, the most important number that India needs to focus on and remember “every single day in the fight against Covid” is that of 7%.

While politicians will politic, for any publication, getting its numbers right is extremely important. Just as one gets started as an editor, or even a journalist, one is careful to ensure that the basics of the report – what, why, who, when, how much, names, places, etc are accurate. These details form the very foundation of the report and are facts that must not be trifled with.

Hindustan Times, however, seems to have dropped the ball in its urgency to publish an article that would seem to stir the political pot and therefore, benefit their publication in terms of readership.

While the opinion piece by Praveen Chakravarty claims that only 7% of the population has been inoculated, on the 8th page of Hindustan Times itself, the numbers show a very different picture.

On the 8th page of Hindustan Times, the paper declares that a total of 13.22 crore ‘total vaccinated across India’.

Infographic from Hindustan Times

According to the official government website, 11.3 crore people have received at least 1 dose of the vaccination.

Stats according to GOI website

When one extrapolates that, it would come to about 8.3% of the entire population (taking the entire population to be 136 crores).

Therefore, when about 8.3% of the population has been inoculated according to Hindustan Times’ own numbers, the paper allowed Praveen Chakravarty to claim that only about 7% have been inoculated.

Further, one has to bear in mind that India was focussing on phased vaccination till now. Therefore, front-line workers and those above 45 have been targeted for vaccination so far. Given that multiple reports say that 25% of India’s population is above the age of 45, that would amount to about 34 crores. According to population projection for 2021 by census India, the population above 45 years of age is 34.5 crore. If we take that as a benchmark, the Government of India managed to inoculate 32.75% of the target group so far, give or take some since it also included health care workers.

Now, if we want to know what percentage of the adult population has been vaccinated, we get that India’s 18+ population is around 90 crore according to the population projection prepared in 2019 by the Census India [PDF]. Therefore, India has vaccinated almost 12.5% of the adult population. It may be noted that except the USA, no other country has opened up vaccination for the 18+ population, while India is scheduled to open it up from 1st May.

Therefore, it is rather evident that the 7% used by Praveen Chakravarty as a bedrock of his article is wildly incorrect no matter how one looks at it and a large part of the blame goes to Hindustan Times, that clearly failed to employ quality filters during the editing process. While during other times, this could be charted to oversight by HT, during a pandemic when the country is descending into panic, it has to be the responsibility of the media to present a true picture of facts, and not blindly publish what politicians and their aides want one to.

While Hindustan Times has surely failed in its duty, it would appear that Praveen Chakravarty succeeded in his, given that he has a long history of not only spreading fake news but also working for the Congress party, that has regularly indulged in fear-mongering in the midst of the pandemic.

Following the 2019 general elections debacle, while Congress IT cell head Divya Spandana had disappeared into an abyss, the grand old party’s data analytics head Praveen Chakravarty was back in the news as AICC Technology and Data Cell Chairman.

Praveen Chakravarty, it is to be noted, was also the founding trustee of the faulty ‘hate tracker’ of the dubious data analytics website, IndiaSpend. It is pertinent to note that the hate spearheaded by Chakravarty has been picked up by several publications to further a problematic narrative against Hindus. If one recalls, The Wire and IndiaSpend’s fact-checker journalist was caught trying to manipulate Dalit victims who were attacked by local Muslims to prove that there was ‘no hate crime’.

After Congress’ humiliating defeat, Chakravarty was accused of misleading the then Congress President Rahul Gandhi and feeding him wrong information. In fact, Congress also suspected that Praveen Chakravarty was a mole planted by the Modi government to ensure that Rahul Gandhi is fed misinformation in order to hand him a loss. In July 2019, it was reported that Congress will disband the data analytics department. And while the department was indeed disbanded, Praveen Chakravarty was rehabilitated in its restructured ‘technology and data cell’.

In June 2019 it was reported that Chakravarty had allegedly conned Rahul Gandhi and set him up for the humiliating defeat. Rahul Gandhi was reportedly made to believe that the party would secure somewhere between 164 and 184 seats in the 2019 general elections. Congress, however, ended with 52 seats and Gandhi even lost the ‘family’ seat of Amethi which has elected many of his family members.

