Wednesday, January 27, 2021
Home Opinions The absurdity of the 'solution' to build a Hospital at Ram Janmabhoomi

The absurdity of the ‘solution’ to build a Hospital at Ram Janmabhoomi

When I was younger, on the question of Ayodhya, I would have told you, ‘Why bother for a Mandir? Why not build a Hospital or a School and do something good for the society? That would be more godly.’

It was a genuine feeling – so I would like to think, and there would perhaps not be a tinge of guilt in making the suggestion. Today, however, I do see through the convenient hypocrisy of this suggestion.

There are several reasons for saying so – but, they perhaps need to be articulated systematically. It is therefore, important to first dissect the suggestion to understand its fundamental rationale.

The suggestion ostentatiously rests on the premise of the superiority of the services provided by Hospitals and Schools as against those provided by Temples. It would not be presumptuous to extrapolate the argument on behalf of its proponents to include that Temples are a drain of resources and wealth of the nation.

Here is why the argument is hypocritical. Despite the fact that an ‘urbanised’ section of the Indian populace may believe in the futility of temples, it remains a fact that temples do provide an immense amount of support to the large practicing Hindu population of India. Unfortunately, this same population is too subdued and knows no means of making its voice heard. So, neglecting the value temples hold to hundreds of millions of voiceless Hindus is essentially a coup of national priorities by the Urbanised Indians who make their case based on inherited Hindu names that they place no value on.

Moreover, it is also well known that as with any other institution – religious or otherwise, hospitals and schools are breeding grounds of corruption and exploitation of the society as well, if such a case is to be made against temples.

The second argument in favour of building a hospital is the hope that it will bypass communal ill will. However, in reality this is a dangerous appeasement tactic, which has been consistently proven to not work over the history of mankind. It only brushes conflicts under the rug until they resurrect with greater ferocity. This in fact is an escapist and cowardly approach, that runs away from the very fundamental question that India has been facing since independence. The question being – does India (irrespective of religious communities) have the honesty and courage to admit and correct wrongs done by restoring the sites of Indian civilisations to their deserved respect? To suggest there is an iota of communalism in this ask is disingenuous.

Thirdly, there is an inherent insincerity in asking for a hospital at Ayodhya in that it does not rest on a sound, repeatable principle. If the overarching principle substantiating the demand is the superiority of hospitals and similar services over benefits of a religious institution, then it must be universally sought, including as much on Jama Masjid, Golden Temple, St Pauls Cathedral and as on every place of worship. If one were to ask such, it might still be appreciated as a principled approach. But, unfortunately Ayodhya has been made a special case for hospital. A special casing that is sought on account of the first two reasons, and so, is entirely hypocritical.

Also, as someone on social media had asked, will these people be happy if a Ram Mandir is build at Ayodhya with the promise that bulk of the chadhava (donations and offerings by the faithfuls) will be used to fund a hospital and a school? Clearly this solution is not amendable to them, as their motive is not to build a hospital or a school, but to stop building a temple.

Those seeking the building of a temple at Ayodhya do not debate the merits of a Hospital or a School at all. But they do question the wretchedness and lack of courage to admit the ugly pieces of our history and take corrective actions in the restoration of our civilisation. It is too easy to see through the deception inherent in the suggestion. It tries to emotionally distort the question at a very superficial level and obscure the underlying troubling issues for which there aren’t easy answers.

It is absurd to suggest that Indian civilisation stands apart from Ramayan and Mahabharat. The life of Lord Ram is the very essence of the five millenia old civilisation that in the modern day manifests as India. Whether scientific rationality allows one to believe in the historicity of Ramayan is another matter. Irrespective, it is a plain truth that the conception of Lord Ram is a pillar of the Indian civilisation in terms of culture, value systems, as also Indic religions. In the multi dimensional diversity of a country like India that includes differences in languages, dressing, food, music and so many other aspects, the value systems derived from our epics are the singular unifying spirit of the country.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Siddhartha Kar
Technologist and Entrepreneur. Keenly interested in India, World History and Current Affairs.

 

Related Articles

Trending now

‘Tiranga ka apman, nehi sahega Hindustan’: Angry villages in Rewari issue ultimatum to ‘farmer’ protestors to vacate Highway blockade in 24 hours

The villagers said that due to blockade on the highway, the region remains jammed with vehicles, which have created difficulties for them

Farmer bodies withdraw their support from ‘farmer’ protest, blame Rakesh Tikait for violence on Republic Day

AIKSCC's VM Singh said he does not want to be part of protests led by Rakesh Tikait.

