Home Economy and Finance The Wire comes up with flawed logic to rubbish new methodology which slashed growth rates of Congress regime

The Wire comes up with flawed logic to rubbish new methodology which slashed growth rates of Congress regime

MK Venu's argument of sluggish bank credit due to rise in NPAs further validates how excessive credit under the UPA era led to a boost in the investment figures which did not reflect the economic realities of that period.

There’s a lot of talk around the recently released back calculations as it puts into perspective the growth that India experienced from 2005 onwards. It is interesting to note that the new methodology was appreciated by the Former Finance Minister P. Chidambaram when the 2013-14 estimates were revised from 4.7% to 6.9% according to this methodology.

Thus, when the methodology revised estimates of GDP, the Opposition along with the likes of eminent commentators decided to use this revision as a manifestation of the “strong growth” that India experienced under the UPA-II era. However, when the same methodology was extended to the data from 2005 onwards, all those who hailed the “strong growth” have started to question the same methodology. As hilarious or hypocritical as it may appear, I found the reasons given by the article by the leftist propaganda website, The Wire more amusing as it clearly showed their lack of understanding of data, statistic and above all, of economics.

- Ad - - article resumes -

There is no doubt that the new methodology is a significantly better one as it takes into account the global best practices. Despite that, the article by The Wire talking about the credibility of the numbers tries to unfairly politicize what is a routine exercise by the government.

MK Venu’s argument is that investment as a percentage of GDP was higher under UPA than under NDA so how can growth be greater under NDA than UPA. The article gets the rationale behind the investment to GDP ratio wrong as it assumes that investments today have a direct impact on growth in the same period. Investments have a lagged effect on growth. Money invested today in a plant would take a couple of years to yield dividends for further growth in future.

Another issue is that a firm would invest only when it needs to add more production capacity to meet further demand in the economy. As a result, investments would be realized once there’s an increase in Capacity Utilization.

Most economists agree that the Indian Economy has had spare capacity since 2011 onwards due to the economic slowdown and this spare capacity came due to “over-investment” from 2007 onwards till 2011 which was fuelled by availability of excess liquidity due to the aggressive lending policy followed by banks: and this is what has led to the rise in NPAs and the current “twin-balance sheet” problem that our banks face.

It is amusing to see basic economic logic being completely disregarded by M K Venu in his article for The Wire as he focuses on a flawed logic to suit a convenient narrative, a narrative that stems more from political considerations rather than economic rationale.

The investment as a percentage of GDP graph shows the same story which explains why there was a build-up of excess capacity in the economy which further led to a collapse of the investment cycle post-2011. It is only in 2014 that the capacity started to pick up and once capacity utilization improved, we can witness investments to increase from 2016 onwards.

Thus, the explanation of a high ratio of investment during 2007-11 compared to 2014-18 is not a legitimate explanation for two reasons: investments have a lagged impact on growth and that investment under the UPA was fuelled by excessive credit rather than strong economic fundamentals. This is validated when one looks at the excess capacity build-up that occurred in the economy during the UPA era.

Further, his argument in The Wire of sluggish bank credit due to rise in NPAs further validates how excessive credit under the UPA era led to a boost in the investment figures which did not reflect the economic realities of that period. As a result, the investment far exceeded the growth in demand and this led to unutilized capacities which further led to a reduction in subsequent investments. The problem got amplified when economic growth collapsed post-2011 and the twin balance sheet problem started to originate.

Thus, what this new data tells us has been only strengthened by M K Venu’s article; excessive credit-fuelled investments led to overheating of the economy and this was not sustainable. There is no redemption from the gross mismanagement of the economy by the UPA and no matter how many op-eds TheWire publishes, it is well established that the growth under UPA was volatile, did not create ample jobs, it came with a very high inflation and it collapsed significantly post 2011. All of these facts have been further established by the latest release of the data so it is about time that we end the politicization of this data and find solutions to enter into the “high-growth” path.

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Big Story

A viral video has been shared several times on Social Media where a railway official can be seen taking money from a poor man travelling on the train.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

Proud to be a brand - Made in India?
Now, Advertise on Opindia

Who is Prime Minister Modi’s ‘very special friend’ who came to meet him in the Parliament today?

Prime Minister Modi today shared images with a 'very special friend' who had come to meet him at the Parliament.
Exclusive interview with BLF chief Dr Allah Nazar Baloch with OpIndia

Pakistan plundering Balochistan, we appeal PM Modi to support freedom struggle: Dr Allah Nazar Baloch of BLF speaks exclusively to OpIndia

Away from the glare of the world that often talks tall on Human Rights and the rights of the indigenous people, Balochistan bleeds at the hands of Pakistan. OpIndia interviews founder and chief of Balochistan Liberation Front, Dr Allah Nazar Baloch

Uttar Pradesh: After Triple Talaq, Man pressurizes wife to undergo nikah halala with his brother and uncle

Rabiya further stated that when she refused to give in to her husband's demands, she was thrashed and thrown out of the house.

Hey, New York Times, F**k you, again

India successfully tested anti-satellite missile today, springing it into the elite space club.

Senior citizen who used to put lizards in his own food on trains to get free meal caught by railway officials

A senior citizen named Surender Pal, in his 70s was found guilty of contaminating his own meal to get free ones from the national transporter
Donald Trump lies in the most foolish manner about PM Modi and the Kashmir issue

Had Donald Trump taken time to educate himself about world affairs before becoming President, he would not look foolish

For Donald Trump to lie about something so elementary as India's stand on Kashmir, only goes to show how terribly ignorant the President truly is.

Is there a concerted attempt to sow doubts against PM Modi among his most loyal base?

By now, everyone of us who is out there on social media is aware of this strange new phenomenon.

Live updates Karnataka Trust Vote: Karnataka Government has fallen

JDS-Congress government of Karnataka is facing their second floor test after assembly elections were held in May last year.

Himalayan Blunder : When India gave up on Tibet and what it needs to do now

During Rajiv Gandhi's 1989 visit to China, Deng Xiaoping had suggested: "Let both sides forget the unpleasant period in our past relations and let us treat everything with an eye on the future."30 years have since passed, however, the future is yet to arrive in India, Tibet and China relations.
Image Source: Moneycontrol

Karnataka Congress-JDS coalition government collapses after it fails to get trust vote passed in Assembly

After days of drama, CM Kumaraswamy finally moved the trust vote today that failed to pass in the Assembly. As a result, the Karnataka government has officially collapsed
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

173,806FansLike
160,686FollowersFollow
74,950SubscribersSubscribe
Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post