Tuesday, October 20, 2020
Home Media While talking about Muslims in Jammu, Karan Thapar diminishes massacre of Hindus and Sikhs...

While talking about Muslims in Jammu, Karan Thapar diminishes massacre of Hindus and Sikhs in Jammu and the KP exodus

Karan Thapar chooses to ignore the well-established fact that the tribal raids were planned and incited a month before the alleged atrocities of the State forces when Kashmir was peaceful. This was not a spontaneous reaction to save Muslim brethren from a fictional Dogra genocide.

Karan Thapar in his article “We cannot be selective about the past in Jammu & Kashmir” in Hindustan Times dated 15th Sept 2019, gives a call to morality, intellectual honesty and being conscious to multiple peoples and their identities. He further goes on to say that our memory becomes selective, it also becomes one-sided and that could divide us. We could end up a very different country to the one we want to be he adds. Since I agree with this I feel compelled to comment on his article and point out some glaring facts he has both missed and misrepresented.

My ancestral village of Bumnal, in Jammu district, is not too far from what is now the International Border and my father recounts the troubling times of Partition when he had to vacate his village. He distinctly remembers the journey because he as a 7-year-old refused to leave and only after a slap or two, mounted the horse my Grandfather had specially arranged for this forced exodus. In their absence, the village was burnt down along with its primary school. My father and his family relocated to Samba district and it took a few years before they made their way back to our ancestral village. Since this was an anomaly for a secular and pluralistic Jammu, it must be pointed out that ours was a Hindu village and the events an overspill of the bloody partition of India. A fact Mr Thapar missed in his remembrance of Jammu in 1947.

India Office Records Library in London corroborates the fact that at least till the end of September 1947 when communal disturbances gripped the sub-continent and even lead to disquiet amongst the people and administration of Kashmir, there was next to no animosity between the Hindus and Muslims, barring a few stray incidents in the Jammu Region.

The Records mentions and Prem Shankar Jha in his book Kashmir 1947- Rival Versions of History also makes a reference to the fact that though some atrocities were committed by bands of Sikhs and by some of the state troops in the border belts of Jammu Province in the first weeks of October it was an extension of and reaction to the communal carnage occurring along its borders in East and West Punjab and the atrocities committed on the Hindus within Jammu & Kashmir and in the adjoining areas of West Punjab.

Karan Thapar makes an unreasonable comparison of events related to the Partition in 1947 with what happened to the Kashmiri Pandits in 1990, effectively doing exactly what he professes of not doing, i.e diminishing the KP exodus. No atrocity can be justified and the atrocities committed in Jammu Kashmir in 1947 because of a bloody partition cannot be justified either. 

However false references to Jammu Massacres of 1947 and the suggestion that the atrocities were only committed against Muslims will also not go unchallenged. Karan Thapar’s pitch-perfectly colludes to the Pakistani version of the events of 1947. Pakistan justifies its attack on Jammu Kashmir based upon the propaganda that Hindu Dogra Maharaja Hari Singh wanted to cleanse his state of its 77% Muslim population so that he could accede the state to India. A preposterous lie which does not explain why the Maharaja did not first cleanse his own 8000 strong State Forces which comprised of 3000 Muslims and wait for them to betray and kill the Hindu officers before deserting and joining the enemy ranks on 22nd to 26th October.

Karan Thapar quotes Horace but forgets to mention the fortnightly reports sent from December 1946 to the end of June 1947, where the Crown’s representative to the Secretary of State for India on Kashmir Internal Conditions, Webb writes that there was nothing to report or that the communal situation was uneasy but that there had been no violence. Even Jinnah’ Direct Action Day caused no ripples in the Valley.  The only incident occurring in Jammu town on 21st September 1946, when a Hindu youth was stabbed to death. The following day three Muslims were also found killed similarly. There was a crackdown by administration after this incident. Webb refers to this incident and adds that the state government’s response was ‘ prompt and firm’. He even reports that despite the arrival of 2,500 Hindu and Sikh refugees from the tribal agency of Hazara in December 1946, there were no communal reactions. Of course, tragically most of these refugees fell victim to the very tribesmen they had escaped ten months later on October 1947.