Red Fort attack: Dear ‘liberals’, here is how a little understanding of physics can help you

The underlying message of holding a parallel parade on Republic Day was always clear. They wanted to showcase a parallel power center on the streets, a republic of mob rule.

The mayhem on Republic Day was planned by these ‘farmer leaders’. Here is how they are lying

From Yogendra Yadav to Rakesh Tikait to Darshan Pal: How the 'farmer leaders' egged the 'farmers' to run a riot on Republic Day

Red Fort Insurrection: Deep Sidhu, his Khalistani links, role in violence and how ‘liberals’, who made him a hero, are now using him to...

Opposition leaders who had supported Deep Sidhu saying it is a farmer are now alleging he is linked to BJP

Recently Popular

Protesting mob enters Red Fort, unfurl the Sikh flag, Terrorist outfit SFJ had demanded Khalistani flag to be hoisted: Details

The protestors have hoisted the flag on Red Fort that appears to be the Sikh Flag. Some believe it is the Khalistan Flag.

‘Flag of Khalistan is waving on Red Fort,’ ‘Historic Moment’: All Pakistan Muslim League celebrates “Black Day” for India

The All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) is celebrating the hoisting of the 'Khalistan Flag' at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Here is how Congress and trolls tried to paint a Khalistani accused of spearheading the Red Fort siege as a ‘sanghi’

Deep Sidhu is accused of being responsible for the hoisting of the Sikh flag at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Rajdeep Sardesai lies twice, says ‘farmer’ was killed because the police shot him in the head: Here is the truth

In this way, those who had shared the fake news once would live under the false impression that it was indeed a case of police firing.

Watch: Protestors throw away Tricolour, place Sikh flag on top of flag pole at Red Fort

Disturbing visuals emerge from the tractor rally on Republic Day.

Protesting ‘farmer’ spends Rs 35 lakh to modify his tractor for Republic Day rally

The modified tractor is fitted with huge wheels. It is said to withstand heavy rain and water cannon charge.
- Advertisement -

 

Farmer protests: Twitter suspends 550 accounts for inciting violence, abuse, and threats

Delhi Police had claimed that hundreds of Twitter accounts were created to sow confusion about the tractor rally proposed by the 'farmers'.

Congress leader Digvijaya Singh blames Delhi Police for Republic Day violence by ‘farmer’ protestors

While it was already known that barricades will be removed after Republic Day parade is over, Digvijay Singh blamed police barricades for riots

‘You cannot hurt religious sentiments’: SC rejects anticipatory bail pleas of ‘Tandav’ makers

"Freedom of speech was not absolute. You cannot hurt anyone's religious sentiments", Supreme Court of India said to makers of 'Tandav'.

Banned Khalistani outfit SFJ confesses to their hand in Red Fort attack, announces reward for laying siege on Indian Parliament on February 1

Khalistani terror organisation SFJ has announced a reward of $350,000 for those who wave Khalistani flags at the Parliament

‘Tiranga ka apman, nehi sahega Hindustan’: Angry villages in Rewari issue ultimatum to ‘farmer’ protestors to vacate Highway blockade in 24 hours

The villagers said that due to blockade on the highway, the region remains jammed with vehicles, which have created difficulties for them

Farmer bodies withdraw their support from ‘farmer’ protest, blame Rakesh Tikait for violence on Republic Day

AIKSCC's VM Singh said he does not want to be part of protests led by Rakesh Tikait.

Red Fort attack: Dear ‘liberals’, here is how a little understanding of physics can help you

The underlying message of holding a parallel parade on Republic Day was always clear. They wanted to showcase a parallel power center on the streets, a republic of mob rule.

The mayhem on Republic Day was planned by these ‘farmer leaders’. Here is how they are lying

From Yogendra Yadav to Rakesh Tikait to Darshan Pal: How the 'farmer leaders' egged the 'farmers' to run a riot on Republic Day

Red Fort Insurrection: Deep Sidhu, his Khalistani links, role in violence and how ‘liberals’, who made him a hero, are now using him to...

Opposition leaders who had supported Deep Sidhu saying it is a farmer are now alleging he is linked to BJP

‘Farmer leaders’ start blame game after running riots in Delhi, claim some groups conspired with govt to create violence

The Samyukt Kisan Morcha has played blame game. It has stated that they have nothing to do with violent elements that ran riots at Red Fort.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
23,000SubscribersSubscribe