Friday, September 25, 2020
Home Fact-Check Business Standard article on Coal auction revenues 'falling short' is sensationalist and poorly argued

Business Standard article on Coal auction revenues ‘falling short’ is sensationalist and poorly argued

A Business Standard article published earlier today suggested that proceeds from coal block allotments and auctions by the Modi government is woefully short of what the government had estimated.

The article titled “After bold estimates, coal auctions, allotments get Rs 56.84 bn in 3.5 yrs”, pitched an amount of Rs 5,684 crore earned till date against a total of Rs 3,35,000 crore that was estimated to flow to states through coal mines e-auctions and allotments over 30 years.

The Business Standard article, which is behind a paywall, makes the following assumptions and assertions:

  1. The government claimed that the potential revenue claimed by the government was Rs 3.35 lakh crore and when these claims were made, 67 coal mines had already been auctioned or allocated. The article does concede that the press release of the government mentioned that this total revenue was to flow over a 30 year period.
  2. The article arrives at an estimated figure of Rs 22,400 crores that “should have been” earned in two years from 67 operational mines and compares that with Rs 5,684 crore earned till date. Here, the author draws a conclusion that all 67 mines are operational and that the revenue cycle would be uniform throughout the period of estimation i.e. he divides 3.35 lakhs by 30 to arrive at an annual figure.
  3. The article assumes that it is the government’s job to put out the ‘potential revenue’ the 83 mines auctioned and allocated by August 2018 could generate if they were working to meet their approved mine plans. A job that the government hasn’t done.
  4. The article says that the government had also claimed that just the first two rounds of the auction (of 29 coal blocks) would see power rates coming down. These rate cuts would be offered (to consumers) by companies bagging coal blocks reserved for the power sector. But the government or its agencies have not put out an assessment of how the benefits of cheaper coal to the power sector have been passed to the consumers through lower electricity tariffs.

Before looking at the numbers closely, it is pertinent to note that some of the assumptions that the author of the article, Nitin Sethi, makes, are too simplistic and thus faulty when employed to suggest success or failure of any big public sector scheme.

- Advertisement -

The fact that the author assumes that the revenue generation cycle would be uniform and there might not be frontloading or backloading of revenues, is against the common understanding of how any business works. In the case of mines, the revenue generation process is backloaded, as initial phases go into incidents like compliance, capacity building, and making the mines operational.

The same was confirmed by sources in the Ministry of Coal, who further told OpIndia that any delay in operationalisation and non-generation of revenue in the initial year does not represent any loss, but only shifts the incoming revenue from one time period to another.

The data as provided by the ministry officials was not too different when it came to the estimated total revenues over 30 years. The ministry officials put that figure as Rs 3.17 lakh crore as opposed to the Rs 3.35 lakh crore mentioned in the article.

However, they officials pointed out that out of these Rs 3.17 lakh crore, Rs 1.19 lakh crore were towards royalty proceeds i.e. almost 37% of the total proceeds were in form of royalties. The figure of Rs 5,684 crore, which Business Standard tried to pitch against 3.17 lakh crore, however, did NOT include royalties.

The article itself makes mention of that. “These are the proceeds from the auction of 31 and allotment of 58 coal blocks. This revenue is in addition to royalties that the states have always collected from coal mining.” the article says.

Therefore, even if the overly simplistic calculation of the author was employed, the author should have compared the figure of Rs 5,684 crore to an amount that did NOT include the royalties for a fair assessment. Was this an oversight or a deliberate comparison to a much higher number to show ‘failure’, we leave it upon the readers to conclude.

The ministry sources also pointed out that the number of operational mines currently is at 23, which is far below the number of operational mines assumed in the Business Standard article. Since the number of operational mines are less, it is obvious that any comparison with a much higher number would show that the revenues have ‘fallen short’ of the target or original estimates.

If we are to undertake similar simplistic calculations as the author of Business Standard article has undertaken, firstly the figure of Rs 22,400 crore that the article puts as revenue that should have been generated in two years, comes down to Rs 14,112 crore after we remove the royalties part for a fair comparison. And it further comes down to Rs 4,844 cores when adjusted for 23 operational mines as against 67 assumed in the article. So the figure of Rs 5,684 crore, which has actually been accrued, can be argued to be higher than what was originally estimated!

When asked why the number of operational mines were so less, the ministry source explained that after the cancellation of 6 coal blocks, of the remaining 83 coal mines, 33 were Schedule II coal mines i.e. mines which were operational/producing/likely to produce shortly as on date of their cancellation. Remaining 50 coal mines were Schedule I/III coal mines, which are expected to become operational from 2018-19 to 2022-23: 

They clarified that as far as Schedule III coal mines, which are the new mines, the delays have been due to legal and technical issues at the state level. However, for some mines, they are actually ahead of schedule. Thus the article does a very unfair job of assumption about number of mines being operational and revenues being generated in the first couple of years.

Next, when the article assumes that it is the government’s job to put out the ‘potential revenue’ the 83 mines auctioned and allocated by August 2018 could generate if they were working to meet their approved mine plans. It is another fallacious assumption. The estimations are meant to be released by bodies like the CAG or independent research institutions. The government’s job is not to publish presumptive figures on some regular basis.

On the issue of power rates not coming down, the ministry source revealed that these benefits have not been passed on to the consumers yet due to legal troubles.

