Monday, November 30, 2020
Home News Reports Hadiya and 'Love Jihad' : It is not a simple case of 'free will'

Hadiya and ‘Love Jihad’ : It is not a simple case of ‘free will’

The “Hadiya Love Jihad” case has raised many questions among the Indian intelligentsia. Can court govern our free will on whom to marry? Can court rule on which religion we chose to profess? Should the court tell us who we should live with? How is it that the court can decide who we can meet and who we can not?

It is being seen by many as judicial overreach into citizen’s free will on marriage and religion, guaranteed by article 15 and 25 of the Indian Constitution, which are fundamental rights of every citizen.

Can courts really go so wrong in interpreting and following the constitution? Do our Twitter activists know about the case better than the judges?

It is understandable that one rushes to make right noises over free will and freedom of religion over the issue, but it is important to look at the case with its context and background, not as an isolated case of court annulling an inter-faith marriage, to make an informed decision.

A brief history of the case tells us that Akhila, the only daughter of ex-serviceman Akhil Asokan, a resident of Kottayam, Kerala, went to Salem, Tamil Nadu to pursue Bachelor of Homeopathic Medicine and Surgery (BHMS) in 2015. On 6th January, 2016, Akhila went missing from a house in Salem, where she was staying with her friends Faseena and Jaseena. Her father filed a missing complaint with police where he accused her room-mates and their father Aboobacker. Thereafter, when Akhila could not be traced, Asokan filed a Habeas Corpus in Kerala High Court, following which Akhila appeared in the court on 19th January, 2016.

There Akhila, now Hadiya, confessed to have converted to Islam out of her own free will, “impressed” by her room-mates’ way of living, prayers and “good character”. She even produced an affidavit where she said she was accepting Islam out of her free will with no coercion. Thereafter, she stayed in an Islamic study centre named “Sathya Sarani” and got enrolled as a student. She stayed with a PFI (Popular Front of India) member Sainaba.

After her affidavit, Ashokan’s petition was dismissed. However, Ashokan filed another petition after 6 months, where he alleged that efforts were being made to transport his daughter out of the country. The court passed an interim order, asking police to ensure that Akhila/Hadiya is not taken to a foreign land. Meanwhile, Akhila had been moved from Sainaba’s residence to an undisclosed location.

Now, while the case was going on, court directed the police to look at the role of Sainaba and Sathya Sarani in illegal conversions while ascertaining how Akhila is maintaining her and her source of income. In the meantime, on 21st December 2016, she appeared with someone called Shafin Jehan, whom she claimed to be her husband.

Among the 6 respondents in the case, Shafin Jehan was nowhere in the picture. They also produced a questionable marriage certificate, and claimed that they have got married which was attended by close relatives from both sides. However, nobody from Akhila’s side, not even her parents, were aware of the marriage. Moreover, “Thanveerul Islam Sangham”, which issued the marriage certificate has no authority to issue any such certificates. The court observed:

The certificate is seen to have been issued by the Secretary of an organization by name Thanveerul Islam Sangham, Kottakkal, Malappuram District. We do not know what is the organization that has issued the certificate. It is not clear whether it is even registered.Whether it is only a paper organization alone, also requires to be ascertained.

The court was not even sure of the identity of the names that appeared on that certificate. When Akhila converted to Islam, which doesn’t have any documentary proof, she assumed the name “Aasiya” through an affidavit. Later on her writ petitions, she called herself “Akhila Ashokan @ Adhiya.”

Though it is repeatedly stated that Ms. Akhila has got converted to the Islam religion, there is no document evidencing such conversion on record. The name which she is alleged to have chosen, according to an affidavit executed by her before Adv.Devy A.C., Advocate and Notary on 10.9.2015 is ‘Aasiya’.

In W.P.(Crl.) No. 25 of 2016 she has sworn to affidavits describing herself as Akhila Ashokan@ Adhiya. In this writ petition, in her affidavits, she describes herself as ‘Akhila Ashokan @ Adhiya’.”

However, she comes across as Hadiya in the questionable marriage certificate that she produced.

“In the alleged marriage certificate issued by Thanveerul Islam Sangham dated 20.12.2016 produced by the Senior Government Pleader along with a memo dated 19.12.2016, her name is shown as Hadiya, D/o. Akhil Asokan. It is clear from the above that, even regarding the identity of Ms. Akhila, there is no certainty.”

Hadiya’s husband Shafin Jehan’s radical inclination is evident from his Facebook postings as noted by the court. He has criminal background and had cases registered under IPC section 143, 147, 341, 323, 294(b).

The questionable marriage certificate, the issuing authority being a non-authoritative institute to issue such certificate, court being kept in dark about the marriage, the criminal antecedent of Shafin Jehan and clear intention of taking Akhila to Gulf after marriage are the factors the court considered in its wisdom before it annulled the marriage. Here is the full judgement of the case [pdf], which observes:

The marriage was conducted in a hasty manner with the object of overreaching the jurisdiction of this Court with the object of transporting her out of India. Shafin was only a stooge who has been assigned to play the role of going through a marriage ceremony.

