Monday, August 3, 2020
Home Editor's picks After Twitter's 'caste' row, Manish Tewari says Brahmins should accept their fate as Jews...

After Twitter’s ‘caste’ row, Manish Tewari says Brahmins should accept their fate as Jews did

It would be interesting to see reactions of the 'intellectual' friends of Congress on Manish Tewari's tweet where he takes a sympathetic view on the Brahmin community.

Also Read

Nirwa Mehtahttps://medium.com/@nirwamehta
Politically incorrect. Author, Flawed But Fabulous.

Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey’s maiden trip to India had its fair share of controversies. Netizens got quite furious when he posed with a far-left Hinduphobic slogan on a placard that read ‘Smash Brahminical Patriarchy’. ‘Brahminical’ is often used as a code-word to attack Hinduism just as anti-Semites use ‘Zionists’ to spread hatred against Jews.

Congress leader Manish Tewari is the latest to join the debate.

Manish Tewari tweeted that ‘Anti-Brahminism’ is the reality of Indian politics. In the post-Mandal era, the same got accentuated in North-Indian politics. He added that we (as in Brahmins) are the ‘new Jews’ and we must just learn to live with it.

Mandal Commission was set up in 1979 by Prime Minister Morarji Desai to identify socially or educationally backward classes of India. The report recommended reservations to the scheduled caste, scheduled tribes and other backward classes to 49%. While the report was submitted in 1983, it was implemented only in 1992 amidst widespread protests. Criticising the reservation system, which focuses on caste over economic status, is often dubbed as ‘Brahminical privilege’. Hence, it is politically incorrect to be critical of the reservation system.

Although there were mixed reactions to Tewari’s tweet, with some looking it as support for Jack, Tewari’s sentiments are not unique or new. A 2008 Outlook article talks about how being against “Brahminism” is a part and parcel of Indian politics. In the article, researcher Jakob De Roover draws parallels between the Jews in Europe and Brahmins in India.

To be against “Brahminism” is part and parcel of the political correctness of progressive scholars in twenty-first-century India, much like being against Muslims is part of the message of their Hindutva colleagues. This indicates that something is very wrong with the Indian academic debate. Promotion of animosity towards a religious tradition or its followers is not acceptable today, but it becomes truly perverse when the intelligentsia endorses it.

Jakob mentions the striking similarities between the Jews in Europe and Brahmins in India like the stereotypes about them. While Jews are described as conniving people who could go to any lengths to personal gains, Brahmins are often described as oppressors. He explains that in both cases, the historians have claimed to have produced ‘evidence’ which cannot really be considered as one.

He points out that when anti-Brahminical people are countered with facts that Brahmins in a major part of the country are not as powerful, and are in fact, poor, they resort to ad hominem by claiming that Brahmins were the ones who manipulated kings and politicians behind the scene.

If you observe the Twitter discourse, self-proclaimed Dalit rights activists are out to set right the historical wrong done to them. As a sample, you could perhaps read the comments that would be targeted at me on the basis of my surname, Sharma (post-marriage) and Mehta (maiden), attacked for being a Brahmin, a ‘place of privilege’, speaking on the caste system.

Targeting of Brahmins, which is politically safe in India, with the ulterior motive of fueling divide in the country is not unheard of. We had earlier seen how Pakistan based propaganda websites indulged in such deeds. Thus, some people seeing red flag over an ‘outsider’ Jack holding this poster is bound to raise a few eyebrows

Hence, it would be interesting to see reactions of the ‘intellectual’ friends of Congress on Manish Tewari’s tweet where he takes a sympathetic view on the Brahmin community. Especially since now Rahul Gandhi now identifies himself as a ‘Janeu-dhaari Brahmin‘, the avatar of Congress President that was discovered during the run-up to Gujarat elections last year.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Nirwa Mehtahttps://medium.com/@nirwamehta
Politically incorrect. Author, Flawed But Fabulous.

Trending now

Digvijaya Singh claims 5th August is inauspicious, Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan should be postponed, BJP leader Narottam Mishra calls him an ‘Asur’

At a time as historic as this one, Congress leader Digvijaya Singh goes on to spread fear and suspicion about the auspiciousness of the date on Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan

There was never any doubt that ‘seculars’ were behind the Delhi riots

From Day 1, the Delhi riots was an open and shut case. It was obvious who had the motive.

‘Aaj Dekh Lenge Hinduon ko’: The tale of Faizal Farooqui, Rajdhani and DRP school and what Chargesheet number 1 says

The Delhi Police and the Special Cell have filed numerous chargesheets in the Delhi riots that pertain to several different incidents of violence that led to carnage and destruction over a period of the two days.