Praveen Chakravarty was responsible for handling the Shakti App on the basis of which inputs were given to Rahul Gandhi. He was evidently made to believe by Praveen Chakravarty that the party will be securing somewhere between 164 and 184 seats in the elections.

Fake stories of suffering by social media ‘influencers’ amidst COVID-19 outbreak: What it says about our moral compass?

For the last few weeks, India has been grappling with a resurgent coronavirus outbreak that threatens to overwhelm the country’s health care system. States across the country, particularly Maharashtra and Delhi, started reporting an alarming spike in the daily new cases, contributing immensely to the rising tally of the COVID-19 cases.

Over 2.5 lakh new coronavirus cases are being reported for the last few days, the highest since the start of the pandemic last year. Hospitals across the country, especially in the hotspot regions, are swarmed with patients infected with the virus and the health complications it brings in its wake.

Consequently, the country’s health care infrastructure came under tremendous strain as the number of people seeking medical intervention to combat COVID-19 grew exponentially. Unavailability of isolation and ICU beds, shortages of oxygen supplies and vital medicinal drugs such as Remdesivir were reported from several parts of the country.

Amidst times of distress, people turn to social media for salvation

A general wave of panic and anxiety swept across the country as people ran pillar to post in search of vacant hospital beds, medicinal oxygen cylinders and stocks of Remdesivir injections to help their closed-ones in their battle against the coronavirus. However, with the hospitals overstretched and the resources depleting, many failed in getting beds, oxygen cylinders or Remdesivir injections.

In such times of profound distress and adversity, many individuals took it upon themselves to compile the data of vacant beds available in the hospitals, contact details of suppliers who could provide medicinal oxygen and Remdesivir, and share the same on social media websites.

Several social media influencers jumped into the fray, extending every possible help that they could to the people in securing hospital beds, oxygen cylinders and vials of Remdesivir injections. Some of them even ran crowdfunding campaigns on social media to provide financial assistance to those who could not afford the exorbitant costs of fighting the coronavirus.

Social media websites, on their part, proved incredibly helpful to people who had otherwise lost hope in getting beds or securing life-saving drugs. It played a pivotal role in connecting people who were seeking help to those who were qualified and resourceful enough to offer assistance. However, as is the case with most things in life, this kindness also had a downside.

Crooks on social media exploit the COVID-19 crisis to line their pockets

While there were many genuine social media influencers who went out on a limb to extend assistance to people in need, there were some others who used the opportunity to feed on the vulnerability of the people in such testing times and take undue advantage of the crisis.

Many people on social media ran crowdfunding campaigns, alleging that the money from the donations would go towards helping the underprivileged who could not afford the cost of getting the treatment for COVID-19. They urged their followers to donate, in spades, to help such people in defraying their hospital and medicinal cost.

However, as it turned out, many of the stories that accompanied such crowdfunding requests were fabrications. The social media influencers had tried to illicitly collect funds by appealing to the sympathies of the people. Well-meaning folks who sincerely wanted to help the poor and the needy ones and even those who themselves needed help saw themselves being duped by these morally bankrupt social media influencers.

A Twitter user recently exposed one of the social media users who was purporting to raise money, allegedly for a sister with COVID-19. When the Twitter user contacted the hospital to seek details of the patient, the social media user deleted all her tweets and blocked her.

Baffled, the Twitter user tried out to find out if the hospital was charging excessive from the patients for the COVID-19 treatment. As it turned out, the hospital owners were probably innocent and were working round the clock to treat the COVID-19 patients.

Another social media user Abhishek Dwivedi revealed how he found every single story of his Instagram friend helping people with oxygen cylinders fake.

There are also reports doing the rounds on the internet about people posting pictures of life-saving medicines, including Remdesivir, on social media and taking orders with advance payment.

In utter desperation, some people send money, but the life-saving drugs never arrive.

Donors should exercise caution before getting swayed to donate

The aforementioned instances are but a few cases when social media influencers are exposed for their depravity. There are, surely, many other cases that do not come to the fore because the donors simply do not bother to check if the money they had donated ever reached the actual beneficiary or not.