Karan Thapar chooses to ignore the well-established fact that the tribal raids were planned and incited a month before the alleged atrocities of the State forces when Kashmir was peaceful. This was not a spontaneous reaction to save Muslim brethren from a fictional Dogra genocide. Major Gen Akbar Khan in his book Raiders in Kashmir details this planned invasion against Jammu and Kashmir, while also regretting a lack of local support. Amiss in Thapar’s references was the dispatch of 30 th March 1947, that Pir of Manki Sharif in the NWFP had sent his agent provocateurs to the frontier districts of the state to prepare the people for ‘holy crusade’. To uncritically accept the accounts of an Alistair Lamb, Snedden or a Richard Symond is where the intellectual dishonesty lies. Multiple accounts and reports like that of General Scott proves that quite contrary to the lies about a genocidal anti-Muslim Dogra Force, the State forces had done an exemplary job of looking after its own population alongside taking care of a quarter-million of refugees that had entered the state 

Since Karan Thapar rues selective memory and its dangers, important to point out the massacres of Hindus and Sikhs of Mirpur, Bhimber, Kotli, and the tribal agencies of Hazara where they were completely wiped out. The brutal killings and rapes of Sikh and Hindu men and women are hard to forget. Bal K Gupta in his personal memoir Mirpur Ki Traasdi – Vismrit Atyachar, recounts crossing the bridge over Jhelum, along with a fleeing Hindu and Sikh population and seeing many women jump off the bridge to avoid rape and kidnapping. His bone-chilling account of these mass suicides details how women shocked and robotic in their grief and fear first threw their children into the icy cold river and only after watching them completely drown, threw themselves off the bridge too. Bal K Gupta details how the local Muslim population of Mirpur city and adjoining villages joined this carnage and kidnapped Hindu women and killed their men. The author was one of the 1600 people who were rescued by the ICCR from Alibeg and repatriated to India. 

Poonch and Rajouri were no different from Mirpur. Col Rehmatullah Khan sent for Rajouri’s protection by Maharaja Hari Singh defected and joined the tribal raiders. He and Major Nasrullah killed the Gorkha sepoys of their own companies. Rajouri witnessed mass suicides by the Hindus by means of consuming poison, some in full public view. To avoid rape and kidnap of Hindu women, Rajouri witnessed chilling honour killings. Many women and children were abducted and sold in Kotli by raiders. 

Important to remember these forgotten Hindus and Sikhs of Jammu and Kashmir or as Karan Thapar rightly points out the memory would be one-sided and one-sided memory can never do justice to the truth. We can neither be selective nor untruthful about the past in Jammu and Kashmir. The census figures quoted by Karan Thapar if not completely untrue are at best projected and contentious. Limitations, inconsistencies and contradictions have marred the available census figures. Jammu city known as the City of Temples has never be known as a Muslim majority city but post-1947 has been known as the Refugee capital, home to POJK, West Pak and KP refugees. The influx of the Hindu and Sikh refugees in 1947 to Jammu city is reflected in the rise of Hindu population in the 1981 census.

It is Karan Thapar who in his hurry to toe the Pakistani version of the events in Jammu and Kashmir in 1947 has resorted to inflated and incorrect census figures, not taken into account the Pakistani invasion of Jammu and Kashmir and effectively murdered and insulted the massacres of Hindus and Sikhs in 1947 and then of the Kashmiri Pandits in 1989. The past must be remembered but remembered in all its entirety and truthfulness otherwise we become a very different country from what we want to be.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

The MP who was sentenced to death: In Bihar elections, Anand Mohan Singh’s wife and son are now RJD candidates

Son and wife of Anand Mohan Singh, first-ever MP to get death sentence, are contesting in upcoming Assembly Elections in Bihar

FT publishes damning investigation implicating China, WHO and their role in the spread of Coronavirus: Here are 7 takeaways

The Financial Times carried out an investigation about China's initial mismanagement and complacency that led to a global coronavirus pandemic

After Mumbai Police harasses Arnab Goswami, ex-cop Iqbal Shaikh approaches court to stop Republic TV from reporting on TRP scam: Read details

Iqbal Shaikh accused Arnab Goswami and Republic TV of engaging in a smear campaign against Mumbai Police.

Srinagar: Govt-allotted office building of Kashmir Times sealed by authorities 5 years after allottee’s death, current Exec Editor calls it ‘vendetta’

Estates Department informed that they just took possession of the property after serving notices to Kashmir Times to vacate the premises.

