Home Opinions The absurdity of the 'solution' to build a Hospital at Ram Janmabhoomi

The absurdity of the ‘solution’ to build a Hospital at Ram Janmabhoomi

When I was younger, on the question of Ayodhya, I would have told you, ‘Why bother for a Mandir? Why not build a Hospital or a School and do something good for the society? That would be more godly.’

It was a genuine feeling – so I would like to think, and there would perhaps not be a tinge of guilt in making the suggestion. Today, however, I do see through the convenient hypocrisy of this suggestion.

There are several reasons for saying so – but, they perhaps need to be articulated systematically. It is therefore, important to first dissect the suggestion to understand its fundamental rationale.

- Ad - - article resumes -

The suggestion ostentatiously rests on the premise of the superiority of the services provided by Hospitals and Schools as against those provided by Temples. It would not be presumptuous to extrapolate the argument on behalf of its proponents to include that Temples are a drain of resources and wealth of the nation.

Here is why the argument is hypocritical. Despite the fact that an ‘urbanised’ section of the Indian populace may believe in the futility of temples, it remains a fact that temples do provide an immense amount of support to the large practicing Hindu population of India. Unfortunately, this same population is too subdued and knows no means of making its voice heard. So, neglecting the value temples hold to hundreds of millions of voiceless Hindus is essentially a coup of national priorities by the Urbanised Indians who make their case based on inherited Hindu names that they place no value on.

Moreover, it is also well known that as with any other institution – religious or otherwise, hospitals and schools are breeding grounds of corruption and exploitation of the society as well, if such a case is to be made against temples.

The second argument in favour of building a hospital is the hope that it will bypass communal ill will. However, in reality this is a dangerous appeasement tactic, which has been consistently proven to not work over the history of mankind. It only brushes conflicts under the rug until they resurrect with greater ferocity. This in fact is an escapist and cowardly approach, that runs away from the very fundamental question that India has been facing since independence. The question being – does India (irrespective of religious communities) have the honesty and courage to admit and correct wrongs done by restoring the sites of Indian civilisations to their deserved respect? To suggest there is an iota of communalism in this ask is disingenuous.

Thirdly, there is an inherent insincerity in asking for a hospital at Ayodhya in that it does not rest on a sound, repeatable principle. If the overarching principle substantiating the demand is the superiority of hospitals and similar services over benefits of a religious institution, then it must be universally sought, including as much on Jama Masjid, Golden Temple, St Pauls Cathedral and as on every place of worship. If one were to ask such, it might still be appreciated as a principled approach. But, unfortunately Ayodhya has been made a special case for hospital. A special casing that is sought on account of the first two reasons, and so, is entirely hypocritical.

Also, as someone on social media had asked, will these people be happy if a Ram Mandir is build at Ayodhya with the promise that bulk of the chadhava (donations and offerings by the faithfuls) will be used to fund a hospital and a school? Clearly this solution is not amendable to them, as their motive is not to build a hospital or a school, but to stop building a temple.

Those seeking the building of a temple at Ayodhya do not debate the merits of a Hospital or a School at all. But they do question the wretchedness and lack of courage to admit the ugly pieces of our history and take corrective actions in the restoration of our civilisation. It is too easy to see through the deception inherent in the suggestion. It tries to emotionally distort the question at a very superficial level and obscure the underlying troubling issues for which there aren’t easy answers.

It is absurd to suggest that Indian civilisation stands apart from Ramayan and Mahabharat. The life of Lord Ram is the very essence of the five millenia old civilisation that in the modern day manifests as India. Whether scientific rationality allows one to believe in the historicity of Ramayan is another matter. Irrespective, it is a plain truth that the conception of Lord Ram is a pillar of the Indian civilisation in terms of culture, value systems, as also Indic religions. In the multi dimensional diversity of a country like India that includes differences in languages, dressing, food, music and so many other aspects, the value systems derived from our epics are the singular unifying spirit of the country.

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Big Story

After abrogation of Article 370 by the Modi government, Congress and Pakistan seem to have found an ideological soulmate in each other

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

Barkha Dutt’s strange coincidences with a Kashmiri who wished death upon PM Modi and Amit Shah

Idrees ul Haq, with whom Barkha Dutt had a series of ‘coincidences’ is a known separatist sympathiser
Actor R Madhavan was trolled on social media by many 'liberals' as he had posted the pictures of himself and his son wearing the Yajnopaveetham

Actor R Madhavan hounded on social media for sharing pictures of himself wearing the Poonal or Yajnopaveetham

Madhavan posted pictures of himself with his son wearing the Poonal or Yajnopaveetham, the sacred thread of Brahmins.

Imran Khan’s Twitter meltdown continues as international community ignores his rants

For all his theatrics, Imran Khan appears to be screaming into the void.

Here is why Shobhaa De could be first in a long list to be exposed by Pakistan

India’s stand on abrogation of Article 370 and 35A and dilution of Jammu and Kashmir from a state to a Union Territory has dropped the baby of pretence.
Pakistan finance minister Assad Umar writes to FATF to remove India from its co-chair

I am an Indian, a Christian, and I live in India without fear: An open letter to Pakistan PM Imran Khan

"Don’t ever drag an Indian-Christian into your false propaganda. You don’t know our love for #BharatMata", says Savio Rodrigues, Editor-in-chief, Goa Chronicle

After the abrogation of Article 370, Pakistan Minister expresses angst over Rahul Gandhi not winning 2019 elections

After abrogation of Article 370 by the Modi government, Congress and Pakistan seem to have found an ideological soulmate in each other
Image Source: Hindustan Times

Ram Guha, you cannot peddle the Pakistani narrative at the international level without people questioning your patriotism

Ramchandra Guha claimed that India had dealt with Kashmir 'harshly' because the majority of Kashmiris are Muslims.

Are people like Ramachandra Guha trolls?

The verdict is clear: The world will not mess with India easily. Least of all to make Pakistan happy. Then, what does it accomplish when some article in some newspaper “downgrades” India?

Purported email screenshots of Kavita Krishnan’s team show them discussing use of retired judges and ex-military officers for Kashmir propaganda

Purported screenshots of internal emails of urban naxals are being circulated on social media

Assam: Girl drugged and raped inside ruins of ancient temple premises, accused Kutubuddin Ahmed arrested

Kutubuddin Ahmed drugged and raped a girl in the ruins of an ancient temple in Assam
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

180,471FansLike
169,731FollowersFollow
88,752SubscribersSubscribe
Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post