So before outraging on how courts can ‘undo’ a marriage, do consider that it’s a court of law, where material evidences are admitted, not a news studio where passionate rhetoric aimed at virtue signalling can clinch the deal for you. There were just too many reasons why the High Court ‘annulled’ the so-called marriage:

  1. The marriage certificate was not issued by competent authority
  2. Names on the questionable ‘marriage certificate’ were not matching with real names
  3. Court was kept in dark about the marriage even though a case was going on

Now here comes the question of free will. Given that Hadiya had submitted an affidavit that she is accepting Islam in her free will, should the state interfere in how she decides to live her life? Looking at isolation, absolutely no. However, looking at the matter in its entirety, the following questions arise:

  • Today she says she wants to complete her studies. But she left her studies midway to join a 6 month Islamic course which she continued only for 2 months.
  • The court trusted Sainaba as the guardian of Akhila. She should have at least informed the court that Akhila’s marriage is being considered. But she didn’t even inform her natural guardians i.e. her parents who are alive.
  • What is the role of PFI in this, given both Sainaba and Shafin Jehan draw allegiance to PFI? PFI is known to be a radical Islamic outfit having connection with Islamic terrorist groups, possessing arms, rioting, “Love Jihad” and cutting off hand of Prof. TJ Joseph for setting a ‘blasphemous’ question paper of Islamic prophet Mohammed. Kerala police and NIA have raided arms training camp conducted by PFI and Kerala govt has given affidavits in court that PFI members are involved in murders of RSS members in Kerala.
  • Shafin Jehan had connection with someone called Mansy Buraqui, who also belonged to PFI and was arrested by NIA for having connection with ISIS, beside Shafin Jehan himself has criminal charges on him. Shafin Jehan is also part of many WhatsApp group which are Islamic fundamentalist in nature.
  • In a similar case, another girl from Thiruvananthapuram Nimisha, had accepted Islam and became Fathima and married Isa, supposedly out of her free will. The court had dismissed her mother’s petition and later the girl with her husband left to Afghanistan to join ISIS.
  • Shafin had expressed interest in taking Akhila to Gulf, where he claimed to have find a job and given there was a confusion on the real name of Akhila/Hadiya/Aasiya, it would have become impossible to even trace her out had she been taken out of India. There are reports of girls taken out of the country after such conversions, having become untraceable.

    An observation by the court
  • These cases are not new to Kerala. In fact, forcible conversion by radicalising young minds is so rampant in Kerala that the High Court had asked government to frame suitable laws to stop “Love Jihad”.

Based on the history of this region, precedents and unanswered questions in this particular case, it will be foolish to look at the matter as a case of a girl marrying to an young man of another faith out of her free will. The matter is linked with internal security, and the courts are assessing all aspects.

One really has to be a fool to believe that an inter-faith marriage (well, technically it is not inter-faith when one of the adults convert and accept the same faith) is being questioned by the courts. There are tonnes of such marriages happening all around the country and courts are not bothered. This goes beyond the purview of freedom to practice one’s religion and free will.

No one (among those being heard by the Supreme Court, where lawyers like Kapil Sibal are arguing for Hadiya, who claims to earn 2000/- a month as house surgeon but is able to get Sibal and senior lawyers like Indira Jaisingh to argue for her) is objecting to an inter-faith marriage or free will. It is NOT the marriage that is being questioned but the consequences of one’s actions that is being looked at.

It is not a singular event. There is whole set of grey areas and precedents that has to be looked at. Recently, there was an intel report that ISIS may try to poison Sabrimala pilgrims by poisoning water in railway stations in Kerala. Kerala police has said that about 100 people from Kerala have joined ISIS over the years. Her husband and her former guardian Sainaba are PFI members which is believed to be the reincarnation of the banned Islamist outfit SIMI. With this background, the Kerala High Court noted that, “In the present state of affairs, it is absolutely unsafe to let Akhila [be] free to do as she likes.

Of course, free will is paramount but so is national security and internal security. Remember that even ‘preventive detentions’ technically go against the principle of ‘free will’ and liberty. However, our laws allow that and governments have used such laws more often than not. In fact, our activists themselves demand such restrictions to be imposed on various occasions.

If your free will has consequences on the national security, then sorry, your free will can not be yielded to — that’s how it is right now in India and many countries abroad, including in the US, considered to be the best when it comes to individual freedom and liberty. However, the matter is sub-judice and I will not like to pass a judgement. The court in its wisdom has asked NIA to look into the matter and I believe it is a step in the right direction.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

Farmer thanks PM Modi for mentioning him during Mann Ki Baat, narrates how the passage of Farm Bills helped him

PM Modi's Mann Ki Baat speech came just as the issue has been raked up once again as ‘farmers’ from Punjab and Haryana have marched towards Delhi to protest against the farm bills.