Based on the emotional appeal of the posts uploaded by social media influencers, people proceed to donate money without making any effort to verify if the cause is legitimate and the beneficiary authentic. Most folks make their donations and carry on with their lives, believing that they did their ‘part’ of the duty.

The lethargy in not seeking additional details of the suspicious crowdfunding campaigns also can be attributed to the celebrity endorsement the cause gets. When people see celebrities or famous personalities endorsing a crowdfunding campaign, they usually take its authenticity for granted.

In many cases, celebrities who endorse such crowdfunding campaign do not bother to ascertain if the money pooled is routed to the beneficiary. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the donors to remain vigilant and authenticate the cause before donating. It is pertinent for them to bear in mind that some unscrupulous individuals are lurking on social media to prey on their empathy to feather their own nest.

And what’s worse? Because of a few immoral individuals, even those who genuinely want to help others are viewed with suspicion. The skulduggery of select individuals undercuts the efforts of a large number of well-meaning social media users who are earnestly and tirelessly assisting people in the fight against COVID-19. It is, therefore, important to make the distinction between the two so that those who need help are not deprived of it. The diminishing moral conscience of a few perverse individuals should not impinge on the altruist efforts of many.

The moral bankruptcy of social media ‘influencers’ to concoct fake stories of people’s sufferings amidst pandemic

These incidents, however, reflect our society’s decaying moral compass, where making profits takes precedence over preserving and nurturing ideals of honesty and integrity. People have become so callous and indifferent to the sufferings of others that they have no qualms in exploiting them to advance their purpose.

While one doesn’t expect crooks to have ethical precepts guiding their behaviour, they are, nonetheless, still expected to exhibit basic decency. Perhaps, it is a tad too much to expect.

The COVID-19 outbreak has wreaked havoc across the world, including in India. There have been thousands of deaths precipitated by the complications caused by the coronavirus. The situation is grim as governments around the world have struggled to contain the infection. To use this global crisis to illicitly make money by concocting fake stories of sufferings and travails endured by people takes a particularly egregious kind of moral debasement.

However, in testing times, do not lose your faith in humanity. People with their hearts in right place are giving all the could to help those in need. Do not let few bad cases stop you from doing good. Do good anyway. We are in this together. And we shall emerge stronger and kinder out of this mess.

Late-night urgent hearings by Delhi and Bombay high courts on oxygen and Remdesivir shortage

On April 21, the Delhi High Court and Bombay High Court conducted emergency hearings amidst a shortage of oxygen and Remdesivir in the states. While the Delhi High Court asked the center to ‘beg, borrow or steal’ oxygen to provide for medical purposes, the Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court pulled up the state government for not complying with the previous orders to provide Remdesivir.

Beg, borrow or steal oxygen, tells Delhi High Court to center

During an urgent hearing on the plea filed by Max Hospital, the Delhi High Court came down on the union government heavily and questioned if human lives are not important. The divisional bench comprising of Justice Vipin Sanghi and Justice Rekha Pelli said that the centre must “beg, borrow or steal oxygen to provide to the hospital. It is a national emergency.”

In its plea, the Max Hospital had stated that they were on dangerously low levels of oxygen supply. Notably, the situation was quite similar in other hospitals in Delhi. While the hearing for Max Hospital was happening in the High Court, Rathi Hospital, located in Najafgarh, was running from post to pillar to arrange oxygen. There were 78 critical patients in the hospital. After hours of running around, they were able to procure oxygen with the help of the Delhi Police.

We cannot shut our eyes, said the Court

The Court mentioned that the number of Covid-19 cases has been doubling every 10 days. It is the ground reality that there is a shortage of oxygen. “It is not that it is artificial or being wrongly projected. It is there. We cannot shut our eyes to it,” the Court added. The Court said that the state could not say that it can only provide that much oxygen and no more. “We will have to enforce the fundamental rights of people and direct beg, borrow and steal and do whatever you have to do, but you have to do. We cannot see people dying because people are dying,” said the Court.