Times of India spreads fake news about PV Sindhu quitting national camp due to fall-out with family and coach: Here is the truth

Badminton world champion PV Sindhu has left the national camp meant for Olympic hopefuls and travelled to London to work on her recovery and nutrition.

Twitter first says Leh a part of China, then, they say technical glitch, gets it horribly wrong even after fixing it: Read how

Nitin A Gokhale found that the microblogging platform had not fixed the technical glitch, despite being well aware of the sensitivity around it.

Recently Popular

After Chinese phones blocking weather data for Arunachal and Ladakh, now Twitter shows Leh as part of China

Security analyst Nitin A Gokhale found that Twitter has labelled Leh in Ladakh as part of People's Republic of China (PRC)

During 26/11 Mumbai attack, Param Bir Singh refused to be on ground and take on terrorists, then Mumbai CP Hasan Gafoor had said

Hasan Gafoor, who was the Mumbai Commissioner of Police during the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks, had accused senior police officials, including Param Bir Singh of not taking on the terrorists.

In 2012 ‘out of town’ Salman Khan partied with Parambir Singh in Mumbai on day Bandra cops could not serve him Court summons for...

As reported by Mid-Day in 2012, Salman Khan and Parambir Singh were both found attending a Christmas party hosted by Sunny Dewan and his wife Anu Dewan in Mumbai. This when the Bandra cops claimed Khan was not in town.

Rajdeep Sardesai and India Today secure a gag order against social media user who had said they took 8 crores for Rhea interview

Issuing an order on India Today petition, the Delhi HC has ordered Twitter to suspend the man named Anurag Srivastava, and Google to remove the content from search results.

TimesNow joined the Left in condemning Republic TV to hell, now, the Left is gunning for them too

The 'TRP scam' started off when Mumbai Police Commissioner Parambir Singh named Republic TV and hid the fact that the FIR which was filed, based on the Hansa Research Report, named India Today

Anti-Trump legal analyst of CNN and The New Yorker contributor suspended after masturbating on Zoom call

Jeffrey Toobin has offered an apology for masturbating on the Zoom video call and said that he thought he had put the video and audio on mute.
- Advertisement -

The benign gibberish on AajTak: How a clueless anchor and a clueless journalist discussed how clueless they are

Since no news channel seem to have any prior information about the PM's message, Aaj Tak probably decided to share random sentences repeatedly.

Unless Mohua Moitra is a Hindu from Pakistan, her comment on CAA makes no sense: Here is how the TMC leader made a fool...

The Citizenship Amendment Act does not affect the Indian citizens but TMC MP Mahua Moitra said she would not furnish her papers for the CAA

The MP who was sentenced to death: In Bihar elections, Anand Mohan Singh’s wife and son are now RJD candidates

Son and wife of Anand Mohan Singh, first-ever MP to get death sentence, are contesting in upcoming Assembly Elections in Bihar

ISIS terror magazine calls to avenge Babri demolition, instigates Muslims to wage ‘Jihad’ against India

The digital publication named 'Voice of Hind' instigates Muslims to wage war against India to 'avenge' Babri.

Kamal Nath refuses to apologize despite Rahul Gandhi’s rebuke, suggests RaGa never understood the context of ‘item’ remark

Earlier too, Kamal Nath had brazened it out by saying his comment was distorted to deviate public discourse from 'main issues'

Captain Amarinder Singh tables resolution in Punjab Assembly to oppose Centre’s farm laws: Read details

Captain Amarinder Singh added that the farm laws, passed by the Parliament were against the Indian Constitution, as agriculture falls under State subject (Entry 14 List-II)

UP Police team returns empty-handed again after Punjab govt puts mafia don Mukhtar Ansari on ‘bed-rest’ for 3 months

Punjab govt cites medical problems for jailed don Mukhtar Ansari, avoids handing him over to UP police

Former adviser to Manmohan Singh, Pankaj Pachauri brazens it out after being caught spreading fake news about Indian trade with China

Pankaj Pachauri claimed Indian imports from China had increased by 27% during tension between the two countries at the LAC.

From DDLJ to IPL: Netizens come up with hilarious ideas about what PM Modi might say today at 6 PM in his address to...

PM Modi today announced on Twitter that he is going to address the nation at 6 pm today, sparking amusing responses from social media users.

Connect with us