SFJ ads appear on YouTube offering $10m support for farmers, in return, wants Sikhs to join ‘Khalistan movement’: Details

Amid ongoing farmers’ protests in Punjab, Haryana, and Delhi, it is evident that Khalistani supporters have hijacked the protests and now, they are running ads on YouTube

A year after quitting Congress over ‘petty politics’, Urmila set to join Shiv Sena, to be nominated as MLC

Urmila Matondkar is expected to be nominated as MLC by the Shiv Sena led Maharashtra government

Indian man proposes to his Australian girlfriend during Ind vs Aus cricket match, here is what happened next

While India's performance has been below par, netizens found happiness in the unusual proposal that became the highlight of the match.

NIA refutes claims about ‘activist’ Stan Swamy’s straw and sipper seized by agency. Read details

NIA stated that when Stan Swamy's personal search was undertaken in presence of two independent witnesses no such straw or sipper was found on him as claimed by him.

France, Germany, UK and all other countries we should boycott for using water cannon and tear gas

As a newly woke nation, we also have a moral responsibility to oppose other countries that carry out atrocities such as using water cannons on protesters.

Recently Popular

Wife of late Wajid Khan writes on her sufferings in an inter-faith marriage, says anti-conversion law should be nationalised

Wife of late music composer Wajid Khan wrote how her husband and his family had been forcing her to convert to Islam after their marriage

Actor Deep Sandhu disappoints Barkha Dutt after she provides platform to ‘distance himself’ from OpIndia report that he supports Khalistan

Barkha Dutt lamented after actor Deep Sidhu refused to condemn Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and to call him terrorist on her YouTube channel

Who is the man in farmer protest video, lying about ‘govt snatching farmland’: Profile of an actor and Khalistan supporter

Khalistan supporter Punjabi actor Deep Sidhu has been seen spreading the lie that govt will snatch farmer's land using the new farm laws

‘Will not say Jai Hind, will teach lesson to Modi like we taught Indira’: Khalistani protester in presence of AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan

Sikh protester threatens to teach Modi a lesson in the save way they taught Indira Gandhi in the presence of AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan

Indian man proposes to his Australian girlfriend during Ind vs Aus cricket match, here is what happened next

While India's performance has been below par, netizens found happiness in the unusual proposal that became the highlight of the match.

As Iran vows to avenge their nuclear scientist Fakhrizadeh’s murder, read how 62-member squad planned and carried out his assassination

The killing of Fakhrizadeh is the latest in the serious high-profile assassinations of people belonging to Iranian regime since the assassination of General Qassem Soleimani.

Farmer thanks PM Modi for mentioning him during Mann Ki Baat, narrates how the passage of Farm Bills helped him

PM Modi's Mann Ki Baat speech came just as the issue has been raked up once again as ‘farmers’ from Punjab and Haryana have marched towards Delhi to protest against the farm bills.

Rebellion inside Rahul’s Congress grows, Anand Sharma defies party line, hails PM Modi for visit to Coronavirus vaccine hubs

A day after Congress criticised PM Modi's visit to Coronavirus vaccine hubs, senior Congress leader Anand Sharma has defied the party line

From support for zamindars to ‘protest will help overthrow Modi govt’: A saga of clueless people at farmer protest

A series of interview of protestors by the team of Know the Nation reveals how many of these protestors are completely clueless about why they are there

SFJ ads appear on YouTube offering $10m support for farmers, in return, wants Sikhs to join ‘Khalistan movement’: Details

Amid ongoing farmers’ protests in Punjab, Haryana, and Delhi, it is evident that Khalistani supporters have hijacked the protests and now, they are running ads on YouTube

President of farmer organisation says they will block all five entry points to Delhi because Burari park is an ‘open jail’: Details

The farmers protesting against the Modi government over new farm laws have rejected Union Home Minister Amit Shah’s proposal for a discussion on their grievances.

A year after quitting Congress over ‘petty politics’, Urmila set to join Shiv Sena, to be nominated as MLC

Urmila Matondkar is expected to be nominated as MLC by the Shiv Sena led Maharashtra government

‘Haven’t you seen how they cry, do ‘haye tauba’: Here is what Amit Shah said, responding to Owaisi’s comment about illegal Rohingyas

Amit Shah said when he takes action against Rohingyas and Bangladeshis back, leaders like Owaisi stand against him in Lok Sabha.

Indian man proposes to his Australian girlfriend during Ind vs Aus cricket match, here is what happened next

While India's performance has been below par, netizens found happiness in the unusual proposal that became the highlight of the match.

NIA refutes claims about ‘activist’ Stan Swamy’s straw and sipper seized by agency. Read details

NIA stated that when Stan Swamy's personal search was undertaken in presence of two independent witnesses no such straw or sipper was found on him as claimed by him.

France, Germany, UK and all other countries we should boycott for using water cannon and tear gas

As a newly woke nation, we also have a moral responsibility to oppose other countries that carry out atrocities such as using water cannons on protesters.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
490,968FollowersFollow
20,200SubscribersSubscribe