Curtail state-run steel plants and petroleum industries

The centre had earlier exempted some industries from the ban on industrial use of oxygen. The Bench asked the government why they were not curtailing the state-run steel plants and petroleum industries to whatever is absolutely critical. “We can understand that you cannot shut down petroleum production completely in the country because it is a critical thing by itself, but you can reduce it. We are sure that if you were to divert their oxygen for medical use, you would be able to meet the requirement,” the Court said.

If it means to shut down the industries, for the time being, let it be – Delhi High Court

The Court said if procuring oxygen from the industries means that those industries have to be shut down for the time being, let them be. “we cannot afford to lose lives. That is the bottom line,” said the Court.

Delhi’s lawyer was unable to connect to Deputy CM

During the hearing, Advocate Mehra was asked to take instructions from the Deputy Chief Minister of Delhi. However, he was unable to connect to him. The Solicitor General said on record that he was ready to make a statement that the union minister had talked to deputy CM minutes before.

Provide safe passage to oxygen tankers

There have been reports that the oxygen tankers were not getting passage on the Delhi borders where farmers are protesting. The Court has asked the center to provide safe passage to the tankers. Earlier, when the oxygen suppliers had approached Delhi Police to provide support for passage, the Police had created a green corridor to ensure a smooth transition from other states.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said that the decisions related to closing down the industries are only possible at the higher levels. He asked for an adjournment for a day so that he could take instructions and reply to the Court accordingly. The Court will hear the matter today at 3 PM. While adjourning the session, the Court said, “We are hopeful that the emergent needs of various hospitals in Delhi will be met so that no casualties are suffered on account of discontinued supply of oxygen to seriously ill Covid patients and other patients who require oxygen support till we take up the matter and pass orders tomorrow.”

‘Ashamed to be part of nasty society’ Bombay High Court pulls up Maharashtra government

The Nagpur Bench of Bombay High Court was not pleased with the state authorities for non-compliance with its order passed on April 19 regarding the supply of 10,000 vials of Remdesivir injections to Nagpur district. MG Bhangde, appearing for the State, submitted two affidavits from Joint Commissioner (FDA) and the other by Additional Collector, Nagpur. The Court noted that the contents of the affidavits were contradictory.

The Bench comprising of Justice SB Shukre and SM Modak said that they seemed to have shirked away from the responsibility of providing relief to the Covid-19 patients. “This life-saving drugs not being made available is violating the fundamental rights of people. It is now clear that these authorities are shirking responsibilities,” the Court said.

The Court further said that if the state does not feel ashamed of itself, then the Court feels ashamed of being a part of this nasty society. “We cannot do anything for the unfortunate patients of Maharashtra. This is how we are shirking from our responsibilities. You are neglecting and ignoring our patients. We give you a solution, you do not follow it. You do not give us a solution. What absolute nonsense is going on here!” Justice Shukre said.

Bhangde, reading from the Joint Commissioner FDA’s affidavit, said that for private hospitals, the seven companies manufacturing the drug have their depot at Wada, and the companies decide how many vials to send to the state. The state has no role to play in it.

Justice Shukre showed displeasure on the statement and said, “If he (Commissioner) is not the procurement agency for the vaccine, then whose bloody business is it? You are saying that you are not in a position to comply with the order, then what is the solution according to you? You are saying there was stock, but not available for Nagpur. How come Thane gets more and Nagpur gets less is not explained.”

The Court asked to ensure Vidharbha receives 12,404 vials of Remdesivir by night and adjourned the hearing till 8 PM. At 8 PM, the Bench again assembled and took cognizance of the oxygen shortage and Remdesivir availability in the state. The Divisional Commissioner of Nagpur stated that the Remdesivir vials will be equitably distributed. The companies that will be providing the injection to Nagpur are Hetero Labs (3000), Cipla (1500), Sun Pharma (320), Mylan (500), Dr Reddy’s lab (1000) and Zydus (432).

Distribute drugs fairly to the entire nation, said the Court

The Court said, “We direct ASGI to obtain instructions from Ministry of Health regarding steps taken by them under the Drug Control Act and other relevant Acts to ensure fair and equal distribution of this drug not only to Maharashtra or Vidarbha region of Maharashtra but to the entire nation.”