Mata Amritanandamayi sends special Raksha Bandhan greetings to the Prime Minister, PM Modi thanks the Nari Shakti of India

Spiritual leader Mata Amritanandamayi, popularly known as 'Amma', greeted Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Raksha Bandhan today.

Karti Chidambaram tests positive for Chinese coronavirus

Congress MP and son of former Union Minister P Chidambaram, Karti Chidambaram, has tested positive for coronavirus.

Sushant Singh Rajput case: BMC forcefully ‘quarantines’ Bihar Police officer, DGP Bihar says he was not even provided accommodation

Mumbai police's behaviour in the case has been criticised by many. Earlier there were reports that the many aspects of the case are being covered up due to involvement of some high profile persons.

Recently Popular

Delhi Police confirm OpIndia report, say that Tahir Hussain has confessed he had planned the Delhi riots to teach Hindus a lesson

Tahir Hussain confesses before Delhi police that he had planned the Delhi Riots, collected materials in advance for the same

Barkha Dutt interviews Sushant Singh Rajput’s therapist, who breaks client confidentiality to give a clean chit to Rhea in middle of investigation

Barkha Dutt and Susan Walker Moffat breaks patient confidentiality by releasing mental illness history of Sushant Singh Rakput

Aaditya Thackeray meets Mumbai Police Commissioner, reports say Sushant Singh Rajput’s death was discussed

According to reports, a politician's son had attended a party at Sushant Singh Rajput's residence, a night before his alleged suicide

After Kangana Ranaut hits out at the son of a Chief Minister, gunshots heard outside her house in Himachal Pradesh

Kullu district police rushed to the house of Kangana Ranaut after gunshot sounds were heard near her house in Himachal Pradesh.

The curious case of Dr Aisha: How the quest to find the perfect ‘Muslim’ victim of the Wuhan Coronavirus fell flat on its face

Dr Aisha supposedly lost her life to the Wuhan Coronavirus after being put on ventilator on the occasion of Eid-al-Adha.

If Bakra Eid was a Hindu festival: 10 images that tell the tale of how ‘liberal’ media and celebs would have reacted

Today is the Islamic festival of Bakra Eid where thousands of cattle, goats and buffaloes specifically are slaughtered by pious Muslims as an offering to Allah

Digvijaya Singh claims 5th August is inauspicious, Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan should be postponed, BJP leader Narottam Mishra calls him an ‘Asur’

At a time as historic as this one, Congress leader Digvijaya Singh goes on to spread fear and suspicion about the auspiciousness of the date on Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan

BJP slams Times Now for claiming 21 BJP leaders, including 4 MPs and 1 MLA, ‘likely to join TMC’, calls it fake news

West Bengal unit of the BJP slammed Times Now for claiming in a report that 21 of its leaders were 'likely to join' Trinamool Congress

There was never any doubt that ‘seculars’ were behind the Delhi riots

From Day 1, the Delhi riots was an open and shut case. It was obvious who had the motive.

‘Aaj Dekh Lenge Hinduon ko’: The tale of Faizal Farooqui, Rajdhani and DRP school and what Chargesheet number 1 says

The Delhi Police and the Special Cell have filed numerous chargesheets in the Delhi riots that pertain to several different incidents of violence that led to carnage and destruction over a period of the two days.

Tavleen Singh comes out to defend her son Aatish Taseer for spewing venom on Amit Shah, lies through her teeth

Aatish Taseer still outraged about his OCI status revocation, uses vile, abusive words for India's Home Minister.

Mata Amritanandamayi sends special Raksha Bandhan greetings to the Prime Minister, PM Modi thanks the Nari Shakti of India

Spiritual leader Mata Amritanandamayi, popularly known as 'Amma', greeted Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Raksha Bandhan today.

Anti-China protests take place in Canada: ‘Covid-19 Made-in-China’ slogans raised

"China lied, people died" slogan were raised in Canada during the protest.

Sushant Singh Rajput case: BMC forcefully ‘quarantines’ Bihar Police officer, DGP Bihar says he was not even provided accommodation

Mumbai police's behaviour in the case has been criticised by many. Earlier there were reports that the many aspects of the case are being covered up due to involvement of some high profile persons.

‘Mind your own business’: Capt Amarinder Singh accuses Arvind Kejriwal of playing politics over Punjab hooch tragedy

Hitting out on his Delhi counterpart, Punjab Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh on Sunday asked Kejriwal to 'mind his own business' for demanding CBI probe in the Punjab hooch tragedy which has claimed lives of over 100 people.

Tripura: FIR registered against CPIM leader and social media accounts of the party for spreading fake news on social media: Read details

CPIM blames BJP and RSS for a statue fallen due to heavy rain in Tripura, FIR registered for spreading fake news

Connect with us

238,628FansLike
420,468FollowersFollow
288,000SubscribersSubscribe