“Out of the 9 coal mines auctioned for the power sector, 6 coal mines got engaged in litigation as the Successful Bidders of these coal mines have approached the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi challenging the resolution of Ministry of Power for capping the fixed charges of power tariff. Out of the blocks allotted to PSUs (NTPC & State PSUs), 8 are in Court due to dispute with the Mine Developer and Operator. Once these legal hurdles are over the coal supply to the power sector will increase and will have the expected effect on the prices of power,” the ministry source said.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Nupur J Sharma
Editor, OpIndia.com since October 2017

Related Articles

Trending now

Delhi Riots: WhatsApp chats acquired by OpIndia show how some anti-CAA protestors were aware that violence was planned, discussed ‘de-escalation’

The WhatsApp chats accesses by OpIndia show that some individuals were aware that some anti-CAA groups had fanned the violence and they now need to de-escalate.

Illegal Christian Cross and Jesus statue removed from government land following High Court order in Karnataka: Details

District administration removed a Christian Cross and a statue of Jesus Christ, which was illegally put up, on Susai Paliya Hill in Chikkaballapur in Karnataka.

Separated from her family, kidnapped, converted to Islam and sold for an Ox: Story of Daphia who finally found her family in India

An old woman in Pakistan who was separated from her family during the partition, was abducted and converted to Islam, has finally united with her family in India over a phone call.

India Today journalists whine about media coverage on Deepika summons by NCB only to tail her car giving live updates from Goa

The leftists claimed that the summon sent to Deepika Padukone was timed to distract the nation from the farmers protest

Parliament sees its most productive session: Here is a summary of all the 25 Bills passed by the Modi government in Lok Sabha

A total of 25 bills were passed during the just concluded monsoon session of the parliament some of which are very significant bills

Amidst rising coronavirus cases in Maharashtra, doctor alleges Shiv Sena leaders have advised self-medication to suspected COVID patients

An e-poster in the name of Shiv Sena leaders has gone viral on social media platforms, under which they are advising the coronavirus patients to take prescriptions suggested by the Shiv Sena leaders.

Recently Popular

KWAN representative told me that I need to attend Karan Johar Parties to make a comeback to movies: Suchitra Krishnamoorthi

One of the main things is that you need to be seen at Karan Johar's parties, KWAN representative had told Suchitra Krishnamoorthi

Chief of Chief Minister’s Medical Assistance Cell in Maharashtra breaks down while describing the coronavirus situation in the state

In the video, the chief of medical assistant cell in Maharashtra says that he has lost all hopes and that court is the only ray of hope now

Parliament sees its most productive session: Here is a summary of all the 25 Bills passed by the Modi government in Lok Sabha

A total of 25 bills were passed during the just concluded monsoon session of the parliament some of which are very significant bills

ABP journalist manhandles and slaps psephologist Pradeep Bhandari

Pradeep Bhandari was in Mumbai near the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) covering the bollywood drug abuse scandal.

India Today journalists whine about media coverage on Deepika summons by NCB only to tail her car giving live updates from Goa

The leftists claimed that the summon sent to Deepika Padukone was timed to distract the nation from the farmers protest

Properties made available for sale or rent only to Muslims appear on several real estate portals

Even in a cosmopolitan city such as Mumbai, bigoted homeowners actively discriminate between tenants.

Uttar Pradesh: Hindu girl beheaded after she refused to convert to Islam, husband Ejaz and friend Shoaib Akhtar nabbed

23-year-old Hindu woman has been brutally murdered by two Muslim youth after she refused to convert to Islam after marriage.

Delhi Riots: WhatsApp chats acquired by OpIndia show how some anti-CAA protestors were aware that violence was planned, discussed ‘de-escalation’

The WhatsApp chats accesses by OpIndia show that some individuals were aware that some anti-CAA groups had fanned the violence and they now need to de-escalate.

Ranveer Singh asks Narcotics Bureau to allow him to accompany Deepika Padukone during interrogation due to her ‘anxiety issues’

Bollywood actor Ranveer Singh, the husband of Deepika Padukone, has asked NCB whether he can be present during his wife’s interrogation

Illegal Christian Cross and Jesus statue removed from government land following High Court order in Karnataka: Details

District administration removed a Christian Cross and a statue of Jesus Christ, which was illegally put up, on Susai Paliya Hill in Chikkaballapur in Karnataka.

Cannot withdraw prosecution based on religion, says Andhra Pradesh HC in case where Muslim mob laid siege on Guntur police station: Details

Petition was filed by Legal Rights Protection Forum against the decision of the Andhra Pradesh govt to withdraw prosecution of Muslim youth, who had attacked a police station in Guntur

Radicalises Muslim youth, spreads hate: Govt plans to ban Islamist Zakir Naik’s Mobile App through which, banned Peace TV is being broadcast

Central govt is planning to ban radical Islamist preacher Zakir Naik channel Peace TV, his mobile app and YouTube channel for inciting religious hatred.

Separated from her family, kidnapped, converted to Islam and sold for an Ox: Story of Daphia who finally found her family in India

An old woman in Pakistan who was separated from her family during the partition, was abducted and converted to Islam, has finally united with her family in India over a phone call.

India Today reporters chase a car in Goa saying Deepika Padukone is inside it, hours later says the actress is still in hotel

India Today reporters were chasing a wrong car in Goa, believing that Deepika Padukone was travelling in it on the way to the airport.

Delhi Police rebuts fake news by NDTV that Kapil Mishra named as a whistle-blower in Delhi riots case

Delhi police have said that NDTV is trying to peddle its narrative in Delhi riots by airing fake news, saying the channel is creating fiction

‘The situation in electronic media is like Nazi Germany’: Families of Congress leaders file intervention petition in Sudarshan News case

Wives of Congress leaders Rajiv Tyagi and Pawan Khera seeks to 'assist' the Supreme Court in the Sudarshan News case

Connect with us

244,181FansLike
455,329FollowersFollow
16,900SubscribersSubscribe